2 ms·
Actually, the equality is part of Euclid's definition of the right angle: ῞Οταν δὲ εὐθεῖα ἐπ᾿ εὐθεῖαν σταθεῖσα τὰς ἐφεξῆς γωνίας ἴσας ἀλλήλαις ποιῇ, ὀρθὴ ἑκατέ
by Koshkin 9y ago
Actually, the equality is part of Euclid's definition of the right angle:
῞Οταν δὲ εὐθεῖα ἐπ᾿ εὐθεῖαν σταθεῖσα τὰς ἐφεξῆς γωνίας ἴσας ἀλλήλαις ποιῇ, ὀρθὴ ἑκατέρα τῶν ἴσων γωνιῶν ἐστι, καὶ ἡ ἐφεστηκυῖα εὐθεῖα κάθετος καλεῖται, ἐφ᾿ ἣν
ἐφέστηκεν.
On the other hand, there is nothing wrong with leaving the property of an angle being 'right' undefined and postulating that all angles that possess this property are equal.
(The notion of acuteness requires the ability to compare angles; those 'smaller' than the right angle are 'acute'.)
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> there is nothing wrong with leaving the property of an angle being 'right' undefined and postulating that all angles that possess this property are equal Yes there is; it makes the postulate completely useless. Stating "all angles possessing a certain property which cannot be assessed are equal to each other" is useless, identical to declaring "any two equal angles are equal". Actually -- are there proofs in the Elements which invoke that postulate?
- Koshkin 9y agoWell, in a theory based on axioms some notions must be left undefined (which does not make them useless), so why not the notion of the right angle?
- thaumasiotes 9y agoBecause then you have no way of identifying right angles. That leaves you with a claim you can make about right angles, and no angles you can ever apply the claim to. That is the same as not having the claim at all. Consider this modified classic syllogism: 1. All men are mortal. 2. No one can ever know whether any particular object is or isn't a man. 3. Therefore, Socrates is mortal. See the problem? It may still be possible to prove that Socrates is mortal, but you can't prove that or anything else with the postulate "all men are mortal", because that postulate, by hypothesis, doesn't apply to anything.
- Koshkin 9y agoOf course, a theory that only includes the "equality axiom" would be incomplete, there would have to be other axioms that reference the (otherwise undefined) notion of the 'right angle'. Then it will be possible to prove theorems that involve this notion. For example, it will be possible to prove that "the particular object" that lies between the shorter sides of a triangle with side lengths three, four, and five, is, in fact, a right angle!
- thaumasiotes 9y agoUntil you have a definition of right angles, it is not possible to prove that anything, including the angle opposite the 5 side of a 3,4,5 triangle, is a right angle. Really, that's what a definition is. It isn't necessary for the statement "all right angles are equal" to include a definition of right angles. But for the statement to have any meaning at all, the logical system that the statement is made in must include a definition of right angles. They cannot be left undefined.