3 ms·
It's published on wordpress.com, non-peer reviewed etc. There is a range of credible opinions on some aspect of climate change (for example, the impact of wate
by nl 9y ago
It's published on wordpress.com, non-peer reviewed etc.
There is a range of credible opinions on some aspect of climate change (for example, the impact of water vapor around cities on measurement). It's probably worth concentrating on the ones which have at least been peer reviewed.
- seren 9y agoGoogling the author's names, you'll quickly find a snopes article in the first results: http://www.snopes.com/climatology-fraud-global-warming/ http://www.snopes.com/climatology-fraud-global-warming/
- jrapdx3 9y agoTrue enough, I didn't check out the authors or those endorsing the report. The report wasn't from a peer-reviewed journal, but then neither is the NYT or Snopes. The analysis could be considered on its merit. I'd leave that to people better qualified in that field than I am. We'd expect bias, that's entirely normal in all research. But the deep polarization of the scientific community considering climate data and findings is symptomatic of the absurd political influence on the field. The extreme level of viciousness surrounding climate research has to render all of it suspect in any honest observer's mind.
- jrapdx3 9y agoI understand the article wasn't peer-reviewed, it was only an example of the absurd level of polarization that has distorted the scientific process in climate research. However, it must be said "peer review" is no guarantee of scientific purity, the peer review system is subject to being gamed and can exhibit severe bias against unconventional approaches or novel findings. One version is the "file-drawer effect", operative in a range of science publishing. For example, accepting drug studies showing positive results but not those where drug treatment doesn't separate from placebo gives a falsely favorable impression of the effectiveness of the drug. Logically we could assert that in the presence of bias toward publishing climate studies supporting warming vs. reports not showing warming, the credibility of widely quoted results becomes questionable. It's natural, healthy and desirable for serious students of a subject to disagree. OTOH whenever political force imposes suppression of opposing points of view the process of science grinds to a halt, leaving only pseudo-scientific mythology in its place.