3 ms·
Do you mean on HN or elsewhere? On HN, a story is scored both on the number of upvotes and on the number of comments. When a story has a lot of comments (in pr
by majewsky 9y ago
Do you mean on HN or elsewhere?
On HN, a story is scored both on the number of upvotes and on the number of comments. When a story has a lot of comments (in proportion to the number of votes), that story is punished based on the idea that it's probably only a few people talking to each other very agitatedly without producing many novel insights.
I have not followed the Google Manifesto discussion, but it's easy to imagine that this prediction holds true in that case.
- onion2k 9y agoWhen a story has a lot of comments (in proportion to the number of votes), that story is punished based on the idea that it's probably only a few people talking to each other very agitatedly without producing many novel insights. Perhaps you're right, but a topic could spark an agitated yet wholly positive discussion. Pushing it down the list just because a few people are commenting a lot wouldn't make much sense in some discussions.
- majewsky 9y agoThat's the problem with algorithms. Even if they're right 90% of the time, the 10% errors are so much more noticeable.