11 ms·
Dark Matter May Be Trapped in All the Black Holes
- KirinDave 9y agoMeanwhile, the evidence for unbound WIMPS is sorta growing: http://earthsky.org/space/waterloo-image-dark-matter-cosmic-web-2017 http://earthsky.org/space/waterloo-image-dark-matter-cosmic-...
- ajross 9y agoAnd the X-Ray axion evidence from a few years ago looks OK too. But honestly: my money would have to go on this one. Black holes are by far the most boring and conventional of the existing theories, and the easiest to refute. aLIGO will tell us if it's right or not within years.
- Florin_Andrei 9y ago> Black holes are by far the most boring and conventional of the existing theories I was ready to start arguing, but then I realized you were speaking in the context of dark matter theories. :) I feel there's gonna be a few interesting years or couple decades ahead. Maybe not as big as the early 1900s. Maybe as big. Maybe even bigger.
- throwaway7645 9y agoThat's all options :)
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoWell, uncertainty is exciting. :)
- philipov 9y agoMay you live in uncertain times.
- nerfhammer 9y agoMay all your predictions be either jointly exhaustive or not jointly exhaustive.
- KirinDave 9y agoThreads like this are what keep me coming back to orange website. They are rare & touchingly innocent flowers amongst a field of awash with metaphorical blood. Thank you.
- ngold 9y agoThats really exciting. It would be amazing if we could get clear observable confirmation like Einsteins eclipse.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sixothree 9y agoAt the top of the article, is that real imagery or some sort of mock-up?
- stagbeetle 9y agoPhotograph by NASA Goddard Space Flight Center / Flickr
- davesque 9y agoBut a black hole has literally never been imaged.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agobut this could be an image of the lack of image. there are a couple ways to take what you said, since "light isn't escaping" how about the event horizon then
- davesque 9y agoNo. There is literally no high-res image in existence of the lack of light effected by a black hole's event horizon. Any cool-looking picture of light apparently warping around some unseen object, gas jets shooting out of a black ball, or any other depiction of any fidelity is an artist's impression at this point. Currently, there is a project underway (http://eventhorizontelescope.org/ http://eventhorizontelescope.org/) coordinating the efforts of many different researchers with the goal of resolving the event horizon of a black hole. This project would only produce an image that most people would still call extremely blurry. But it would be the first legitimate image of the characteristic visual features of a black hole.
- stagbeetle 9y agoYou are correct, after doing some digging I found this caption: "An illustration of the supermassive black hole located in the middle of the very dense galaxy M60-UCD1. It weighs as much as 21 million times the mass of our Sun. Credit: NASA, ESA, D. Coe, G. Bacon (STScI)" leading to: https://www.spacetelescope.org/images/heic1419a/ https://www.spacetelescope.org/images/heic1419a/
- gfodor 9y agoA universe peppered with black holes may also explain the Fermi paradox. A terrifying but logical thought.
- ythn 9y agoCould black holes also be masking an infinite number of stars? Stephen Hawking notes in his book "A Brief History of Time" that we know that there aren't infinite stars because otherwise the night sky would have no patches of darkness since an infinite number of stars would imply that you could shoot out an arbitrary ray from earth and it would always reach a star. However, black holes (lots of them!) could trap light and obscure line-of-sight stars.
- coliveira 9y agoThis line of reasoning works only in a static universe. In a expanding universe, stars can move apart faster than the speed of light. Thus there might be a lot beyond the observable universe that can never be detected.
- Neeek 9y agoI mean... isn't it still technically correct though? We have an opaque horizon of light, it's just all in the microwave spectrum.
- burkaman 9y agoThis is Olbers' paradox, and I don't think you need black holes to explain it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olbers%27_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olbers%27_paradox
- Neeek 9y agoI've always wondered about the CBM in this instance. Isn't that technically an opaque horizon of light? I understand that it's not stars per se, and that there is technically stuff "beyond" that, but doesn't that count as a "bright" night sky? Just not in the visible spectrum.
- stutterSpeaker 9y agoSo the way I understand it dark matter doesn't even have any physical interaction with matter. But it must be affected by gravity, or else it wouldn't end up trapped in black holes right?
