3 ms·
Perhaps if some one of his fellow men had engaged with Rodgers, not in agreement but with the modicum of respect required to have an honest conversation, he mig
by throwanem 9y ago
Perhaps if some one of his fellow men had engaged with Rodgers, not in agreement but with the modicum of respect required to have an honest conversation, he might have been diverted from the course that led him to murder.
Perhaps it might also be worth reserving implicit equation with a murderer for people who have, you know, also killed someone. To the best of my knowledge, Damore has not done so. One also generally finds, in the cases where manifesto and murder coincide, the latter tends to precede rather than follow the former into the public eye.
One might surmise from this that it may make a
difference in outcome whether or not people feel themselves to be heard. I'm not sure that's accurate, and certainly don't imagine it would be so in all cases, but the idea doesn't seem too outré to me. But perhaps I'm merely being foolish in the suggestion.
- norea-armozel 9y agoEthics and common sense states no one is owed a hearing or respect from strangers beyond the bare minimum to be left alone. Rodgers had no excuse for murdering anyone for any reason. To attempt to rationalize his actions is to assume people who do no harm deserve to die.
- throwanem 9y agoI don't believe I have attempted to rationalize his actions, or to claim he was owed a hearing. I have said that, had he found one anyway, he might not have gone and done what he did. It's of a piece with the opinion, which I strongly hold and have yet to see reason to do otherwise, that the answer to erroneous speech is not less speech but more speech. Hatred is easy and satisfying in the short term. Engagement is hard, and often unsatisfying over any span of time you care to choose. But answering hatred with hatred only adds more hatred to the world. Answering hatred with engagement offers a chance of some more beneficial outcome. But I appreciate not everyone sees the matter as I do.
- norea-armozel 9y ago"...that the answer to erroneous speech is not less speech but more speech..." This is where I think you're completely wrong. I don't talk to someone who sees me as subhuman or irrational because I'm transgender since the vast majority of the time these folks have already concluded that since I'm subhuman and/or irrational that my arguments are invalid. Trying to break through their mental barriers as erected is like trying to dredge the Panama Canal with a tea spoon. Meaning you can do it but it's impractical. So instead of trying to engage folks that already made up their minds it's better to engage folks that are asking honest (even if insensitive) questions. Those are the folks that are worth arguing with because they're not entirely settled on an issue. But fanboys, true believers, kooks, and apologists aren't worth it by any measure. I say this as someone who's been on both sides of the fence so I have a decent understanding of the tactics employed to stay fixed in ones beliefs. I know this offends many a believer in the "market place of ideas" but reality doesn't bend to the idealism of the naive. Reality has to be obeyed to be mastered.
- throwanem 9y ago> I don't talk to someone who sees me as subhuman or irrational because I'm transgender since the vast majority of the time these folks have already concluded that since I'm subhuman and/or irrational that my arguments are invalid. Sure. Same with Rodgers and women. That's why I phrased my original comment as I did: "Perhaps if some one of his fellow men had engaged with Rodgers..."
- norea-armozel 9y agoAgain that wouldn't have worked. As someone who's been down the rabbit hole of ultra conservatism of the 1990s I speak from my own experience but I believe it's one that gets into the basic structure of all extremist views. 1. Extremists are already convinced of their position. To them it's their mission to convince you one way or another (often by dishonest means). 2. Extremists use the notion of free speech to broaden their access to an audience even if that audience is not receptive (no attention like negative attention). Especially since it convinces them of their position if the audience is overtly hostile to their views. 3. Extremists rarely, if ever, analyze their beliefs. Those that do inevitably cease to persist in those beliefs or at very least moderate them significantly. So the only person that could have ever convinced Rodgers to not murder is Rodgers. Extremism is basically a crude coping mechanism that inevitably harms the person who holds it (but as a consequence it harms everyone else around them). In fact, I'd say that an extremist has a similar set of maladaptive traits as a heroin or meth addict. The difference being they're not biologically addicted to their beliefs, they're merely addicted to the feeling of specialness and their outsider status.