4 ms·
The fundamental problem, it seems to me, is an academic culture where an advisor doesn't get kudos for an idea that their student came up with. This (again AFA
by lisper 9y ago
The fundamental problem, it seems to me, is an academic culture where an advisor doesn't get kudos for an idea that their student came up with. This (again AFAICT) is unique to the humanities. In technical fields, an advisor gets points when their students succeed, to the point where if a student fails a Ph.D. defense it reflects badly on everyone on the committee. Because of that, by the time you get to your defense, it is a foregone conclusion that you will pass unless you screw it up badly. If that is not the case, your committee won't let you defend. (That leads to its own set of dysfunctional dynamics, but it's nowhere near as dramatic or emotionally taxing as what happened here.)
I think the real problem is that a huge proportion of academic research in the humanities is bullshit and deep down the practitioners know it. They survive, then, by insuring that only those willing to Play The Game rise through the ranks. Any hint of dissent is brutally crushed.