- qubex 9y agoWell, the very reason for conceiving of dark matter is because there is evidence of gravitational effects from mass we cannot observe. So dark matter by definition must at minimum interact gravitationally, and be hard to observe by other means (electromagnetically, maybe even intent to the nuclear forces). Black holes sans accretion disk clearly satisfy these criteria.
- notzorbo3 9y agoAs far as I understand it: All kinds of stuff is happening in the universe that can only happen if there's much more gravity than we can explain with the matter we can actually observe. So there has to be something more than the observable matter. But we can't find it, so the assumption was that it didn't physically interact like normal matter (except for gravity), otherwise it would give at least some indication that it's there. Like infrared or something, I dunno. But if it turns out it's black holes, I'm guessing it would have physical interaction with other matter but still be hard to detect and not interact in the usual way we expect of normal matter. All this is speculation though, and I don't really know what I'm talking about.
- ryandrake 9y agoIgnorant "ELI5" question from a non-astrophysics major: Couldn't all this unobservable matter be just normal but so-far unobservable matter? Little planets and rocks all over the place that we just can't see yet because our telescopes aren't good enough? Why do we think it has to be some other "exotic" form of matter?
- ww520 9y agoBecause the gravitational pull from these unobservable matter is so huge that little planets, rocks, and dusts cannot account for it.
- kafkaesq 9y agoSo if, hypothetically, dark matter had some detrimental effect in those parts of the universe where it appears in overly high concentrations (making the universe less "interesting" in those parts... less able to produce life-bearing planets, say) -- -- then black holes would, in effect, be (our) universe's GC mechanism. Or at least, its "janitors" in some form. Pretty cool.
- qubex 9y agoExcept they don't relinquish what they gobble up, so they're not making a finite resource (memory) available for re-use, they're a total resource sink. Whether that's ’cool’ or not is a matter of persona preference.
- tdb7893 9y agoDon't black holes emit radiation or something?
- bitshiffed 9y agoHawking radiation, yes. They eventually evaporate.
- _FKS_ 9y agoHawking radiation is speculation AFAIK, there's no observation to back it up.
- KGIII 9y agoSome light reading on it: https://medium.com/the-physics-arxiv-blog/first-observation-of-hawking-radiation-9d77fa8c8055 https://medium.com/the-physics-arxiv-blog/first-observation-...
- macspoofing 9y agoOP isn't wrong. That we haven't proven the existence of Hawking Radiation is the only reason why Hawking hasn't won a Nobel.
- TekMol 9y agoI am sceptical about dark matter. It feels like it was invented because the theories we have do not match our observations.
- ngold 9y agoThat is kinda the hole point.
- TekMol 9y agoExactly. Scientists: Listen people! We have created models that explain why stuff does what it does! They are so complicated almost nobody can understand them. They involve 4 dimensions, a zoo of particles, randomness in everything and no reality independent of the observer. And they conflict. But at least they explain why stuff does what it does! World: But they make the wrong predictions. Stuff does not behave like that. Scientist: Oh, no problem. Just imagine there is an invisible force out there that moves stuff around. Imagine most of our universe is made of that invisible stuff. Now back to our awesome models!
- nimih 9y agoThis doesn't strike me as an especially powerful critique, in spite of your provocative language. We have well understood mathematical models which correctly and accurately predict all physical behavior relevant to our everyday lives, and, further, correctly and accurately predict the majority of our observations of the universe around us, period. As tools for understanding our world, they are incredible achievements. In spite of us knowing these models to be fundamentally incomplete, we have yet (to my understanding) to perform an experiment on Earth which contradicts them. More to the point, the theory which supersedes them will, by virtue of needing to replicate all experimental results so far, will likely be even more esoteric, complicated, wild, baffling, and impenetrable (and--with any luck--elegant, inspiring, and beautiful).
- ColanR 9y agoHe didn't say it very well, but I think he was getting at the Occams' Razor argument - this seems like an unnecessarily complex set of theories to explain the observed phenomena. (Not that I agree, but I think you missed his point)
- andy_ppp 9y agoWhat semi accessible books are available on the subject?
- vectorEQ 9y agononsense context makes science very hard to understand.