5 ms·
I wonder if the guy in the article has considered buying his drug without insurance? In the case of the generic for Adderall XR it is about $70 with a GoodRx co
by tzs 9y ago
I wonder if the guy in the article has considered buying his drug without insurance? In the case of the generic for Adderall XR it is about $70 with a GoodRx coupon at Walgreens, which is less than the $90 copay to get the brand drug with insurance.
Even if your insurance company lets you use generics, it is a good idea to take a look at GoodRx, and take a look at Walmart.
I've had generics where through my insurance my out of pocket was a $20 copay, but when I checked GoodRx there was a $12 coupon. I've had other generics, again with a $20 copay if I got them through insurance, where they were $4 at Walmart with no insurance or coupons.
- brilee 9y agoFrom the article: > Then, in 2014, her pharmacist told her that her insurance plan would cover only the brand-name drug, which cost her family some $50 more a month than the generic. If she paid for the generic herself, it would not have counted toward her deductible. Ms. Freundlich complained to her insurer, UnitedHealthcare, but could not get a clear answer.
- vm 9y agoThis is good advice, though the article also mentions that self-paid drugs don't count toward deductibles. In addition to shopping around, patients should calculate their deductibles and estimate how that might impact their spending. ...which is a messed up, Byzantine system. I'd love a single payer system just to crush this inefficiency out of the system and make patient's lives easier. I would have thought healthcare is all about saving lives but in the U.S. it seems like a dirty busy.
- Aloha 9y agoI'd love for us to so some market-based reforms to the current system before we blow it up - I concede that Single Payer is likely the only workable answer in the end. We need to do things like tort reform, the current system presumes that a doctor making a mistake is an extremely rare thing - its not, doctors are human like any other mechanic. Instead doctors over diagnose, and over treat out of fear of liability (which in most states is unlimited). we could limit liability to 2x the actuarial predicted lifetime earnings potential, and limit damages for pain and suffering to 1x that. We need to allow insurers to pool together to purchase drugs to force the price down - medicare should also be unshackled and be allowed to negotiate pricing on drugs as well. We should require cost transparency in healthcare - try asking how much a procedure is the next time you go to the doctor, you'll get a bunch of blank stares. People cant make reasonable choices if they cant perform a cost benefit analysis. Those changes alone - while they may not reduce costs would stop the increases from occurring as quickly.
- DougWebb 9y agotry asking how much a procedure is the next time you go to the doctor, you'll get a bunch of blank stares. That's probably because the people you can ask who fully understand the procedure you need don't know what the prices for you are or everything you're going to need, and the people who know the prices aren't doctors and couldn't determine what exactly the procedure will entail. This is by design, of course, but it means that the people you might try to get a price from aren't able to tell you, even if they really want to. Take your car to a mechanic, and ask how much a repair is before they look at your car. They can tell you typical costs, but can't tell you what your repair will cost yet. So you let them look the car over, then come back to you with an estimate. But that's still not the final cost, because once they start working something else might come up, and they'll have to stop to talk to you about the additional work. You don't know the final cost until all the work is done. That's the way it is with medical procedures too, except most of the time you can't stop midway through to discuss options and costs when something unexpected happens. The doctor just has to take care of it, and let you know about it afterwards.
- maxerickson 9y agoThere's a whole host of tests and services where price transparency would be easy. Billing simplification too (if the hospital picks the radiologist, they should pay the radiologist out of the fixed fee they charge for the xray...)
- Aloha 9y agoThis is a great point to make too - if the hospital chooses who renders me service, I shouldn't be getting a separate bill from them.
- majormajor 9y agoYeah, when it comes to really expensive stuff they'll know the minimum, because then they have their own incentives to make sure you can pay, and will be in a financial position to be able to do the post-procedure upkeep. This is especially true when it's stuff with scarce resources like transplants. It's gonna cost a fuckload, you'll have a lot of recurring costs, and they're going to evaluate if you'll be set up for success or not because otherwise there are other people who could use the organs.
- cbhl 9y agoWould single payer cover prescriptions though? Canada has single payer, and you still have to pay something whenever you get a prescription at the pharmacy.
- aktiur 9y agoIt could. In France (which has a mixed system), single payer cover around 70% of prescriptions costs. And you usually have an additional private plan that will cover the rest (and if you're too poor to buy one of these plans, you can be eligible to get it from the state).
- the_mitsuhiko 9y agoIn Austria prescriptions are coveres but you pay a flat fee if the price of the prescription is higher than that flat fee.
