3 ms·
I saw -$9000/vehicle and 40,000 vehicles and thought, that's only $360 million of losses. At the scale of Uber, that's just a cost of doing business. It's half
by brudgers 9y ago
I saw -$9000/vehicle and 40,000 vehicles and thought, that's only $360 million of losses. At the scale of Uber, that's just a cost of doing business. It's half of what it paid for Otto, and probably less than 1% of the startup costs for producing self-driving vehicles.
To put it another way, $360 million one way or the other is noise on Apple's bottom line. It is 0.05 of the variation in GOOG market cap over the past five days (~$7 billion).
I'd bet it provided far more bang for the buck than $360 million spent on advertising...with more bang for the buck over online advertising being a four star lock. The interesting story of Uber's subprime leases is not the losses, but the predation on driver partners.
- tyingq 9y ago$360 million is, though, a substantial portion of their ~$3b/year of losses. If I were an investor, I might question how many of these types of decisions were driving losses. The model may depend on subsidizing rides, but there's no reason to bleed more than needed.
- brudgers 9y agoConcern over local losses at one company in an investment portfolio is what separates ordinary investors from the class of investors Uber allows to invest. The Saudi Sovereign Wealth Fund is not going to sweat this. The value of Uber is the distribution of possible outcomes weighted for probability. The worst outcome is $0 and that was accepted going in. The reason companies like Uber stay private is to keep out ordinary investors and for the ability to ignore the traditional haymaking of Wall Street analysts. All those subprime leases let Uber gain market and refine its product. The widely published per ride loss numbers reflect those leases because they are baked into the overall losses.
- charlesdm 9y agoAre there any metrics on how well these sovereign wealth funds are actually doing? I often see them making big bets, with some definitely paying off (e.g. Kingdom Holding and Twitter), but I wonder how well they do across the board.
- URSpider94 9y agoNot that they are doing badly, but to some degree they don't have to perform well to be successful. Their primary goal is to transform a currently-limitless stream of oil money into a sustainable source of wealth and income when the spigot turns off in a generation or two. Same for China overseas investments, it's a way to turn RMB-denominated cash into hard assets in democratic countries with stable political environments. Value-for-money comes second.
- charlesdm 9y agoThis is true. I had a friend, who pretty much built a shovelware game, talk a chinese publisher into doing a deal. He banked $200k. I don't even get how that deal even could be made. Hell, he didn't even understand it.
- L_Rahman 9y agoThe Chinese mobile gaming market is one of the hottest in the world right now. Tencent (the people who make WeChat) pull in USD $1BN each quarter just from games. There was and possibly still is a lot of dumb money in that space right now.
- brudgers 9y agoI don't expect to see them launching Gofundme pages: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuwait_Petroleum_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuwait_Petroleum_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saudi_Aramco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saudi_Aramco
- tyingq 9y agoI get the difference between private and public. Private investors, though, aren't universally hands off. I'm sure there's some level of bad decision making that trigger the Saudi fund to start probing. Maybe not this level, but there's a line somewhere.
- aetherson 9y agoUber had better hope that the startup costs of self-driving vehicles are a lot lower than $36B. They can't afford that.
- brudgers 9y agoUber spent $680 million on the Otto. GM spent $1000 million on Cruise Automation. Neither of these came with tooling and supply chains or production engineering. In the automotive industry, a billion gets some talent and potentially promising intellectual property, not vehicles on the road. Yes, I think the Otto purchase was a bigger waste of money than the subprime leases. On the other hand, it didn't wreck lives by treating people disposabley.
- aetherson 9y agoI mean, sure, but on the other hand $1B is 36 times lower than $36B. Maybe we're just talking in cross purposes. Obviously if you buy a million cars, you'll be spending tens of billions of dollars. I didn't mean that Uber was hoping to be able to roll out a massive worldwide fleet of driverless vehicles for under $36B. I meant that Uber has to demonstrate a mature technology and business model involving lets say thousands or tens of thousands of vehicles that people are actually paying for and that have unique advantages over their many competitors, for much less than $36B. If they can do that, they won't have any difficulty securing the financing to scale their fleet of vehicles up significantly. If they can't do that, and they can't do that for much, much, much less than tens of billions of dollars, then they're in a lot of trouble. I do think that we tend to get sloppy about large numbers. It feels like people hardly see any difference between $1B and $5B.
- brudgers 9y agoCars that are produced in the 1000's or 10,000's tend to run in the $100,000's [1] even when the costs are amortized over the total production of an established manufacturer where startup costs like site acquisition and robots and hiring are already sunk costs. To better explain, the difference between one and five billion is significant when its my money. But it is not a quantum difference in terms of ordinary automotive manufacturing. Tesla is fourteen years old, has raised billions of dollars and is not relevant at the global scale in terms of production or sales. [2] More importantly, Tesla's differentiation is not self driving technology, it is electric drive trains which have an automotive history going back to the 19th century. Tesla is able to draw on established power technologies and engineering expertise in the production of batteries and electric power systems. Just maybe it will be able to produce a few tens of thousands of $35,000 electric cars a year at some point. I think that the odds Tesla will be first with a full on self-driving vehicle with wide availability are pretty low...but given that it has been working on the idea for about a decade or so, much higher than Uber's ever were. [1]: To be clear, I am not talking about 2017 Camero's with green leather interior and cherry red paint. [2]: That's not to say it does not have potential to become so over the next fifteen years.