29 ms·
How a government was elected and how a government behaves are two different things. They're undermining both free media and the justice system. How would you c
by xg15 9y ago
How a government was elected and how a government behaves are two different things.
They're undermining both free media and the justice system. How would you call that?
- mc32 9y agoDepends. Are they going against the will of the people and are they doing it illegally? Or are they following protocol? Germany kerbs free speech in many ways vis a vis the US, but we don't call them undemocratic --they followed protocol and it's their version --not a version I'd prefer, but still not undemocratic.
- wegi 9y agoFollowing the Protocoll does not mean you act democratic necessarily. The NSDAP was following the protocoll as well in the beginning. Every protocol and law can be abused. Especially when you control the judiciary. The problem with Polands move is that the legislative tries to control the judiciary, a thing that goes against the very definition of a free democracy. Similar in Turkey. The AKP controls not only the legislative without any real opposition, they also inoficially control the judiciary and the executive. Since all critical journalists get put in prison, the Press is also opressed.
- mc32 9y agoRight, it's complicated and it's not clear cut. Amassing power is always a cautious endeavor that should be viewed with suspicion --but that's not always "undemocratic" people may want and vote for that --that all may lead to an eventual undemocratic regime which intimidates, fires rivals, jails and extorts its population ala Chavez. Poland and Germany are far from that.
- alkonaut 9y agoIt's a slippery slope. In the beginning it looks like innocent little constitutional changes etc. Usually under the pretense of some external enemy (Terrorists, whatever). some private media losing their broadcast rights (Poland). Journalists arrested on terror charges under very strange circumstances (Turkey) and so on. Once these changes are in place, and the division of power and free press is gone - the goal is open to move much faster. That's why it's so alarming in Poland/Turkey even though Venezuela is much worse already. Liberal democracy is brittle, and it can still be saved in Poland/Turkey. In Venezuela it has to be built.
- markvdb 9y ago"Democratic" has been overloaded with meanings and has become very ambiguous in that respect. That is the real problem. My guess is that many here say "democratic" and mean "a system that will guarantee one respect as per John Rawls' veil of ignorance [0]". A parliamentary democracy with clear separation between legislative, executive and judiciary seems to be the lease bad solution humanity has been able to come up with for now. Venezuela, Turkey and Poland are just recent highlights of how vulnerable parliamentary democracy is... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veil_of_ignorance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veil_of_ignorance
- alkonaut 9y agoGermany has proper separation of power, free press etc. About the only thing that makes it undemocratic (in the sense of liberal democracy) is if takes away any of these foundations: suppresses media, takes away the independence of courts etc. Germany does neither. Whether the governing person or party is populist or extreme right or socialist or whatever doesn't matter.
- biggerbistro 9y agoFreedom of speech (which Germany does not have) is a core tenet of democracy. If the government can police what we say then it follows that they can prevent those from being elected that they do not agree with. For example: what if we made liberal values into hatespeech, how likely do you think it would be for the democrats to win the next election? Any country without true freedom of speech is autocracy in disguise.
- alkonaut 9y agoWhat is it that makes Germany not have freedom of speech? Most liberal democracies have freedom of speech even though they have laws against libel/slander/hate speech and so on. Next you go on to say that countries without freedom of speech are autocracies in disguise - implying Germany is an autocracy... not sure what to make of that. Are you implying that e.g either you live in a democracy and you can hate-speak, or you don't live in a democracy? From the last paragraph I get the feeling you live in re US and take great pride in it being a true democracy because of its lack of hate speech laws (libel/slander laws exist). I wouldn't worry so much about politicians being able to limit hate speech in a place where elected officials draw the election district lines, effectively choosing their voters, where entire groups of citizens (such as prison inmates) can't vote at all, and where the executive branch of government doesn't have popular support even on Election Day. I'm no fan of hate speech laws myself, but I consider it quite useless to define democracy as not being able to coexist with them.
- mc32 9y agoDo you recall the German Boehmermann who was almost jailed because he made fun of a _foreign_ leader? That limits free speech. It's not hateful but it's political.