- alkonaut 9y agoThe NHS covers almost all drug costs. In Sweden drugs are free for kids under 18, and others have a yearly cap at ~$200 for drugs, at which they become free (partially subsidized a bit before that).
- tomohawk 9y agoLet's see. Under single payer system, it's illegal to purchase medicine or health care. Only the government can do it. The government does not get sick, and so is primarily focused on cutting cost. Government picks generic drug that works for most people and has no incentive to worry about the 5% - 10% of people it doesn't work for. Oh, well. This is pretty much what we have now, except with an oligopoly instead of a monopoly. Not really seeing how going even more in the direction of a monopoly helps. When people can make choices, thats when things change. People actually get sick, so paying for healthcare is more than just a cost, it can have a value as well. At least with the current oligopoly system, there is a small amount of choice, and you can choose to purchase a drug on your own if what your insurer has on offer does not work or is more expensive. We should be going in the opposite direction - away from monopoly instead of towards it. Instead of a single payer, we should have a single market.
- Thlom 9y agoIt's not illegal to purchase medicine or healthcare under most single payer systems.
- al452 9y ago"Under single payer system, it's illegal to purchase medicine or health care." Total utter FUD. It's legal and normal in each of the 3 countries I've lived&worked in with a single-payer system. You seem very misled.
- maxsilver 9y ago> Let's see. Under single payer system, it's illegal to purchase medicine or health care. Only the government can do it. No, Nearly every single payer system allows you to purchase extra health care, over and beyond what the single payer system provides. In Canada, as just one example, this is sometimes called "supplementary health insurance". See https://on.bluecross.ca/health-insurance/health-insurance-101/compare-our-plans https://on.bluecross.ca/health-insurance/health-insurance-10... for an example > Government picks generic drug that works for most people and has no incentive to worry about the 5% - 10% of people it doesn't work for. Oh, well Generally, this isn't true either. Government picks generic drugs, because it frees up the most amount of money for them to treat other people with. But if the government covers medications and there's a real medical reason to need a name brand drug over a generic, they'll usually prescribe you the name brand one automatically. Here's a list of that happening in the UK, for example - http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Medicinesinfo/Pages/Brandnamesandgenerics.aspx http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Medicinesinfo/Pages/Brandnamesa... And of course, as always, your still welcome to buy any name brand drug yourself, if you like.
- Sleeep 9y agoMy old plan copays didn't count towards the deductible though, they were totally separate. Is that uncommon?
- Animats 9y agoGoodRX coupons are a come-on. I've had one long out of patent drug jump from $14.77 to $100.58 this year. My doctor was amazed at this. (I just sent that info to the NYT; they have a form for this in the article.)
- maxerickson 9y agoGoodRX is just a free pharmacy benefit manager. They are relatively up front about it: How does GoodRx make money? GoodRx is free for consumers, and we do not require that you create an account to search for prices and receive discounts. We do not collect your personal information. We make money from advertisements on our site and referral fees. https://www.goodrx.com/how-goodrx-works https://www.goodrx.com/how-goodrx-works They might offer coupons in addition to that (I don't know), but they primarily negotiate prices for a formulary. So those prices aren't going to be one time coupon type prices, they are going to be the price they have negotiated with the pharmacy in question (which may indeed change as they renegotiate).
- goodrx 9y agoHi there - a few corrections: 1) We're not a pharmacy benefit manager; we just list prices and available discounts. 2) We're constantly looking for new prices and lower discounts. While prices don't generally change as much as mentioned above, they do sometimes change. I believe we're familiar with this case, and this was the removal of a price by one pharmacy benefit manager. We're sorry it went up, but it was only because this price has been adjusted by the pharmacy benefit manager, not because we're up to anything evil.
- Sleeep 9y agoYeah, around 2007 Target announced they had reduced a whole bunch of generic maintenance drugs to $5 for a 30 day supply. I was still paying a $10 copay at CVS, so I switched to Target and paid the $5.
- cosmie 9y agoIs this still the case since Target sold their pharmacy operations to CVS? I've been curious how much of the "Target charm" remained after that transition.
- Sleeep 9y agoNo idea. I stopped going to Target a long time ago. I know they got rid of the specially designed pill bottles everyone liked and people are annoyed about that.
- NelsonMinar 9y agoI've saved $3/pill (75%) with a GoodRx coupon. Blink also provides a similar service. But how insane is it that I have to not use my health insurance to buy a health product at a good price?