5 ms·
The word existed before digital content. By your own logic; corporate protectionism is also harmful to others, so that is wrong too?
by Chris2048 9y ago
The word existed before digital content. By your own logic; corporate protectionism is also harmful to others, so that is wrong too?
- coldtea 9y ago>The word existed before digital content. So? Words get revised when society/technology/etc changes. Besides copyright existed before digital content too.
- Chris2048 9y ago> Words get revised In this case, society adopted the word "piracy" to represent the new semantic, whereas the recording industry chose "stealing" so as to conflate the issue. The word war is not a neutral process. > copyright existed before digital content too And it's application in modern times is increasingly contrived and outdated. Since when was it decided that mandatory "remastering" was a reasonable condition to repay for a media all over again? Why would I have to pay additional fees just to use a different medium (mobile phone vs laptop, for example).
- coldtea 9y ago>In this case, society adopted the word "piracy" to represent the new semantic, whereas the recording industry chose "stealing" so as to conflate the issue. The word war is not a neutral process. No, but it's also not as clearcut as "society uses piracy / recording industry chose stealing". If anything, the recording industry refers to piracy all the time. >And it's application in modern times is increasingly contrived and outdated. From a consumer standpoint? Because it's meant to protect creators, not consumers. >Why would I have to pay additional fees just to use a different medium (mobile phone vs laptop, for example). Because the seller sets the price. People can pay it or not use the product. It happens with everything else.
- Chris2048 9y agoYes, but "piracy" seems to have stuck. "Stealing" I'd consider non-neutral. > Because the seller sets the price But I already paid. The seller is also asking to control the medium. That does not happen with everything else. In fact, there has been a creep toward control in the hands of distributers (e.g. Amazon deleting recalled ebooks off the devices they sold to you). This isn't just a case "seller has product, seller sets price". The landscape of available products is being purposefully manipulated to expand the number of different products that exist e.g I'd consider a digital movie file to be one 'product', independent to whatever medium I choose to play it on; But the movie industry might advocate for a separate 'product' per medium. At that point it's not even related to the original "artist"/creator or their compensation - I'm now dealing with middlemen actively lobbying to create new forms of compensation, and restricting the ways in which I can access certain services without them. In the example I gave above, "remastering" is an excuse to charge for the same product on a different medium. There might be compensatory charges on top of DVDs that go to offset piracy, but there will never be compensation for consumers who already bought a film on a different format (VHS, for example) - the advantage only ever goes one way, so I don't care what narratives industry lawyers care to craft - piracy provides a necessary pressure to prevent consumers being taken advantage of even more.
- coldtea 9y ago>But I already paid. The sellers set what is being sold too. They can set it to be e.g. "I sell the ability to see just 1 minute of my 10 hour movie, only in black and white, with mono sound for $1000, only once" if they so wish. >I'd consider a digital movie file to be one 'product', independent to whatever medium I choose to play it on; But the movie industry might advocate for a separate 'product' per medium. So, isn't that to their discretion? The question is rather: why are buyers so desperate for those things in the first place. They could have boycotted the whole thing. But buy buying and/or pirating them despite such terms (e.g. only in DVD), they show there's value to what the sellers are trying to sell. (Note: not entirely my personal preferences on the subject, playing the devil's advocate)
- 9y ago