4 ms·
That's one way to read it. Another way would be, "Stop trying to promote diversity, it alienates the racists and sexists who work here." I don't think this is
by mikeash 9y ago
That's one way to read it. Another way would be, "Stop trying to promote diversity, it alienates the racists and sexists who work here."
I don't think this is an unfair reading. One of the bullet points in the conclusion is literally that the company's diversity programs are problematic because they alienate non-progressives.
- andrenth 9y agoDid you just equate "non-progressives" with "racists and sexists"?
- loeg 9y agoIf a non-progressive is alienated by a diversity program, are they not a racist or sexist?
- Spivak 9y agoNot all diversity program are created equal, heh. Diversity through quotas or hiring preferences to X, Y, Z classes of people are bound to make people angry. Diversity though increased access to education, recruitment efforts, and accommodation of different strengths and weaknesses, personalities, work styles, management styles, etc. would make people much happier.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- axaxs 9y agoNo. Maybe we just believe in equality for all regardless of race or sex. If a cool course opens but only for women, or people of color, of course that makes us feel alienated.
- johngalt 9y agoWe have a mandated bible study program covering the ten commandments. Oh that alienates you? So you want to murder people and steal stuff? We are going to fire/blacklist you now as a thief.
- mikeash 9y agoNo, I believe the author did that when he said that diversity programs alienate non-progressives.
- Spivak 9y agoYou at least agree that there are different types of diversity programs. (From his claims) Google's approach to diversity are hamfisted and end up achieving a level of diversity that looks good on internal reports but ends up alienating people because it's more important what you are than who you are.
- axaxs 9y agoI cannot believe what I'm reading in this thread, especially from usernames I recognize and respect. If this is really what is ascertained from this, our two sides' differences are too large to be reconciled. Consider maybe some people truly want to work with the best of the best, ignoring race or gender. Let the cards fall where they may based on merit.
- vyhd 9y agoAn alternate way to phrase it for you, then. Why are you assuming that these programs do not produce the "best of the best"?
- mikeash 9y agoI'm all for hiring based on merit and nothing else. 100%, that's what I'd want to see. But actually doing so is a fantasy. Building bias-free selection processes is really, really hard. I don't think anyone actually knows how. (At least not useful ones. You can trivially eliminate bias by never hiring anyone, for example.) It looks to me like this is the fundamental agreement between the two sides here. Both sides want to hire the people who will be best at the job, full stop. People who think James Damore is correct believe that the typical hiring process, or at least some achievable tech hiring process, already achieves this, and any modification is necessarily selecting worse candidates. People on the other side, such as myself, believe that the hiring process selects for far more than just merit, and diversity programs are an attempt to fix that. So, yes, let's pick the best of the best. How?
- Aunche 9y agoHe's not saying that the diversity programs are alienating conservatives. He's saying that if Google really wants to care about diversity, they should be more open to political diversity.
- mikeash 9y agoHe literally says that Google's diversity programs alienate non-progressives.
- Aunche 9y agoNo he doesn't. His bullet point about not alienating conservatives is completely independent from discussion about diversity programs.
- mikeash 9y ago"These [diversity] programs are highly politicized which further alienates non-progressives."
- Aunche 9y agoThanks for finding the quote. Regardless, the author says that the politicization is alienating conservatives, not the program itself. If Google allowed for an open discussion about its diversity program, the author would not have this criticism.
- mikeash 9y agoHe's saying the program itself is, and this is the reason why. "Politicization" is quite vague and the author doesn't explain exactly how these programs are "politicized" or what that means. I suspect it comes down to their mere existence.