5 ms·
Her assertion that world geography is not taught to US high school students shocked me.
by marcus_holmes 9y ago
Her assertion that world geography is not taught to US high school students shocked me.
- Nursie 9y agoYes, me too. I had a fairly sheltered upbringing in the UK, but we did at least do some world geography and the GCSE curriculum in the early 90s required a little bit more social geography, concentrating on the southern parts of West Africa (not that I remember much of it now). Without any world geography at all, well it seems criminal to set up an education system, that way.
- davedx 9y agoYeah, and swathes of the conservative / alt-right movement currently running things want to get rid of the (Federal) Department of Education altogether, so I read. I've even seen people on Twitter claiming America would be better without any college system at all.
- didgeoridoo 9y agoThe DoE has only existed since 1980. American public schooling did just fine without it for centuries. Why is it beyond the pale to consider eliminating it?
- jessaustin 9y agoWho else would enforce standards in geographic education? /s
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoPresumably it was the responsibility of the individual states?
- toastking 9y agoAt least from the perspective of someone who deals with teaching disabled students. The federal DOE determines allocation of resources and ADA compliance of schools. Without federally mandated special needs services many districts could stop offering these services all together.
- didgeoridoo 9y agoThese just sound like laws that should be enforced by the courts and the regular legal system. Why do we need an additional federal bureaucracy to administer them? The question isn't if the ends are desirable. It's whether it is acceptable to merely consider whether the DoE as currently-constituted is the best way to achieve them.
- soundwave106 9y agoIt's not beyond the pale, but typically when I hear something like "we must eliminate the Department of Education", it is attached more to a philosophical reasoning (eg: "government has no business in education" / Constitutional arguments / individual freedom arguments) versus arguments over what the DoE actually does. As far as I can tell, the Department of Education's role (https://www2.ed.gov/about/what-we-do.html https://www2.ed.gov/about/what-we-do.html) is largely limited to certain funding (eg: student loans), statistics, certain anti-discrimination legal enforcement that is applicable at the national level, and "[identifying] major issues" (eg advocacy). Plus some items related to the No Child Left Behind act. A lot of that seems okay to me. In particular, I think having a centralized statistical department (what this department's role largely was before elevation to cabinet level) is absolutely worthwhile. Student loans would in my opinion be the most interesting topic to explore of the above, but it's more or less worth a debate over it... not "eliminate department due to Reasons".
- Brendinooo 9y ago>We did not study world maps, because international geography, as a subject, had been phased out of many state curriculums long before. It's really just a generalized statement based on her personal experience. Here's some anecdata: In 11th grade I took a world cultures class that spent a lot of time in Russian and Chinese history as well as a broader overview of various parts of Africa (mostly sub-Saharan, if I recall correctly). This was a couple of years after doing a world cultures class that was a bit broader and shallower, but I do remember it having a pretty extensive introduction to the bigger world religions. We learned the Five Pillars of Islam as well as some of the basic principles of Hinduism and Buddhism. In elementary school, the gifted kids would put on a thing called "International Day" where they'd each pick a country, write to embassies for info, get into the CIA World Factbook on the World Wide Web, wear clothing from the nation, bring in their food, etc. It was a nice way for kids to try tzatziki sauce, listen to Slovenian-style polka, say hello in Mandarin, or see someone wearing a ghoutra or kaftan. While this was a good school district, it was nothing remotely resembling an urban or cosmopolitan one. I have to think that plenty of Americans had similar experiences like this.
- frubar 9y agoWhere on earth did you go to school? Was it a public school? I moved around a lot as a kid and no where did I learn any of the things you mentioned.
- Brendinooo 9y agoPublic school, about an hour outside of Pittsburgh.
- coldtea 9y agoHow about not taught properly? How many US high school students can pinpoint even fairly known countries on the map? (Come to Austria, meet the Kangaroos)
- saiya-jin 9y agoYou guys are maybe joking, but this is also my experience from few years back - maybe US geography is taught well, but rest of the world not so much. It's not about knowing every little spot of land out there (how many of us would distinguish Paraguay from Uruguay on a 'blind map' or have a clue about Gambia whereabouts), but knowing our blue little planet a bit more means knowing our tiny little home a bit more. With Google Earth, it can be really great learning experience.
- taneq 9y agoI see this accusation leveled at the U.S. all the time, usually in highly contrived scenarios (random people picked off the street, asked to locate landmarks in another country, then the worst/funniest performers made into a gag reel). It shits me because it's so hypocritical. I'm not from the U.S. and I have no idea where your capital city is (let alone state capitals and whatnot) and I really don't give a crap, so why should you care about mine? It's just "hurr, durr, murkins are stupid" so that equally stupid people can feel superior about something.
- coldtea 9y ago>(random people picked off the street, asked to locate landmarks in another country, then the worst/funniest performers made into a gag reel). Only it's not like that. You can ask random people yourself to verify, or you can trust one of several surveys and/or studies in the subject. E.g: http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2006/05/0502_060502_geography.html http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2006/05/0502_060502_... >It shits me because it's so hypocritical. I'm not from the U.S. and I have no idea where your capital city is (let alone state capitals and whatnot) and I really don't give a crap, so why should you care about mine? Well, it's exactly the "don't know, don't care" attitude we're arguing against here. A basic knowledge of geography is not only essential in the modern, globalized world, but also indicative of a lack of knowledge in other areas, including history and current world affairs. And that, for a country that's intervening left and right, and whose citizens are trusted to vote, rally for, or oppose parties that will perform such international interventions, diplomatic actions, etc, a lack of such knowledge is shameful. Not as if lack of knowledge was ever some kind of badge of honor.
- AlgorithmicTime 9y agoIt's also a false assertion
- crisnoble 9y agoMy school taught world geography in 7th grade (US public school). We learned every country and a capitol, every mountain range, desert, ocean and river across the entire globe. I think maybe only 50% of that has been retained nearly 20 years later, but still we did learn (well at least temporarily memorize) it.
- Sean1708 9y ago> We learned every country and a capitol, every mountain range, desert, ocean and river across the entire globe. This sounds like a very shallow style of geography, did you not do any social geography?
- ionised 9y agoHe did say 7th grade.
- Sean1708 9y ago7th grade is about 13 years old, right? I think I did social geography when I was about 13, I definitely wasn't any older 14 because I didn't do GCSE geography. Edit: In case you were interested this[0] is an example of the kind of stuff we learn when we're 11-14 in Britain. [0]: http://www.bbc.co.uk/education/subjects/zrw76sg http://www.bbc.co.uk/education/subjects/zrw76sg
- ionised 9y agoI am British (31 now). I can't remember year 7 and 8 geography very well, though that all sounds familiar.