3 ms·
There'll no doubt be many responses along this line but... > There is a longstanding right to "freedom of speech" ...is only true in certain limited circumsta
by zimpenfish 9y ago
There'll no doubt be many responses along this line but...
> There is a longstanding right to "freedom of speech"
...is only true in certain limited circumstances, all pertaining to the government (fed, state, local), I believe.
You do not, generally, even in the USA, have a right to "freedom of speech" wherever you are. And you definitely don't have "free (from consequences) speech" anywhere.
- Chris2048 9y agoSince I'm not American, I'll leave this one for others. But, I'd ask what "freedom from consequences" means? There are certain consequences arising from free speech that are, in some sense, protected. Can I (as a non-government entity) fire someone for choosing a certain religion, for example? Wouldn't that be a "consequence" of their choice?
- zimpenfish 9y ago> Can I (as a non-government entity) fire someone for choosing a certain religion, for example? Yes. Can you do it without consequences to yourself? No, because that is almost certainly a protected case in law.
- Chris2048 9y agoThen I'm not sure what your point is. "freedom" in this context usually relates to the law. As such "freedom to X" usually implies the legal framework to support X. If you are saying "freedom to X doesn't mean no legal consequences" then the phrase would be meaningless.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> "freedom" in this context usually relates to the law. Then where is the "a right to freedom of speech" enshrined in the law? The USA doesn't have that - only limited protection from the government. The UK certainly doesn't.
- Chris2048 9y ago> only limited protection from the government ^ Here, this is it.