8 ms·
Airbnb evicts users planning to attend white nationalist event
- bolololo12 9y agoAre they evicting leftist groups demolishing cities like they did in Hamburg couple weeks ago?
- tomlock 9y agoSo you do think these people should have been evicted?
- bolololo12 9y agoif they evict right wing groups meeting, why don't they do the same to left wing anarchist groups? The true is I believe they should not involve themselves in politics as it never ends good.
- geofft 9y ago> if they evict right wing groups meeting, why don't they do the same to left wing anarchist groups? They were not evicted for being right-wing; they were evicted for violating the Community Pledge: in order to use the platform, you have to agree to "accept people regardless of their race, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, or age." Plenty of right-wing people can do that just fine. Plenty of left-wing people cannot. Unite the Right has taken it as a point of doctrine not to "punch right," by which they mean that whether or not they personally believe in rejecting people based on race, sex, religion, cultural origin, etc., they will march with those who do against a perceived "common enemy." This is not common right-wing behavior; in fact the Republican primaries featured serious questions on whether to kill baby Hitler, taking it as granted that killing adult Hitler was a moral imperative. Unite the Right would ally with adult Hitler to win the war against their "common enemy," and then maybe consider rationally debating him later. The ability to follow the Community Pledge isn't a left/right distinction, and you're misrepresenting the right wing (although probably not the "alt-right") by claiming that it is. > The true is I believe they should not involve themselves in politics as it never ends good. Airbnb is inextricably involved in politics because their entire business model is literally illegal in most of the places they operate. The process of convincing politicians to change that is called politics.
- anonemouse145 9y agoWould they evict the lesbians who've been tossing Jews out of pride parades (which is no joke, it happened in my town)? Or do they evict the Jews? Shouldn't they evict all Pride March leadership since Black Lives Matter have been stopping Pride parades due to allegations of systematic racism? Or do they evict BLM for stopping Pride parades? Would they evict the professors of Evergreen who students claim are guilty of systematic oppression? Or do they evict the students who were patrolling campus with baseball bats? Shouldn't they evict all white men, since all white men are guilty of participating in colonialism and patriarchy? Or do they evict all white men, since white men supposedly got Trump elected (something the statistics very much dispute- Trump made gains in several demographics)? This is a very slippery slope in these times. If the leaders of AirBnB were the white nationalists, and they were tossing out their opponents following white nationalist policy, everyone would say the white nationalists deserve harsh retribution. The policy itself doesn't matter. The politics do. And yes, AurBnB has to play politics. I'd wager they saw a couple markets where they hope to keep a foothold for being "the good guys" instead of an illegal business in violation of various local ordinances on innkeeping.
- tptacek 9y agoThis is really just an attempt to inject Twitter drama into the discussion. Obviously, it is not a common position among lesbians to eject people from their parades for carrying Jewish pride flags† --- one way you know that is it was a lesbian who was ejected from the parade. You're criticizing one small LGBT subgroup, but misrepresenting them as the whole LGBT community. Which in the context of this discussion is just an attempt to muddy the water. Please don't do that. (that, by the way, is what got them ejected --- being perceived as vocally pro-Israel --- not "for being Jewish". Plenty of Jewish people are anti-Israel.)
- bolololo12 9y ago> in fact the Republican primaries featured serious questions on whether to kill baby Hitler, taking it as granted that killing adult Hitler was a moral imperative. It's not worth to take part in such worthless philosophical debates in my opinion. They do not add anything to the society or solve any important modern day problems. > their entire business model is literally illegal in most of the places they operate. If that's true their website should be shut down in countries where it's banned.
- AlexeyBrin 9y agoAny kind of extremism, be it from right or from left, should be banned and legally prosecuted in any civilized and democratic country, by the law enforcement and not by individuals or private companies. If someone destroys your property during a protest or if he/she puts your family in potential physical danger, this person is an extremist in my book. Seems that some people take my comment too literally. I meant in a DEMOCRATIC society. If you are living in a Dictatorship all bets are off.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoAnd who gets to define extremism?
- bolololo12 9y agolooks like Airbnb is defining and enforcing it's rules.
- joekrill 9y agoThe problem is: who gets to define extremism? It may seem pretty clear cut to you in this particular instance, but it's a slippery slope. In the US, Republicans may want to label Democrats as extremists, and vice versa. We've already seen it happen with groups like Black Lives Matters. This is why -- in the US -- we have the first amendment and defend it so vigorously (ideally).
