4 ms·
> that software is "thing-oriented" rather than "people-oriented Yes, that is the dominant view. You may have a different opinion (which you haven't substanti
by mpweiher 9y ago
> that software is "thing-oriented" rather than "people-oriented
Yes, that is the dominant view. You may have a different opinion (which you haven't substantiated except by assertion), but that's just that, your opinion.
> without proof, that these observed differences are stable across cultures.
Actually, most of the studies that replicated these findings (with large effect sizes and very large sample sizes) were cross cultural.
I collected references here:
http://blog.metaobject.com/2017/08/the-science-behind-manifesto.html http://blog.metaobject.com/2017/08/the-science-behind-manife...
One of the most interesting finding (that's also been replicated), is that gender differences in these traits increase the more egalitarian the society. This is the exact opposite of what you'd expect if the differences were caused by cultural pressure.
> flimsy, embarassed to be that sloppy in an HN post..
Well, you just were.
EDIT: And even if he had been completely wrong, that doesn't make what he wrote ("We need more diversity, but we're doing it wrong") misogynistic in any way shape or form.
- rayiner 9y ago> Yes, that is the dominant view. You may have a different opinion (which you haven't substantiated except by assertion), but that's just that, your opinion. Whether the view is widely held has nothing to do with whether its supported by evidence. You can't claim to be making a scientific argument, when a major link in your chain of reasoning is nothing more than an appeal to preconception. > Actually, most of the studies that replicated these findings (with large effect sizes and very large sample sizes) were cross cultural. The studies don't show that occupational preferences are stable across cultures (and in fact they're not). The fact that places like China have much higher representation of women in STEM is a smoldering hole in the theory that these preferences are biological. > One of the most interesting finding (that's also been replicated), is that gender differences in these traits increase the more egalitarian the society. This is the exact opposite of what you'd expect if the differences were caused by cultural pressure. That conflates two different things: what gender roles a society imposes on adults, and how the society socializes children. Those two things are not necessarily linked. Take India for example: it's not very egalitarian; women are still strongly encouraged to stay home with kids (and the work force is 70% men). On the other hand, half of STEM majors in India are women. How do you explain that result if you assume that preferences are biological?
- likpok 9y ago> That conflates two different things: what gender roles a society imposes on adults, and how the society socializes children. Those two things are not necessarily linked. Take India for example: it's not very egalitarian; women are still strongly encouraged to stay home with kids (and the work force is 70% men). On the other hand, half of STEM majors in India are women. How do you explain that result if you assume that preferences are biological? Presumably because they're not free to choose what they would prefer, and instead do what their family expects of them. Of course, we're getting back into your "women make a choice because they've been socialized to make it" territory here, which I find pretty convincing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mpweiher 9y ago> You can't claim to be making a scientific argument, > when a major link in your chain of reasoning is > nothing more than an appeal to preconception. "Gendered Occupational Interests: Prenatal Androgen Effects on Psychological Orientation to Things Versus People There is considerable interest in understanding women’s underrepresentation in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics careers. Career choices have been shown to be driven in part by interests, and gender differences in those interests have generally been considered to result from socialization. We explored the contribution of sex hormones to career-related interests, in particular studying whether prenatal androgens affect interests through psychological orientation to Things versus People. We examined this question in individuals with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH), who have atypical exposure to androgens early in development, and their unaffected siblings (total N = 125 aged 9 to 26 years). Females with CAH had more interest in Things versus People than did unaffected females, and variations among females with CAH reflected variations in their degree of androgen exposure. Results provide strong support for hormonal influences on interest in occupations characterized by working with Things versus People." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3166361/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3166361/ "To sum up: I think there is more than "a shred of evidence" for sex differences that are relevant to statistical gender disparities in elite hard science departments. There are reliable average difference in life priorities, in an interest in people versus things, in risk-seeking, in spatial transformations, in mathematical reasoning, and in variability in these traits. And there are ten kinds of evidence that these differences are not completely explained by socialization and bias, although they surely are in part." Steven Pinker - https://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/debate05/debate05_index.html https://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/debate05/debate05_index.htm... UPDATE: But actually, that does not really matter. His argument was that because there are differences we cannot rule out the possibility that unequal outcomes may have causes other than discrimination, not that he had proof that these differences are the cause.