5 ms·
I think you're partially right. The other half of the puzzle is negotiating leverage. One of Warren Buffett's annual reports (I forget which year, but I think
by nostrademons 9y ago
I think you're partially right. The other half of the puzzle is negotiating leverage.
One of Warren Buffett's annual reports (I forget which year, but I think it was the late 1990s) had an interesting observation: inflation doesn't affect all firms equally. Instead, it pools where there is a competition bottleneck. If you are the monopoly provider in a market, you have complete and total ability to raise prices in response to your customers having more money available to pay. If you are in a very competitive market, then every time you try to raise prices, some other entrant undercuts you and your customers and suppliers capture the surplus instead.
The Fed, however, measures inflation based on a basket of goods bought by the "average" consumer. Most of these goods are in competitive markets: groceries and gas and consumer electronics. And so the measured inflation rate that the Fed uses to control the money supply significantly undercounts the true inflation rate, with much of the money injected into the economy pooling in differentiated industries like high finance, elite universities, health care, Google & Facebook, etc. From there, it doesn't circulate the way it should, because people in those industries need few goods that the average American produces. Instead, it goes into asset prices, as they try to buy up more future earning potential.
I've suspected that maybe a simple way to fix this would be with "helicopter" Bernanke's crazy idea: drop money out of helicopters. Maybe not literally (imagine the fights on the ground!), but perhaps the Fed could inject money into the economy at the bottom, through direct deposit into consumer's bank accounts or tax refunds, and then collect it from the top, through fees on banks. That way, the money is immediately spent, and so the true effect of the money injected is more easily measurable in the CPI.
- JamesBarney 9y agoHow would you describe the "true" inflation rate if not by the what the average person buys? It seems like you have a lot of different prices in the economy, and if all prices stay the same, except milk goes up 20% and yachts fall 20%. How much has inflation changed? You have to pick some way to weigh the prices. And it seems to me that the best way to do this is weigh them by how much the average consumer is spending on them.
- Retric 9y agoPeople still pay for hedge fund managers time, they just do this indirectly via 401k fees. Rather than look at some mythical 'the average person' you need to look at total spending because there is a lot of indirect spending going via corporations and the government.
- resu_nimda 9y agoThat sounds essentially like Basic Income, depending on how it's doled out. Especially with the rise of automation "taking all our jobs," it seems like some form of this is inevitable. But of course things will probably have to get much worse before our culture starts accepting the idea (despite the fact that statistically it will directly benefit most of the people).
- jpster 9y agoSome observers argue that basic income has been tried in the past and failed. https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2015/01/the-failure-of-a-past-basic-income-guarantee-the-speenhamland-system.html https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2015/01/the-failure-of-a-pas...
- resu_nimda 9y agoInteresting article. One key difference is that this was done before/during the Industrial Revolution, so it was probably too early. The amount of human labor it takes to provide basic needs for one human is an important factor. For example: It was intended as an emergency measure to help the poor when grain prices had risen sharply due to meager harvests. Today we can produce so much food we have to come up with creative ways to keep it valuable - subsidies, dumping it, etc. We've "lost" a ton of agriculture jobs since that experiment was tried, because we can do it with less people. Seems reasonable to transfer those gains back to the people instead of all of them going to the guy that owns the harvester.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoWhat the Fed does is actually worse (and more dishonest): they deliberately make "hedonic" or "quality adjustment method" adjustments that push down the inflation rate even more. I find/believe shadowstats.com to be more accurate than the gov't stats on inflation and unemployment.
- SilasX 9y agoI keep bringing it up, since it's the most egregious use of that logic, the time that the Fed insisted inflation must be low because the new iPads have faster CPUs[1]. As if a better quality luxury good (whose faster CPU is almost entirely eaten by new bloat) somehow cancels out higher food, healthcare, education, and housing costs. Interestingly, they never seem to adjust inflation upward because of product debasements (other than price per unit in a bundle), so that seems to bias the numbers. [1] http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-fed-dudley-ipad-idUSTRE72A4D520110311 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-fed-dudley-ipad-idUSTR...
- candiodari 9y agoThey are rich: > Dudley tried to explain how the Fed sees things: Yes, food prices may be rising, but at the same time, other prices are declining. The Fed looks at core inflation, which strips out volatile food and energy costs, to get a better sense of where inflation may actually be heading. Guess exactly when food and energy costs were declared volatile. If you thought "when they went up" you'd be right. If you disregard those actual inflation is 5%.
- utexaspunk 9y agoOur top marginal tax rate starts around $418k(single) to $470k (joint). It seems ridiculous to me that every dollar beyond that amount is taxed at the same rate, whether it's dollar 500k or dollar 500m. IMHO, we should have several more brackets, like for the top 0.25%, 0.1%, 0.01% and 0.001% of incomes, with the rates rising sharply. Tax the shit out of the ultra-rich and spread it around.
- bcherny 9y agoI agree with that (you're talking about Piketty's direct redistribution), but there is a tinge of "tax the other guy more because he's making more than me and it's not fair and I'll never be in his bracket anyway so I won't have to deal with it" to your argument.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- NTDF9 9y ago>> it's not fair and I'll never be in his bracket anyway so I won't have to deal with it And he wouldn't be in my bracket so he doesn't have to deal with struggles either.
