4 ms·
Right. That's not the same as asserting that women are "ill-equipped to handle the rigors of the tech industry". He's talking about distributions, and why wome
by jstanley 9y ago
Right. That's not the same as asserting that women are "ill-equipped to handle the rigors of the tech industry".
He's talking about distributions, and why women might be naturally under-represented.
- emodendroket 9y agoI cannot see any possible interpretation of those claims that does not necessarily imply women's being ill-equipped to do the work.
- jenkstom 9y agoJust to play devil's advocate, it might imply that women don't want to do the work.
- emodendroket 9y agoI guess it is possible that he's is claiming they are capable but their biology makes them not want to do it. I don't think it's a very likely interpretation, and even if it is a correct interpretation, I don't really think it is a difference in kind.
- lucozade 9y agoI don't know what the Google chap was referring to specifically, but unequal gender representation in leadership roles is definitely skewed by unequal gender choices over child rearing. It strikes me that there's a perfectly sensible argument to be made that a material part of this inequality has a biological basis. I think there's next to no sensible argument to be made that most maturity decisions are made due to some lack of leadership ability or potential. Or put another way, if someone makes the case that there are biological or cultural effects that impact on choices people make then I, for one, am willing to listen. Not least because there may be opportunities to mitigate those choices (I have had some success, for example, with mothers returning to the workforce in leadership roles). If someone makes the case for biological or cultural reasons why someone is ill-equipped to do most 21C jobs in a developed society, then I usually assume they are just bigots as I've seen little to no evidence for this.
- emodendroket 9y agoI think it's a pretty tortured reading to look at someone talking about innate biological differences and think "choices about child rearing."
- true_religion 9y agoHe's talking about preferences, so why wouldn't you think about the choices people make?
- davidivadavid 9y agoOne is a descriptive claim. The other is a normative claim.
- emodendroket 9y agoThey're both descriptive claims.
- Tomminn 9y agoTo be more precise, he is implying that its possible a smaller fraction of women are both equipped and inclined to do the work than the fraction of men who are both equipped and inclined to do the work.
- jhanschoo 9y agoI've explained this elsewhere and I'll explain it again here. The author does suggest that biological reasons may contribute to fewer women preferring/being capable of (he does not mention the exact mechanism, and he does not claim to know the exact mechanism) working in tech at Google at present. The author goes on to say that Google should seek to review its work processes so that the average women will better prefer and be better able to do productive work in tech. What the author is against is positive discrimination for women which he says leads to gender tensions (which probably doesn't solve the root of the gender disparity).