2 ms·
This is the third argument in this thread that attempts to claim that the mechanisms of crashing might mean that the outcomes are worse, in response to actual d
by dahart 9y ago
This is the third argument in this thread that attempts to claim that the mechanisms of crashing might mean that the outcomes are worse, in response to actual data that the outcomes are, in fact, better.
This argument seems unscientific. The experiment already ran, and the data shows reduced injuries for helmets. Explaining why something "suggests" it might not work makes no sense, when it did already work on a large scale.
I also don't buy that helmets grip more on average. Most are coated in plastic and my scalp is coated in skin and hair. One of those grips gravel & concrete more easily, and it's not plastic.
I gave a source for the quote above, and it comes from a meta analysis of multiple studies.
The simple message is simple because the science showed a large and compelling result. When the statistical significance is enormous, and the results are a clear and unmistakable positive across numerous studies and a lot of scrutiny, the message gets less and less complicated.
Suggesting that there's anything complicated about wildly improved outcomes seems like FUD to me.