3 ms·
I agree that if you build one web app tuned for mobile phones --- it should work for both iPhones and Android phones...as well as for browsers on laptops and de
by jbail 16y ago
I agree that if you build one web app tuned for mobile phones --- it should work for both iPhones and Android phones...as well as for browsers on laptops and desktops.
But, HTML5 is nowhere close to supporting the features you need, nor does it have access to essential phone hardware. I've built a browser based paint app and a browser based GPS using HTML5 and while fun, I think if you're honest, you know it's not quite ready for that yet. There is too much browser sniffing/adapter pattern going on and it can't be avoided.
That aside, my question to other mobile phone users is how Native vs. Web apps are perceived by users on a phone. Since the Native App is --- well, native --- it is given more prominence within the phone's UI. I suppose you could bookmark the web app, but it just doesn't seem to have as much importance as something natively installed with a shortcut icon, full access to all hardware, native menus, buttons, etc.
So, I don't think you can blatantly say "web apps are better than mobile" --- unless maybe you have a vested interest in that position --- like you're writing a book or something (ahem, ahem).
I think the reality is that app stores are a pretty cheap distro opportunity with millions of people with credit cards on file and are certainly not going anywhere in the near future.
- redrobot5050 16y agoYou can "bookmark" web apps into your home screen with the iPhone. I'm sure Android offers some version of support for this as well. But you still have to deal with stuff like having to login every time. Losing some screen space of your app to the Safari bar at the top, etc.
- semanticist 16y agoYou can have your web app not show the safari bar when saved to the home screen. If you're using a framework like jQTouch it's automatic, and combined with a custom icon and splash screen really does give the 'native app' feel. It's just a pity that it's so awkward to get it onto the home screen. Prompting the user to press the '+' and save it is clunky.