- zimablue 9y agoOK then, but who draws the lines on what's extremism? Do you have to want to overthrow the government? What about just heavily reform it? What lines on immigration policy would put you under prosecution, Total ban? Muslim Ban? Point system? I have no support at all for white nationalism but it's insane and counterproductive for big "service-like" companies to be enforcing their own political correctness through bans.
- AlexeyBrin 9y ago> What lines on immigration policy would put you under prosecution, Total ban? Muslim Ban? Point system? You are projecting your own thoughts on my previous comment. I honestly had no idea it can interpreted like this ... read it again and if you see any suggestion that I would condone any kind of ban based on religion, gender or skin color I will ban myself from HN.
- rdtsc 9y agoNot sure why you were downvoted. "Of course I like my city to be destroyed, we need more of that". I remember when during inauguration those brats wearing all black came and burned cars, trash cans in the street and a bunch of other vandalism. Though I think they ended up with pretty steep charges, it turns out rioting in DC is not like in other cities and carries pretty heavy penalties.
- Akujin 9y agoYou're not sure why he's being down voted? Hmm. 1. He used whataboutism 2. Anti capitalism anarchist protesters aren't Nazis and aren't calling for the genocide of entire ethnic groups. Get this through your dumb fucking skull: Nazis aren't conservatives and don't deserve any protection. We used to shoot them dead. They are getting off easy.
- freehunter 9y ago>whataboutism I have a real problem with this term, especially as it's now being used by the alt-right to shut down any conversation. It's completely fine to say "this side does this, that side does that". It's completely fine to point out that other people have flaws as well. Not every mention of the opposing viewpoint is whataboutism. Whataboutism is a diversionary tactic designed to deflect the conversation away from your flaws and onto someone else's flaws. It's super easy to shut down whataboutism. I say "you're a bad person", they come back and say "what about these other bad people" and I say "yes, they're bad too but let's keep talking about you right now". If they say "no no that's not fair, these other guys are bad", that's whataboutism. If the conversation continues like normal, then it's just a normal conversation.
- Akujin 9y agoYou're wrong. The conversation doesn't just "move on". Derailing it from the get go with bullshit points that have nothing to do with the original discussion is detrimental in in of itself. It's an old soviet tactic now being used by internet trolls. Those of us that know history see right through it and roll our eyes.
- ptero 9y agoIf correct, this is very bad. Applying a political filter to deny lodging to people who are visiting for a purpose the corporation does not approve of is a very bad idea. I could understand if hosts who objected to renting out their own place to someone based on the renter's beliefs that they strongly disagree with; but even this is borderline and the corporation acting as a moral police is, to me, a very bad path for a society to start on.
- djtriptych 9y ago"to start on"? American corporate morality isn't exactly new. Do you mean that no corporation should have moral standards of any kind?
- philipov 9y agoYes, corporations should be unfettered in their pursuit of profit at the expense of their employees and the public good. Corporations engaging in moral behavior is clearly unethical and sets a dangerous precedent!
- tantalor 9y agoYou forgot your sarcasm tag.
- DarkKomunalec 9y agoAbiding by one's own moral standards is different from enforcing them on others. Of course things get blurry in common-carrier-like cases such as marketplaces, ISPs, postal services, etc.
- djtriptych 9y agoIs it much different from Hacker News deciding what sort of content is appropriate for this forum? Would you be opposed to an airbnb clone that only rented to white supremacists?
- koolba 9y agoThis seems perfectly fine to me. They're a private company and can decide which customers they want to serve and to which they want to refuse service. Of course if you allow this you'll also need to accept that a baker can refuse to bake a cake for a gay wedding.
- djtriptych 9y agoNo, gender and sexual orientation are typically protected classes, ideology is not.
- ko27 9y ago> need to accept that a baker can refuse to bake a cake for a gay wedding. White nationalists are not a Federal protected class, homosexuals are. This whole thread is full of people who are tying relativize every kind of behavior. Not everything is subjective, our civilization has guidelines on what's accepted as moral and what is immoral.
- koolba 9y agoSource? I'm pretty sure sexual orientation is not (currently) a federally protected class. The statute is regarding "sex" as in gender. EDIT: GC comment verifies my understanding. It's not a uniform application of the statute and depends on the Federal agency involved (ex EEO vs Education).
