3 ms·
So there are several books that said the same thing about Hoover, but does that mean it is more likely that these historians are more accurate than the historia
by kiba 16y ago
So there are several books that said the same thing about Hoover, but does that mean it is more likely that these historians are more accurate than the historians who provided a renegade viewpoint?
I have read another book that said that the early new deals program and regulatory framework were essentially made by insider players, who wrote the rulebooks to fit their business operations. Suddenly, you would have a few entrepreneurs and businessmen, jailed because they do a few things differently.
For example, from my fallible memory, a businessman who sold tires has to compete with Goodyear, who have locations around the country. In order for his business to survive, he must sell his tries cheaper than Goodyears does. However, he got fined because Goodyear wrote the regulation rules for the tire industry.
Which one is more likely in your opinion? The image of government programs being an entirely benevolent operation put forward by FDR, or political machines benefiting some people more than others, sometime at the expenses of one another?
If I got a job with the work progress administration, I might be inclined to vote for FDR because he gave me a job, not whether or not if the work progress administration benefit the economy.
- jbooth 16y ago> Renegade viewpoint? Yeah, in absence of better proof provided, I'll stick with the opinion of the majority of historians. The rest of your points haven't had anything to do with government finances or the attitudes of both presidents towards countercyclical spending vs balanced budgets. They seem like some blindly-applied-backwards-80-years modern republican simplifications about the nature of "government programs". Some dude got screwed by Goodyear at some point in history? Huh? There's been a lot of scholarship on this topic. You've got to do better than that if you're going to make an overarching claim like in your original point. To start with, here's a google search for "herbert hoover balanced budget": http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=herbert+hoover+balanced+budget&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=&gs_rfai= http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=herbert+hoover+bala...
- kiba 16y agoYeah, in absence of better proof provided, I'll stick with the opinion of the majority of historians. What is your rationale for sticking with whatever the majority of historians said? The rest of your points haven't had anything to do with government finances or the attitudes of both presidents towards countercyclical spending vs balanced budgets. They seem like some blindly-applied-backwards-80-years modern republican simplifications about the nature of "government programs". Some dude got screwed by Goodyear at some point in history? Huh? Sorry about non-sequitur here. I was talking about the effects of FDR's New Deal programs and regulations, and Goodyear was just one data-points amongst many(presumably). Even so, why you think mine is a Republican simplification of government programs?
- jbooth 16y agoBecause, respectfully, the entire thought process displayed by your post seems to consist of "government = bad, therefore new deal = bad". It shows very little effort to understand what was actually happening, it boxes a huuuuuge range of possibilities into a simple black/white viewpoint, and it's a silly oversimplification that has high correlation with modern republicans. As far as what the majority of historians said, if it's them or you, and you're not saying something very very persuasive, I'll tend to believe them. No offense intended.
- kiba 16y agoit shows very little effort to understand what was actually happening, it boxes a huuuuuge range of possibilities into a simple black/white viewpoint I do not work on whether a viewpoint is black and white or gray but if it represent the true map of the reality. Such explanations is nonsense to me. and it's a silly oversimplification that has high correlation with modern republicans. You'll need to expand your perimeter on political spectrum. You'll also need to explain why my views is a silly oversimplification.(Err, I mean wrong.)
- anamax 16y ago> As far as what the majority of historians said, if it's them or you, and you're not saying something very very persuasive, I'll tend to believe them. Why? The last time I looked, nothing about history was subject to "nature". If all historians agreed that Hitler had 7 arms and flew, nothing bad would happen. If, on the other hand, engineers decided to act as if steel was less dense than air at 1 bar, things would go wrong.
- timwiseman 16y agoIt depends on how that history is applied. If a false understanding of history is applied in foreign relations, then there are situations where unnecessary wars can be created. If a false understanding of history is applied to military strategy, wars can be needlessly lost. There was a reason that the government created and spent so much on the Ministry of Truth in Orwell's 1984. If you control people's understanding of history, you can have a big impact on what they do in the future.