4 ms·
That is a fantastic outcome, and the sort of end goal that affirmative action should seek. But it doesn't always end that well. In India, affirmative action ha
by exergy 9y ago
That is a fantastic outcome, and the sort of end goal that affirmative action should seek. But it doesn't always end that well.
In India, affirmative action has basically served to deepen the lines between castes/religions etc. More and more sections of society demand that they be included in quotas. The people who do get in using such programs rarely succeed in suppressing the nagging question of whether they earned it (and that questioning stays with you all your life). Meanwhile, people forge identity documents to make it through such programmes, and the abuse of the system means that no one trusts that it is doing any good overall. In fact, by now, it has become a tool for politicians to appease fractious sections of society.
- Kluny 9y agoThat's really too bad. Maybe something like the blind auditions they now use for orchestra positions could help. All applications done blindly or over text, using knowledge tests, something like that.
- exergy 9y agoIn fact, I agree with your original post wholeheartedly. You start with an "end date" (say two decades). And you make that date difficult to change, so that the "let's kick the can down the road" option is not easy.
- kamaal 9y agoThe "end date" will never arrive. If you told a set of people they can get seats at plum places doing 1/4th work the remainder of the population, and you did this with 4-5 generations of their populace, its impossible to do away with this sort of entitlement after a while. And not to forget there will be enough politicians to fight for them as long as they vote for them. These sort of things are pretty much one direction. Once done are irreversible. Its impossible to roll back what people think is a right they were born with.
- troupe 9y ago> Maybe something like the blind auditions Exactly! If you want to remove gender, race or some other aspect from the decision making process you have to actually remove it. You can't just try to fix discrimination one direction by creating discrimination in a different direction.
- lake99 9y agoThat is an excellent idea. The only trouble is, the people who make this policies do not see the problem that you and I do. Their problem is to get more votes, and ocassionally to appease violent hooligans. What they have been doing fixes their problems perfectly well. SNAFU.