- ko27 9y agoSex is interpreted to include discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity. https://www.eeoc.gov/federal/otherprotections.cfm https://www.eeoc.gov/federal/otherprotections.cfm EDIT for you edit: "De jure" vs "De facto". Even if you interpreted it to not include sexual orientation, it would not hold in practice or court.
- gnicholas 9y agoThe EEOC interpretation is one of many (and only applies within the purview of the Employment Equal Opportunity Commission, so not here). As a counterpoint, the current administration's Dept. of Education is taking a different stance on this question. And neither SCOTUS nor any other binding authority has weighed in.
- gnicholas 9y agoI'm pretty surprised Airbnb has done this. This move will draw further attention to their lack of adherence to "common carrier" laws, which prevent hotels (and some other types of businesses) from treating customers in this way. It may be that Airbnb is not subject to these laws as written, but by taking stands like this it becomes more likely that the laws will be amended to force them to comply. Taking a stand like this will also make Airbnb less popular in some circles. I would guess that this won't just be among white nationalists, but also in conservative circles more generally. Grounding this decision in the commitment to "accept people regardless of their race, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, or age" will lead many conservatives - and even some moderates - to wonder what group or behavior will be banned next. Can someone be booted for having tweeted something that is racist, ageist, or sexist? What about statements that are grounded in religious beliefs, but which violate one of the other protected classes, such as sexual orientation? The Airbnb community statement is very broad, and it is now clear that if Airbnb determines that you have violated it, they are willing to take far-reaching actions against you. For some potential customers - and also for voters who are asked to consider "Airbnb taxes" - this revelation will raise a red flag. EDIT: man, this post dropped like a rock from the front page. I'd be curious to know why - perhaps too high of a comment / point ratio? I thought HN was especially careful with news that is negative/controversial about YC companies, to avoid the perception of partiality.
- nxsynonym 9y agoI agree. I believe It should be left up to the hosts, if anyone, to decide who can stay in a private residence. Deactivating user profiles based on anything other than a breach of user agreement is ridiculous.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 9y agoSure anyone should be able to decide who stays in a private residence. AirBnb is not stopping them from choosing another vehicle for advertising. If Airbnb has a non discrimination clause stating that you can't advertise on their platform if you discriminate, is it really such a leap to think someone advertising for a place to stay for a White Nationalist convention may discriminate?
- interfixus 9y ago"those who are members of the Airbnb community accept people regardless of their race, religion, national origin, ethnicity, disability, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, or age" Not - it may be noted - regardless of their political stance.
- ko27 9y agoYou truly believe White nationalists "accept people regardless of their race"?
- interfixus 9y agoWho on Earth suggested anything about what I truly believe or not? I quote, and I point out a specific omission.
- freehunter 9y agoRacism is not a political stance.
- totony 9y agoEven if you disagree with it, white nationalism is a political stance
- freehunter 9y agoJust because somebody wants something to be political doesn't mean it actually is. I can call for a law saying people who drink beer out of green bottles are evil and brown beer bottles are the right solution and I spend millions of dollars campaigning to lock up people who drink out of green bottles, is that suddenly a political stance? No, it just means I have too much time on my hands and maybe even have some mental illness. White nationalism is not a political stance. It is hatred and bigotry. Just because racists want it to be political doesn't mean it is.
- deleted 9y ago
- darrmit 9y agoIt is pretty amusing to see the script flipped here. The very same people saying the baker shouldn't have to bake the cake are now saying the rental service should be FORCED to allow them to stay. Good luck with that.
- koenigdavidmj 9y agoI don't see anyone calling for the government to force Airbnb to let these people use their service.
- cooper12 9y agoSame in this thread. Suddenly, the free market's ability to govern itself is a horrible thing.
- kingmanaz 9y agoFreedom of association is not evil.
- ko27 9y agoNobody is taking their freedom. They just don't want to do business with them.
- whiddershins 9y agoI need more details. The article says it was lodgers, not hosts, who are affected. But air bnb's stated policy of non discrimination is far more directly related to hosts, and in that manifestation is consistent with public Accomodations legislation. However, denying lodging to someone based on their beliefs is dangerously in conflict with the same legislation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ddoran 9y agoI am an occasional Airbnb host. I am happy for Left/Right, Gay/Straight, religious/areligious, black/white/all people to stay in my home, however I utterly reject anyone who discriminates against others for any of these reasons, particularly if they are using my house in order to exercise their discrimination. AirBnB's Community Commitment gives me comfort and it is something I am happy to see them enforce.