6 ms·
This is starting to be scary. Instead of government companies are acting as thought police. I think a lot of people will watch what they are saying publicly fr
by maxxxxx 9y ago
This is starting to be scary. Instead of government companies are acting as thought police. I think a lot of people will watch what they are saying publicly from now on.
- Animats 9y agoAll Googleers .. need to watch what they say, watch what they do. - paraphrasing Ari Fleischer, Bush's press secretary, after 9/11.
- cthulha 9y agoI don't think you've thought this through. Maybe read the article and other informed commentary such as this ex-Googler: https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/so-about-this-googlers-manifesto-1e3773ed1788 https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/so-about-this-googlers-man...
- wyclif 9y agoI think he's thought it through enough to see the implications. And that ex-Googler has a fairly draconian, authoritarian view of groupthink.
- syshum 9y agoI found this to be a pretty good rebuttal to that https://medium.com/@silverstrike/i-like-how-you-portray-the-author-as-a-poor-excuse-for-a-human-being-all-the-while-claiming-some-e600fae3f486 https://medium.com/@silverstrike/i-like-how-you-portray-the-... The summary at the end of "Get over yourself. You are not as special as you believe yourself to be. At that point, I gave up on your pathetic and emotional diatribe. Your piece is devoid of any logic, reason, or sense and serves as a way for you to virtue-signal to the rest of the world how much of a “stand-up guy” you are." Is spot on how I read that Medium post. I found nothing of value in the Ex Googler's commentary.
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoI don't think that ex-Googler read the document. Nothing he attacks him on seems to be in it.
- AbrahamParangi 9y agoI would argue that it's more akin to picking a fight in a bar— you're liable to get kicked out just for making trouble.
- sadface 9y agoGood. People should be thinking twice. Freedom of Speech is not the same thing as Freedom from Consequences. Unless we decide that being "aggressively antisocial" should be a protected class, private companies should have every right to fire employees who they deem toxic for their culture.
- maxxxxx 9y agoWill they fire every Trump voter and every hardcore feminist now too?
- kevingadd 9y agoIf they put 'make america great again' or 'death to white men' posters up on the bulletin boards at work in the break room, yeah, they'll fire them too. It's against the agreements they signed when they got hired. If you don't like it don't sign and go work somewhere else.
- nerflad 9y ago> "If they put 'make america great again' or 'death to white men' posters up on the bulletin boards at work in the break room, yeah, they'll fire them too." Are you saying that supporting a presidential candidate is tantamount to "death to white men"? Yes, the candidate in question is abhorrent, but come on. Those statements absolutely don't carry equal weight.
- kevingadd 9y ago> Will they fire every Trump voter and every hardcore feminist now too? If you read the post I was replying to, it would be obvious why I chose those two examples.
- nerflad 9y agoMy point was, it's not a good set of examples, since they are so unlike each other. Unless you mean certain organizations actually consider them equivalent.
- ionforce 9y agoYou don't think the generalizations against women were scary?
- maxxxxx 9y agoNot really. A lot of people have weird views. Based on this Google can't hire any conservative Christians either. I just don't think this should be a firing offense.
- kevingadd 9y agoThey can hire Christians as long as the hires are intelligent enough to realize that (for example) leaving Chick Tracts on their coworkers' desks is probably not acceptable workplace behavior. Plenty of Google employees are christians and none of them have been fired for it (it's legally protected, for one thing)
- 0xCMP 9y agoVoltaire is rolling in his grave.
- mrbill 9y agoWhen you do/say/write something that has the potential to cause problems for your employer, you should be aware of and prepared for the possible consequences. I certainly would not write a multi-page screed criticizing the policies and practices of my employer, distribute it at work, and then expect to keep my job or have no repercussions.
- Zarath 9y agoGod forbid a monolithic, trillion dollar corporation have an employee saying things they don't like.
- StargazyPi 9y agoWhen it's a widely circulated internal document criticising the hiring practices behind 40% of the company's workforce, it's hardly surprising. He put them in a difficult position. The brand and employee-esteem damage caused by tacitly condoning his manifesto by not firing him, vs just getting rid of one engineer. Easy maths. He's gone. Edit: backwards words not now.
- gopz 9y agoTrue, but what's troubling isn't that he was fired, it's that the memo got leaked, caused a bunch of controversy and basically forced Google to take a position on whether they want to discuss this stuff. Yes, one guy getting fired for sending out something inflammatory and critical isn't a huge deal (although I would have expected Google to be more tolerant), it's the fact that it went public and then when Google had to make a public statement deciding whether to fire him or not they chose "we don't think these ideas should be discussed".
- peoplewindow 9y agoHow do you think companies work through their own policies or change direction? Employees write strategy memos all the time.
- brown9-2 9y agoI would be curious to know at which point in history one could circulate a memo around the office which embarrassed the company and insulted half the workforce without repercussion.
- agentdrtran 9y agoWell not half, only about what, 30%? /s
- MichaelGG 9y agoI find it so bizarre people get this interpretation - it's completely nonsensical. Point: "Chinese tend to be short so not many of them go into basketball". Counterpoint: "I'm Chinese and 6'5" are you saying I'm short and bad at basketball?"
- jumbopapa 9y agoNo one seems to understand that he is talking about the aggregate.
- tanilama 9y agoHe puts his employer in a very difficult situation, however Google reacts, it is going to be trigger half of the internet population. He is hired to be a programmer, not a social activist and Google surely could stand up and say they don't want be part of that.