3 ms·
Here's the book, it's an interesting premise. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Accomplishment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Accomplishment Murray
by canoebuilder 9y ago
Here's the book, it's an interesting premise.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Accomplishment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Accomplishment
Murray ranks the leading 4,000 innovators in several fields of human accomplishment from 800 BC to 1950. In each field Murray identifies a number of sources (leading encyclopedias, histories and surveys) providing information about the leading figures in the field. The rankings are made from information in these sources. A raw score is determined based on how many sources mention and on how much space in each source is devoted to a person. Then these raw scores are normalized so that the lowest score is 1 and the highest score is 100. The resulting scores are called "Index Scores".
The book obviously wasn't written with the express purpose of saying "black people have never contributed anything of any worth to music." That's such a ridiculous mischaracterization, as if that was purpose of writing the book, geez...
It's interesting that you and many others trotting out obvious falsehoods these past few days think this is a wise strategy...
It's far more interesting to write about people that have done interesting, impactful, world-changing things. And that's what he wrote about, he didn't set out to write nor did he write the most boring book he could write, he wrote an interesting book about interesting people, actions, and ideas.
If the book doesn't have enough "diversity" for your taste,
No written language was ever devised in sub-Saharan Africa prior to outside influences.
There is no indigenous tonal music tradition in sub-Saharan Africa, apart from maybe singing. The only instruments native to the continent are unpitched percussion.
The wheel was never invented in Africa.
Sometimes reality is just reality.
- michaelchisari 9y ago> The only instruments native to the continent are unpitched percussion. Talking drums, djembes, balafons, xalams, koras.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoHow many books about rich, white, christian men being genetically, culturally and morally better than those that don't fall into those groups does someone need to write before your crank detector goes off?
- anon12345690 9y agoso basically the more you read about reality, the more you disbelieve it because it cant possibly be true?
- dang 9y agoThis comment is beyond the pale. If you post like this again, we will ban you. You've also been uncivil many times on HN. Please fix this as well if you want to keep commenting here.
- Cozumel 9y ago>'No written language was ever devised in sub-Saharan Africa prior to outside influences.' Is just plain wrong, see ( https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1nz7k6/were_there_no_native_written_languages_in/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1nz7k6/were_... ) also it depends on what you mean by language, Genevieve Petzinger has shown a fully formed written cave art language going back since man (or woman) first started drawing in caves.
- virgilp 9y agoSee, that's exactly what I expect as a rebuttal (the claim sounded fishy to me as well). The bad way to address it would be to say "that's a very racist thing to say, you white supremacist!".