3 ms·
> you're responding as though, at some mysterious date in the future, all people are getting fired and replaced with a robot I have said no such thing. I am re
by pdonis 9y ago
> you're responding as though, at some mysterious date in the future, all people are getting fired and replaced with a robot
I have said no such thing. I am responding directly to your own statements. You said, in effect, that nobody's job is safe from automation. I just assumed you meant what you said.
> You're still hung up on this idea that productive things are all people can do.
All of the things in question are productive things, by the definition I thought we were using. A "productive" thing is a thing that improves people's lives. Are you saying that artistic creativity, service work, craftsmanship, etc. don't improve people's lives?
> There will always be something for us to do
That contradicts "no one's job is safe from automation", doesn't it?
> We already are seeing the beginnings of a population that can't really produce anything
Again, you're using a much too restrictive definition of "produce". But there's another point here as well.
The basic vision I see you describing is, nobody has to produce anything because all of the necessary production will be done by machines. But who owns the machines?
If the machines are owned by a few centralized entities, then we have the same problem of distribution that we had before--who gets the stuff the machines make? If you think there is any way of setting up a society that will guarantee that such a distribution is going to be fair to the people who don't own the machines, I have some beachfront property in Nebraska I'd like to sell you.
The obvious alternative is to make those machines cheap and small and plentiful enough that we can all have one. In other words, instead of universal basic income, we all are able to buy, at some reasonable price, machines that meet all of our basic needs. Then it will indeed be up to each individual person to decide what, if anything, they want to produce, because they will own all the resources necessary to meet their basic needs.
The difference between these two scenarios is that the first (yours) requires a fundamental change to human nature. I don't think that's going to happen. The second (mine) only requires a change in the kinds of technologies we try to build. That seems like a much better bet.
> this doomsday view also relies on the AI being entirely unaware of empathy, which as a core component of humanity, would likely make its way into the artificial minds humanity creates
This strikes me as overly optimistic handwaving. We have no idea how human brains implement empathy, and none of the artificial devices we have built so far have it. Yet somehow we're going to magically be able to build it into an AI?
> It's a base function of animal and human brains
Which evolved over hundreds of millions of years. I think you're vastly underestimating the amount of complexity that process created.