5 ms·
This isn't an issue of "fashion" or "opinion". It's an issue of whether the guy is right or wrong, and if he's wrong[1] whether or not he's caused damage to hi
by ajross 9y ago
This isn't an issue of "fashion" or "opinion". It's an issue of whether the guy is right or wrong, and if he's wrong[1] whether or not he's caused damage to his employer[2], and if that is true whether it is a firing offense[3].
You don't get to avoid discussion[4] about those subtitled points by retreating to some kind of invented safe space here. Out with it. Is he right?
[1] He is.
[2] He has.
[3] It is.
[4] Yeah, I'm just asserting without evidence too. But only
to avoid the pointless flames that result.
- ctlby 9y agoPoint 2 and 3 are independent from point 1. He is completely right on the factual merits; stop with the science denialism.
- halostatue 9y agoHe is completely wrong on his assertions, and those assertions are not facts or science. As Pauli is reputed to have said, the author of the manifesto is “not even wrong”. He’s a white male fantasist.
- ctlby 9y agoPlease stop peddling this science denialism. There is great consensus outside the intellectually-bankrupt fields of sociology and gender studies.
- ajross 9y agoIf you're going to assert a scientific consensus, my friend, you're going to have to cite one.
- ctlby 9y agoStart with Halpern's "Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities" and follow the bibliography where it takes you (I really would like to provide the references, but just I don't have the patience to copy them now). For something rigorous that's digitally available, start with sapinker's slides from his 2005 debate [1]. Modern understanding is quite similar, only with new evidence and insights from evolutionary psychology and neurobiology. [1] https://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/debate05/pinker.slides.html https://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/debate05/pinker.slides.html
- avaer 9y agoRight, wrong, damage, and safety are precisely the dressed-up fashions PG's essay talks about.
- great_psy 9y agoTwo words are not a valid reference. If you want to be taken seriously, put some effort in your arguments.