4 ms·
You see no evidence that an operating system for a mobile device is not their core competency? Clearly, determining core competencies is not one of yours. :-)
by kenjackson 16y ago
You see no evidence that an operating system for a mobile device is not their core competency? Clearly, determining core competencies is not one of yours. :-)
- philwelch 16y agoI think you snuck in an extra negation that I didn't and turned my sentence around, so now I don't know if either of us knows what the other meant! Me: "I see no evidence mobile phones are in any way even close to Microsoft's core competency" "in any way" and "even close to" are non-negating modifiers we can remove, so: Me: "I see no evidence mobile phones are Microsoft's core competency" You: "You see no evidence that an operating system for a mobile device is not their core competency?" (pronoun and noun substitution) Me: "phil sees no evidence that an operating system for a mobile device is Microsoft's core competency" You: "phil sees no evidence that an operating system for a mobile device is not Microsoft's core competency?"
- kenjackson 16y agoMy bad. Trying to be cute. Let me actually attempt to give a little evidence, since you claim to have none. First, if you think MS has no core competency or that software is not one of them, then we could end the discussion right here. But otherwise, it seems clear to me that mobile OS software is among their core competencies. I start with the premise that operating systems are one of their core competencies. They have sold more units of OSes than any other company (or among the top 3). They employ probably the most renowned set of OS experts (David Cutler, of Vax VMS and NT fame. Rick Rashid, who did mach, the kernel that OS X is built on, Butler Lampson and Chuck Thacker, Turing Award winner for their work in operating system. Leslie Lamport, etc...). Now you may say, "but they have no experience with mobile OSes". Except they were one of the first companies to do a mobile phone operating system. They also do operating systems for kiosks, embedded systems, and of course desktops and servers. And while Windows Mobile is not a popular OS, the reason is not the OS itself. It's the shell that is problematic. The underlying OS is solid, and is being used in Windows Phone 7. They need a new shell and app deployment model, but they aren't going in and ripping out the kernel. And from people who have used it, they say the OS in WP7 is snappy. IMO the company has 3 core competencies: OSes, Dev Tools, and Business Productivity sw. They have some secondary ones: Online Services and Video Gaming. In summary, I think for them to give up in a space where they've actually produced a solid code base over the past decade, just when the space is now showing it can generate profit seems absurd.
- philwelch 16y agoMicrosoft has the technical chops for OS's, no doubt. The business chops to introduce and push device platforms is iffy--they got XBox through, but against weak competition and with very high expense. Apple and Google are much stouter competition than Sony and Nintendo and have significant advantages over Microsoft, not least among them the fact that Google has completely undercut Microsoft's traditional point of entry in the OS market (the low cost commodity OS). Since Xbox, Microsoft can't get a decent offering together until well after the real competition and growth stage in the market is over. It's not like IE where they can leverage their desktop monopoly and deliver a compelling product 2-3 years after the competition and clean up--lately they're only really competing 4-8 years too late, in markets where their dominance in other markets gives them no advantage and their competitors have already moved on to newer, higher-growth markets. Maybe if they weren't spread too thin and were focused on Windows Phone 7 as much as Apple was focused on iPhone years ago and it was still 2008 or 2009, but none of these conditions are true. And they're not likely to become true in time to affect this particular project.
- rbanffy 16y ago> Microsoft has the technical chops for OS's, no doubt. Kind of. How many really good OSs they made? DOS 4? Windows classic? Windows 3? Windows NT? Out of that list, only the VMS-inspired NT could be called cutting edge. It had a microkernel-ish architecture with multiprocessing, multithreading and security wired in from day one. And they hired the NT team out of DEC. I have great respect for the SQL Server team. Even after diverging from Sybase, it matured nicely and is a very good database server, comparable to MySQL and PostgreSQL. ;-)
- philwelch 16y agoThey still have the NT folks, and I hear MS Research has done promising things as well.
- jolan 16y agoTheir main problem is that their release cycles are too long across all of their product lines. It takes a year for Microsoft to release a minor revision to Windows Mobile 6. In a year, Apple releases a major revision to iOS. Google releases multiple revisions to Android. It also took them 2.5 years to release Windows 7 to essentially fix Vista which should have been way better considering XP came out 5 years before Vista. Meanwhile Apple and Google have been continuously innovating and iterating. When they did try to rush to market with the Xbox 360, they ended up having to take a $1B charge to repair the shoddy hardware.
- evilduck 16y agoI would also agree that it's not their core competency. Four to five years is a terrible product response time from a company with an existing codebase and the financial means to improve it. Apple/RIM/Google ate their lunch because they sucked at mobile products.