4 ms·
I'm pretty surprised Airbnb has done this. This move will draw further attention to their lack of adherence to "common carrier" laws, which prevent hotels (and
by gnicholas 9y ago
I'm pretty surprised Airbnb has done this. This move will draw further attention to their lack of adherence to "common carrier" laws, which prevent hotels (and some other types of businesses) from treating customers in this way. It may be that Airbnb is not subject to these laws as written, but by taking stands like this it becomes more likely that the laws will be amended to force them to comply.
Taking a stand like this will also make Airbnb less popular in some circles. I would guess that this won't just be among white nationalists, but also in conservative circles more generally.
Grounding this decision in the commitment to "accept people regardless of their race, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, or age" will lead many conservatives - and even some moderates - to wonder what group or behavior will be banned next. Can someone be booted for having tweeted something that is racist, ageist, or sexist? What about statements that are grounded in religious beliefs, but which violate one of the other protected classes, such as sexual orientation?
The Airbnb community statement is very broad, and it is now clear that if Airbnb determines that you have violated it, they are willing to take far-reaching actions against you. For some potential customers - and also for voters who are asked to consider "Airbnb taxes" - this revelation will raise a red flag.
EDIT: man, this post dropped like a rock from the front page. I'd be curious to know why - perhaps too high of a comment / point ratio?
I thought HN was especially careful with news that is negative/controversial about YC companies, to avoid the perception of partiality.
- nxsynonym 9y agoI agree. I believe It should be left up to the hosts, if anyone, to decide who can stay in a private residence. Deactivating user profiles based on anything other than a breach of user agreement is ridiculous.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 9y agoSure anyone should be able to decide who stays in a private residence. AirBnb is not stopping them from choosing another vehicle for advertising. If Airbnb has a non discrimination clause stating that you can't advertise on their platform if you discriminate, is it really such a leap to think someone advertising for a place to stay for a White Nationalist convention may discriminate?
- true_religion 9y agoThis only affected guests not hosts. So they are like a hotel saying you can't stay here if you are racist.
- danesparza 9y agoThe article points out that's exactly what Airbnb has done: “In 2016 we established the Airbnb Community Commitment reflecting our belief that to make good on our mission of belonging, those who are members of the Airbnb community accept people regardless of their race, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, or age,” Airbnb shared in a statement. “We asked all members of the Airbnb to affirmatively sign on to this commitment.”
- nindalf 9y agoWas this agreement part of the EULA that no one reads? Not saying it's less valid, but it does feel a bit weird invoking the EULA. I thought users and software firms had an unwritten agreement that they could add anything they felt like to the EULA as long as they didn't actually invoke it.
- icebraining 9y agoNope, it was a page (or popup?) with a short and visible text and forced you to Accept or Decline: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/553a1999e4b01dde7b6bccdb/t/58ad9de2f7e0ab81132aedca/1487773187075/?format=750w https://static1.squarespace.com/static/553a1999e4b01dde7b6bc...
- fauigerzigerk 9y agoWhat does it mean to "accept people" though? Does it mean to act in a non-discriminatory fashion specifically in the context of using Airbnb? Or does it extend to discriminatory opinions held in general, even if not acted upon in the context of using Airbnb? I think it can only be the former as the latter could easily clash with religions being included in the list of protected groups. There could be (and in fact there are) religious beliefs that are clearly discriminatory against other religions, world views (like atheism) or sexual orientations. The only way to not ban someone holding such a religious belief is for Airbnb to say, OK, we don't care what you believe, but in your role as an Airbnb guest or host, you must act in a way that is non-discriminatory even if that goes against your beliefs.
- couchand 9y agoPractically will the effect be all that strong? It doesn't seem like a winning argument to say "voters: let's charge Airbnb taxes and also make sure we're welcoming to neo-nazis!"
- ko27 9y agoI agree with you, everybody here is ignoring the circumstances of this case and is trying to generalize it to include something that AirBnB is not doing.
- ballenf 9y agoMany here are tasked in their day jobs with implementing vaguely defined requirements. This feels like just such a case and thus the responses indicate a few of the possible ways one could take this entity goal and implement actionable rules. The bottom line challenge I think AirBnB has going forward is how far are they willing to go in researching their customers? Will they only be reactive in case of organized events or can a single person get evicted based on social media posts? It's easy to say case-by-case unless you're talking about an organization dealing with thousands of bookings per day. Unequal application of a policy can sometimes have worse implications than no policy at all. And it's hard to see how the policy can possibly be enforced uniformly.
- makomk 9y agoIt'll start getting really interesting once someone inevitably finds Airbnb users who've publicly proclaimed their hatred for whites, or men, or heterosexuals, or all of the above - because of course that's just as much a violation of the ToS but they'd basically be seen as alt-right supporters if they banned anyone for that. Definitely lose-lose.
- chippy 9y agoRegarding why its not on the front page (but is quite high in /active) I imagine it's because people have been flagging it due to a kind of tiredness from the flurry of other political submissions.