- utexaspunk 9y agoIt's more like "tax the guy whose work is being disproportionately rewarded in comparison to everyone else". I wouldn't argue with the idea of a doctor making more than a dishwasher, or possibly even a good hedge fund manager making more than a doctor. But 1,000 times more? No way!
- jstanley 9y agoFortunately, this isn't communism and you're not a dictator. People aren't awarded money arbitrarily... Nobody will pay you more than you're worth. If a good hedge fund manager is able to make 1000x as much as a good doctor, he is worth 1000x as much as a good doctor, by definition, no matter how distasteful that might seem.
- norea-armozel 9y agoSo you're referring to the Cantillon(sp?) effect? Just asking for clarification.
- nostrademons 9y agoI'm unfamiliar with the Cantillon effect, but from a quick glance at Wikipedia and the Mises Wiki, it looks like he basically anticipated Friedman's monetarist theory a few centuries early? That's a little different; it doesn't touch on the differences in competitiveness between different industries (I guess there weren't really different industries in Cantillon's time), and instead is more concerned about the response of the balance of trade to changes in the money supply.
- mizchief2 9y agoI don't really support artificial cash injections into the system, but I do agree that if you are going to do that, doing so from the bottom vs. the top will create a greater lasting effect, or at least benefit more people in the short term after a major and sudden recession. Imagine where we would be if instead of baling out the banks after 2008, letting those banks fail and forgiving the loans they held. Millions of Americans owning their houses free and clear as well a having an extra few thousand dollars a month to spend or save.
- maxsilver 9y ago> measures inflation based on a basket of goods bought by the "average" consumer. Most of these goods are in competitive markets > I've suspected that maybe a simple way to fix this would be (snip) to drop money out of helicopters. Wouldn't a simple way to fix this, be to change the relative importance of the "basket of goods" so that it reflects what real people actually spend money on? Because housing, healthcare, and daycare/education when totaled should probably be 60-75+% of that basket, since that's where most people's money actually goes. Based on this - https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/cpi.pdf https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/cpi.pdf - the percentages the Fed currently uses seems far, far too low. The cost of gasoline going up 50%, or the cost of laptops going up 50% is far less hurtful than say, the cost of rent going up 50%, or the cost of healthcare going up 50%. I suspect if we used realistic numbers for inflation cost calculations, we'd see the real rate is far higher than is currently claimed, which would help economists better understand why so many people are suffering so much under a "good" economy.
- nostrademons 9y agoThe challenge is that this is non-uniform across social classes. The poor spend a large portion of their income on groceries, gas, rent, and basic necessities. The middle-class spend a large portion of their income on health care and education, which many poor people don't spend anything on because they can't afford it. The rich spend a large portion of their income on asset purchases like stocks and real estate. The Fed already tries to adjust the basket of goods to reflect what real people spend their money on. The problem is that the average dollar is not reflective of the average person. Dollars are concentrated among the rich; that's what inequality means. The rich spend their money on asset purchases like buying stocks, real estate, and businesses. To my knowledge, asset prices are not included in the CPI at all. If all the money that the Fed pumps into the economy ends up being concentrated in Facebook and then is used to buy Whatsapp for $19B, that doesn't count as inflation at all. So they keep pumping money into the economy, it keeps going to the 1%, asset prices keep rising, and the rich get richer while the poor get nothing.
- jjt-yn_t 9y agoA deeply systemic problem, for which I envy the rich not for the wealth but for the poor "sort of coerced" into spending UNWISELY on unhealthy foodstuffs, ... ..., the middle class "sort of coerced" into spending UNWISELY on non-disclosed health care costs and no-opt-out conformance, for example, with rules placed on their activities from afar not fathomed nor foreseen in the 1800's, driving up costs AND worries, and in many areas, also rent and high housing costs, and unread-then-INTO-LAW legal code that if voted on by the people might not stand the light of day. Atop of this, the overweight problem compounding healthy solutions vs 'more hours of the day seated to determine one's I's are dotted and T's are crossed' vs, say, if the tax code was an excise tax, ONLY, for individuals, below the 90th percentile, and vs if only OPT IN health insurance existed, meaning church-based or some such would take up the slack, and other divergences between the 1800's and the modern 'sit before the TV desks and create solutions' vs the more sanguine 1930's 'sit on the back patio and craft among-neighborhood-fathers solutions', the latter made extinct by ring-ring and switch one channel solution to another channel solution. C 2017 all rights reserved, if I could. [ rent ]
- ehnto 9y ago> but perhaps the Fed could inject money into the economy at the bottom, through direct deposit into consumer's bank accounts or tax refunds The Australian Government did just this during the Global Financial Crisis, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudd_Government_(2007%E2%80%9310)#Economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudd_Government_(2007%E2%80%93... It included a lot of measures, such as an increase in infrastructure spending and tax cuts, but one of the most interesting was the $950 AUD outright cash payment to individuals earning less than $80,000 AUD a year. Australia did not feel the Global Financial Crisis nearly as much as other countries, and it is argued that the stimulus package was a big part of that. There are concerns that the stagnation of wage growth we are seeing now is our economy paying for the stimulus package but I am waiting for a thorough retrospective report to make comment.