2 ms·
Molyneux is pretty indefensible, yeah - not because he's outside mainstream opinion, but because he is a severely tendentious reasoner with a nasty habit of pic
by throwanem 9y ago
Molyneux is pretty indefensible, yeah - not because he's outside mainstream opinion, but because he is a severely tendentious reasoner with a nasty habit of picking call-in guests for the weakness of their arguments, the better to dominate the conversation and make his own ideas look unassailable. In any context where he doesn't get to pick his own opponents in debate, I confide he'd get owned in very short order - which I suspect is why he is so hard to find in such contexts.
Disagreement with the prevailing orthodoxy is one thing - I'd like to hope there's no one here who fails to see the value in honorable, substantive dissent, even from an orthodoxy with which one strongly agrees in general. The trouble with Molyneux is not that he dissents, but that in doing so he fails to display either of those meritable traits.
- beaconstudios 9y agovery true. He also seems to have been pandering to his newly found audience of authoritarians too which is an odd position for a proclaimed libertarian. Plus the old "not an argument" line that he throws around a lot.