3 ms·
> Science by definition can't be sexist. Of course. But depending on context the use and quoting of it sure can. I'm sure there is plenty of evidence of physic
by alkonaut 9y ago
> Science by definition can't be sexist.
Of course. But depending on context the use and quoting of it sure can. I'm sure there is plenty of evidence of physical difference betweeen races, and there are reasonable ways to use those scientific results - and there are racist ways of using them. Doesn't change that
> Second, the author didn't argue there are differences between genders or sexes that make one unsuitable for a given task.
Wow I read the whole thing (which is rare) and that was what really jumped out. I wonder what I misunderstood.
- monktastic1 9y agoAs one commenter pointed out, it may be something like the gold-and-white vs blue-and-black dress thing. It really behooves each side to try as hard as they can to read the other side's interpretation.
- dustinmoris 9y agoWell I can tell you exactly what you misunderstood: The English language. You are making shit up, because at no point in this whole memo did the author use the word "unsuitable" or "suitable" AT ALL. AT NO POINT. Yet, people like you constantly keep quoting him saying "genders or sexes that make one unsuitable for a given task". Go back to school, I am seriously losing tolerance with this stupidity. Enough is enough. Don't make up shit. Show me an exact quote where he says something sexist and explain it. Don't make sweeping lying statements like this.
- alkonaut 9y agoAs it has been made obvious I other parts of this thread, people even disagree on what sexism or racism is. Some argue that falsehood is required, for example. I use the definition that includes prejudice, stereotyping or discriminating based on gender, and irrespective of whether something is factual (I.e I do not subscribe to the idea that facts can't be sexist/racist). I apologize for reading the "unfit" between the lines - what jumped out at me as stereotypical was remarks such as women being more neurotical and having lower stress thresholds. I'm not going to argue the truth of it, and I won't argue whether that's sexist (for the reasons outlined above) - but it's definitely stereotyping women - fact or not.
- dustinmoris 9y agoHe mentioned Neuroticism as a characteristic which has been observered higher on average with women and cited it with a link to wikipedia which also makes the exact same statement, which again cites other scientific resources: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroticism Does that make Wikipedia sexist? Which one is sexist to you, or do you find both sexist: "Women have less stress tolerance" "Scientific studies show that Neuroticism, a personality trait which is related to less stress tolerance, is on average more common among women than men" There is a huge difference and if you don't see it, then I think all educational material, books, research, science, really anything is lost on you
- alkonaut 9y agoAgain: science and facts aren't sexist- the arguments and actions using those facts can in some cases be. That's why a single fact quote from the memo can't be sexist, but the memo can be, depending on who it's sent to, what arguments are made. Nothing will be racist or sexist without context. That is, for example why it's not racist for a black person to say something to another black person that would be racist if a white person said it. We are completely agreeing that facts alone are never sexist or racist. I'm not even sure what it would mean for a fact (or Wikipedia - which is a collection of facts) to be racist. It's not making an argument or action of any kind.
- cpncrunch 9y agoSo why exactly is it sexist? He argues that's google's method of achieving diversity is counter-productive and unfair, and he proposes some alternative ways of increasing diversity, which may work better. Doesn't really sound sexist to me.