5 ms·
As far as I could tell from the coverage (I couldn't get past the first few paragraphs of the memo), it asks for more diversity in terms of right-wing/conservat
by danpalmer 9y ago
As far as I could tell from the coverage (I couldn't get past the first few paragraphs of the memo), it asks for more diversity in terms of right-wing/conservative thinking, and for Google to stop encouraging women to apply.
On the surface – that's asking for both more and less diversity, however Google rejects the idea that conservative views (that are compatible with Google's HR policies) are discouraged, which would suggest there isn't more diversity needed there.
- UK-AL 9y agoI would think the author would encourage women to apply, but discourage making interview pass rates biased towards one group or the other.
- pconner 9y agoInterview pass criteria are not based on the gender/race of the candidate. The criteria are the same for all candidates for the same role. The goal of diversity/inclusion programs is to find more diverse candidates to interview in the first place. Edit: referring to Google specifically
- peoplewindow 9y agoDamore asserts that it is actually affected by gender. I used to be at Google. I heard the same thing from recruiters themselves. That a woman could fail an interview but still make it through to the next rounds. Their justification for this was like so: 1. This isn't discrimination because the final hiring decision by the committee takes into account all interviews, so the bar is equal at that point. 2. Our lawyers say this is totally OK. I heard this many years ago, when I first joined Google and was learning how to be an interviewer. It disquieted me a little but I didn't challenge it - I figured, if the lawyers say it's OK, then it's OK. And the logic that in the end, the final decision was unbiased was something I accepted. Well, I was young and naive. If men are being dropped and women are not, then more women will make it through to the final hiring decision than would naturally occur, that's the entire point of doing it. This is, in effect, a way to lower the bar for women - literally, men and women can jump to the same height and one will cross the bar and one won't, based on gender. That's what Damore meant when he said the bar was being lowered by reducing the false negative rate. Is it illegal? I have no idea. But it's definitely not fair on men.
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoThis is at odds with the claim that minority applications get a second pass. Even in the absense of discrimination, this provides a statistical advantage. There are also programs to find more applicants, but this isn't critical of those programs.
- danpalmer 9y agoUnfortunately not, Google does not bias pass rates towards groups, its diversity programs are about ensuring that more minorities apply, which is what the author was suggesting should be ended.
- peoplewindow 9y agoIt's very odd that you admit you didn't actually read the document. Does it cause you physical pain or something? You then judged it based on a bunch of re-tellings, believe it says something it doesn't and that this is somehow virtuous and worthy of proclamation. Kind of discouraging. It didn't say Google should stop encouraging women to apply. That's simply not true. It did say it should stop giving women specific non-encouragement based advantages, like letting them proceed even after failing an interview when a man would have been dropped. It also said lots of other things. Why don't you read it yourself, and then judge it based on that?
- stevenwoo 9y agoThere is an interview type where gender (or even attractiveness/height/race which can bias folks) is not taken into consideration - when orchestras have auditions with the candidates that perform behind a curtain. Obviously there is some component of interviewing for a technical position where one is attempting to assay the candidates suitability for the work environment that is not compatible with this, but it's a pretty foolproof method (if no one is cheating) of making sure the interview process is gender/race blind at that stage. Off the top of my head, this lead to more women being hired for orchestras.
- peoplewindow 9y agoThe problem Google has is not the interviewing process itself (mostly). The problem is recruiters are told to try and close the gender gap. They find various ways to do this that may or may not be legal, but are at least morally questionable, like "reducing the false negative rate" as he puts it by letting women take more interviews despite a failing performance, like active discrimination in favour of women (and thus against men) and so on and so forth. Even if interviewers had no idea who they were interviewing, which is possible but logistically awkward (Aline Lerner posted some data on this), the recruiters would know, and they're the ones making the decisions around how the recruiting process proceeds.
- gribben 9y agoDid you even read the memo? He explicitly asked to end the programs Google has set up to encourage more women and minority students to study Computer Science because they weren't a good use of resources. There is no lower bar or quota. All of the diversity programs he mentioned are to encourage more applications.
- monochromatic 9y agoThe coverage has been near-uniformly garbage. Read the memo and make up your own mind.
- EJTH 9y agoThe coverage has certainly been very disproportionate with what was actually written in the paper. Also I have yet to see a news outlet objectively giving references to the COMPLETE memo.
- EJTH 9y ago> I couldn't get past the first few paragraphs of the memo So you didn't read it? Because ... you were offended or because of practical reasons (like you are illiterate) ? I don't think that the memo asked for "less diversity" just not forced diversity, at least not the way it is forced at google. > , however Google rejects the idea that conservative views (that are compatible with Google's HR policies) are discouraged I have a hard time believing that since they already take a hard stance against their conservative users. Also have you seen some of the tweets from the opposite forces at google? I don't think so...