2 ms·
Earlier explanations of the dinosaurs' demise were pretty speculative. Impact and Deccan traps volcanism were the about the only hypotheses that had specific ph
by mannykannot 9y ago
Earlier explanations of the dinosaurs' demise were pretty speculative. Impact and Deccan traps volcanism were the about the only hypotheses that had specific physical evidence to support them.
According to Stephen Jay Gould, it turned out that the claim of declining dinosaur (and ammonite) diversity was exaggerated through poor statistical analysis, failing to account for the fact that a species' last appearance in the record does not mean that it became extinct immediately afterwards. Furthermore, when paleontologists specifically looked into diversity up to the boundary, they found it. Diversity is always changing, so some decline beforehand is not fatal to the theory.
Gould also believed that many geologists resisted the impact hypothesis on the basis of a somewhat dogmatic objection to 'catastrophism' in any form. This kept competing theories alive longer than perhaps they should have.
FWIW, I am not entirely satisfied with the explanations of how some classes (especially birds) survived, but in any case there were not so many survivors; terrestrial vertebrates came fairly close to total extinction. When the odds are long, chance can make a big difference.
Journalists often want a simple story to tell, and the myth of the dispassionate, objective scientist is largely just that: they will present the ideas they favor in the best light that evidence permits, and sometimes beyond. Furthermore, the evidence increases over time, whether for or against a hypothesis. When a hypothesis accumulates more, and more diverse, evidence consistent with it, its plausibility goes up, and if you want an informed opinion (of anything), you have to follow those developments.