6 ms·
I would never spank my own children, but that's a parenting choice. This societal moralizing about every single aspect of how one should raise their children i
by dasil003 16y ago
I would never spank my own children, but that's a parenting choice. This societal moralizing about every single aspect of how one should raise their children is a big part of the problem described in the article.
For the record, spanking is not necessarily abuse. For you to cite unequivocably that it is is pure unthinking political correctness. Parenting is complicated, psychology is complicated. Is everyone who was born before 1950 irretrievably fucked up? How many of them got spankings?
- bobbin 16y ago> This societal moralizing about every single aspect of how one should raise their children is a big part of the problem described in the article. Well, you are trying to add unearned emphasis with "every single aspect". It's not about "every single aspect", although it is moralizing about compulsion and pain. > For the record, spanking is not necessarily abuse. depends of the definition. > For you to cite unequivocably that it is is pure unthinking political correctness. You don't know how much though I have put into the subject and calling it political correctness is incorrect unless careing about whether or not people use pain and fear to shape children is just political correctness. > Parenting is complicated, psychology is complicated ... > Is everyone who was born before 1950 irretrievably fucked up? I don't know if "irretrievably", but I think almost everyone is psychologically damaged in some way or another.
- dasil003 16y agoWell, you are trying to add unearned emphasis with No, it's fully earned. I am a parent. I have witnessed first hand the moralizing, judgement and mutually contradictory universal expectations that random people have about how childrearing should be done. You don't know how much though I have put into the subject and calling it political correctness is incorrect... Fair enough, you may have put substantial thought into how parenting should work from a theoretical perspective. ...unless careing about whether or not people use pain and fear to shape children is just political correctness Reframing the debate in terms so negative that anyone would appear insane to disagree with them is classic political correctness. I don't know if "irretrievably", but I think almost everyone is psychologically damaged in some way or another. Which raises the question, is your duty as a parent to prevent any and all psychological damage to your child? If the goal is to minimize suffering, then is it better to indulge your child and raise an entitled spoiled individual that will never be satisfied for the rest of their life. Or is it better to "use fear" (the fear of consequences, whatever they may be) to raise a child that has some notion of negative cause and effect?
- bobbin 16y ago> No, it's fully earned. I am a parent. I have witnessed first hand the moralizing, judgement and mutually contradictory universal expectations that random people have about how childrearing should be done. I don't doubt you are an intelligent person, but it's not showing. I hope you consider it as a possible description and not an insult. Let's go by parts: > No, it's fully earned it is objectively unearned. To earn the complaint of "moralizing about every single aspect" I need first to moralize about every single aspect. I moralized about one aspect. > I have witnessed first hand the moralizing, judgement and mutually contradictory universal expectations that random people have about how childrearing should be done. From me? please justify. > Reframing the debate in terms so negative that anyone would appear insane to disagree with them is classic political correctness. Please justify how is it that hitting causing pain is not using hitting and pain to shape children. > Which raises the question, is your duty as a parent to prevent any and all psychological damage to your child? you changed the subject from causing pain as a value in parenting to preventing psychological damage. > If the goal is to minimize suffering, then is it better to indulge your child and raise an entitled spoiled individual that will never be satisfied for the rest of their life. What? you are so far from being able to think about this subject. > Or is it better to "use fear" (the fear of consequences, whatever they may be) to raise a child that has some notion of negative cause and effect? I'm done. You could tell yourself I'm quitting because I don't have an answer. I just realize this subject turns brains off for very good reasons.
- nollidge 16y ago> you may have put substantial thought into how parenting should work from a theoretical perspective. Condescension aside, perhaps bobbin is simply familiar with some of the scientific literature on the subject, such as: http://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2002/06/spanking.aspx http://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2002/06/spanking.aspx > Reframing the debate in terms so negative that anyone would appear insane to disagree with them is classic political correctness. This is only true if the attempt at reframing is disingenuous. What else is corporal punishment but the application of pain in order to elicit fear? > is it better to indulge your child...Or is it better to "use fear" Not hitting a kid is not the same as indulging them. One can be among the strictest of parents without laying a hand on a child.
- fjh 16y ago>For the record, spanking is not necessarily abuse. But giving a 2-year old the "mother of all whoopings" certainly is.
- Tichy 16y agoThink about spanking like this: would you beat up your colleague at work because he won't implement your specifications properly? If no, why not? If yes, would he be more likely to implement your specifications properly after you have beat him up? Would a kid be more likely to understand your arguments than your colleague? If no, why would he be more likely to respond to spanking? Ultimately, how can it really be justified to spank a kid???