4 ms·
Why can't the memo be both sexist and science? Arguing that there are differences between genders that make one gender unsuitable for a task can be as scientifi
by alkonaut 9y ago
Why can't the memo be both sexist and science? Arguing that there are differences between genders that make one gender unsuitable for a task can be as scientific as you want, it's still sexist.
It's no different from doing the same but replacing gender with race - it's racist no matter how carefully and scientifically you worded it.
It's almost as if the person writing this article believes that if the manifesto is factually/scientifically correct then it must somehow not be sexist. As if sexism consisted of lies? I don't get it.
- lanevorockz 9y agoYou are reading things that are not written there, take a breath and read it without bias. It talks about predisposition and how when you look into a collective you observe differences.
- alkonaut 9y agoRight: I explained what I meant in another reply.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Why can't the memo be both sexist and science? Arguing that there are differences between genders that make one gender unsuitable for a task can be as scientific as you want, it's still sexist. http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/06/21/against-murderism/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/06/21/against-murderism/ Definition by motives vs. definition by belief.
- jazzyk 9y agoSo, as a male, should I sue someone who (correctly) points out that I cannot breastfeed for being "sexist", and for "perpetuating gender stereotypes"
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoAre you using definition by belief, as anybody probably ought not to do?
- blub 9y agoSexism relates to prejudices, discrimination. It's a negative word. And no one argued that an entire gender is unqualified for a task. Where do you come up with all this stuff?!?
- alkonaut 9y agoOK: let me rephrase - he argues that women (for example) have lower stress tolerance and are more neurotic, and that could be a reason for the lack of women at the top. He never says outright that these properties actually make women unfit for those jobs, however.
- jazzyk 9y agoYour analogy to race is wrong. There is no research (to the best of my knowledge) claiming that there are biological differences between the same sex of different races. But there is enough research about biological differences between sexes (and some differences are obvious, such as different hormones, etc) to at least warrant a debate. "Sexist" is one of a handful of words that have become absolutely sacred in the US, at the expense of scientific discovery (or common sense, or both).
- alkonaut 9y ago> There is no research (to the best of my knowledge) claiming that there are biological differences between the same sex of different races. I mean it's not controversial to argue that on average caucasian men are taller than asian men. I can't find a quotation for that exact fact right now but let's just assume it's true for the sake of argument. It's a toy example anyway. If it's scientific doesn't mean I can argue without repercussion that I should be allowed to cut before asian men in the line in the cafeteria because as tall people we are always hungrier. Even arguing that would (rightly) be considered racist. I tried to make a toy example but you get my drift - the use of a scientific fact in argument can be racist. Even if you don't agree with my toy example (either the made up fact or the toy argument) - would you agree that IF scientific argument is found that e.g. one race has less cognitive ability than another that might be "good science" (although ethically questionalble science) - that most uses of such facts e.g in arguments would in fact still be racist? Or do you still insist that scientific facts make all arguments and actions based on them non-racist?
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> If it's scientific doesn't mean I can argue without repercussion that I should be allowed to cut before asian men in the line in the cafeteria because as tall people we are always hungrier. Even arguing that would (rightly) be considered racist. Suppose that height is an advantage in basketball and we thereby discover that asian men are underrepresented in the NBA. Are you claiming that is racist and something we have to do something to change?
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoScience by definition can't be sexist. In science there is no place for prejudices, beliefs and biases - only facts. It's human attitudes interpreting these facts that can be sexist, racist and so on. Second, the author didn't argue there are differences between genders or sexes that make one unsuitable for a given task. That's one of the most gross and unfair misrepresentations of the memo.
- alkonaut 9y ago> Science by definition can't be sexist. Of course. But depending on context the use and quoting of it sure can. I'm sure there is plenty of evidence of physical difference betweeen races, and there are reasonable ways to use those scientific results - and there are racist ways of using them. Doesn't change that > Second, the author didn't argue there are differences between genders or sexes that make one unsuitable for a given task. Wow I read the whole thing (which is rare) and that was what really jumped out. I wonder what I misunderstood.
- monktastic1 9y agoAs one commenter pointed out, it may be something like the gold-and-white vs blue-and-black dress thing. It really behooves each side to try as hard as they can to read the other side's interpretation.
- dustinmoris 9y agoWell I can tell you exactly what you misunderstood: The English language. You are making shit up, because at no point in this whole memo did the author use the word "unsuitable" or "suitable" AT ALL. AT NO POINT. Yet, people like you constantly keep quoting him saying "genders or sexes that make one unsuitable for a given task". Go back to school, I am seriously losing tolerance with this stupidity. Enough is enough. Don't make up shit. Show me an exact quote where he says something sexist and explain it. Don't make sweeping lying statements like this.
- alkonaut 9y agoAs it has been made obvious I other parts of this thread, people even disagree on what sexism or racism is. Some argue that falsehood is required, for example. I use the definition that includes prejudice, stereotyping or discriminating based on gender, and irrespective of whether something is factual (I.e I do not subscribe to the idea that facts can't be sexist/racist). I apologize for reading the "unfit" between the lines - what jumped out at me as stereotypical was remarks such as women being more neurotical and having lower stress thresholds. I'm not going to argue the truth of it, and I won't argue whether that's sexist (for the reasons outlined above) - but it's definitely stereotyping women - fact or not.
- computerex 9y agoYou are confused about what sexism is. Sexism is a prejudice based on lack of evidence and reasoning. Saying that women are inferior to men is a sexist remark. Saying that on average, women prefer working in people oriented roles whereas men prefer working in mechanical/technical roles is not sexist, because this is a fact supported by real evidence. The author's point about societies with the most gender equity having bigger gender gaps really drives this point home. In societies where there is gender equity, people aren't compelled to behave a certain way and instead gravitate towards the roles they really want to take. Real, verifiable, reproducible truths are not sexist or racist. They are truths. The fact that the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalenjin_people#Sport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalenjin_people#Sport dominate sprinting is supported by empirical evidence and also science. So to be clear, racism and sexism are terms used to describe prejudices, lies and falsehoods about a gender or race. These terms shouldn't be used to describe real, empirically shown gender or race differences. We as humans are all equal in worth, but that doesn't mean we are all the same.
- alkonaut 9y ago> Sexism is a prejudice based on lack of evidence and reasoning. That's not a definition I have seen anywhere. The usual definition is that it's "prejudice, sterotyping or discrimination based on someones gender". If we have different definitions of sexism to begin with, of course we aren't going to agree on whether X is sexist. So if I don't use the controversial S word: I thought his post was stereotyping and coming out against anti discrimination efforts. > So to be clear, racism and sexism are terms used to describe prejudices, lies and falsehoods about a gender or race. Same again: something being true doesn't make it not racist (or sexist). The falsehood/lying isn't a necessary condition.
- dustinmoris 9y agoWhat on bloody earth are you talking about? Take a moment and listen to yourself, because what you say is exactly the hate speech that we are having today, where people take words of someone else and completely flip it around and claim something terrible which did not happen. > something being true doesn't make it not racist (or sexist). The falsehood/lying isn't a necessary condition. Of course it is! Seriously listen to yourself! If I say "The average 20 year old healthy person will be able to climb this mountain faster than the average 80 year old healthy person" then it is a fact based on science and DOES NOT make me a ageist, or does it? Now apply the same logic to the previous topic and listen to yourself again.
- monochromatic 9y agoReality isn't sexism.