3 ms·
I'm going to say something contraversial, let's allow it for the sake of discussion. Is a biased pipeline even a problem? What are we trying to solve? It seem
by OJFord 9y ago
I'm going to say something contraversial, let's allow it for the sake of discussion.
Is a biased pipeline even a problem? What are we trying to solve?
It seems there are separate issues: equal numbers, we need to tackle the pipeline and convince women STEM is great; what happens happens, we need to not be biased against a gender and admit proportional to applications.
I can see both sides; I think in different moods I ultimately agree with either.
At the moment, I think if we spend long enough with admission (universities, jobs whatever) reflecting competence in the pipeline, then the pipeline will gradually come to reflect the proportion that's interested - 50:50 or not (either way around).
- literallycancer 9y ago>we need to tackle the pipeline and convince women STEM is great "Great" is necessarily a function with (at least) 2 inputs, the thing being considered, and the person considering it (or their goals). Who is more likely to have a better job security, a STEM graduate or a med school graduate? What are the failure modes of each? Is a QA career better, or worse than that of a nurse (just spit-balling here, it might very well be the other way around)? -- I'd argue that men are more likely to be the risk takers, for evolutionary reasons. It makes perfect sense that they go for a career with lower chance at a bigger win. Less to lose -> take more risks. Now, if you are a woman, you are extremely likely to have a quality of life higher than the average man. Why would you take risks when you don't need to?
- gaius 9y agoWho is more likely to have a better job security, a STEM graduate or a med school graduate? That is the elephant in the corner of the room, isn't it? Maybe it's not the women are irrationally opting out of tech. Maybe it's the men are irrationally opting in?
- therebedragons 9y ago> What are we trying to solve? Lets stop there. What are we trying to solve? I'd say we are trying to solve this question: What makes a good life? STEM gets a lot of press because, obviously, it is a well paid field. However, the answer to what makes a good life is not just money. I'd wager it is (almost) universally agreed that a good life consists of: (1) Enough money (see below), (2) a career you enjoy, (3) free time to pursue things you enjoy outside work, (4) good health ((4a) mental and (4b) physical) and (5) connections with other humans. Maybe people can quibble with this to some degree, but I think that is about as uncontroversial as anyone can be on the subject of a good life. Accepting my definition for the sake of argument, how does a gender imbalance in STEM affect this? Does a STEM career affect all 5 of those elements? Just some? Just others? Certainly, a career in STEM provides "enough money". But is it a career EVERYONE will enjoy? Do you get a lot of free time? It seems rather unhealthy as well - there aren't a lot of healthy people in offices in general. As for connections, YMMV on that one. I think we focus too much on money because it is so easily measured. But more money beyond about $75K in the USA doesn't appear to make people more happy: http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2019628,00.html http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2019628... If you make above $75K, then surely that is the time to optimise the hours of your day not towards making more money, but to add more of the other 4 elements of a good life. STEM is not a panacea, and money is not the be all and end all of life. Trading better financial security for health, a career you enjoy and more free time and personal connections may be a sensible decision. I'm not convinced more people would enjoy STEM careers, any more than I think everyone would enjoy being a special units detective, and dealing with a lot of awfulness.
- rayiner 9y agoThere are other studies that show increased life satisfaction with increased income well past $500k/year.
- therebedragons 9y agoWhich you can't show me? Even if I accept that, even if that is true, is it better to make more and lose the other four dimensions? I can see where NOT making more is better for a person, if they can optmise some other element of their lives.
- pw 9y agoThat's interesting 'cause the $75k figure/study is so commonly cited.
- weberc2 9y agoWell said. STEM is neat, but I don't think it's necessarily what every woman (or man, for that matter) is really missing in her life. > We focus on money because it's easy to measure My inner cynic thinks it's because it's the disparity that's politically expedient. Lots of other disparities are easy to measure (flexibility, workplace injuries and fatalities, etc), but we don't post much attention to those... :/
- rayiner 9y agoYes, a biased pipeline is absolutely something that needs to be solved. Society should permit and facilitate people living their best lives and maximizing their potential. I found programming both incredibly rewarding and a wonderful way to jump start my career. So if there are lots of girls who would feel the same way if society didn't bias them against the profession from an early age, that's wrong and it needs to be fixed. The idea that women want different things than men is pernicious and it's not something we should accept without proof. For a long time we rationalized keeping women out of the work force by saying that they preferred focusing on the home. Yet, I know more stay at home moms that are bitter about having given up their career than the other way around. It's a lie we told ourselves to justify a social arrangement that disempowered women. We should know by now not to fall prey to that sort of thinking.
- home_boi 9y ago> Yes, a biased pipeline is absolutely something that needs to be solved. No it doesn't. Bias isn't always bad or oppressive. It needs to be proven that the bias is "bad". If rich kids are underrepresented in tech because their families have connections in finance and they tend to major in finance more often, is this a problem that needs to be solved? Frat bros are underrepresented in engineering in tech atm. HR, recruiting and hundreds of other job families and careers have "biased pipelines". Should resources be spent to solve all of them? Why only tech?
- tptacek 9y agoNo matter which injustice we choose to address, there will always be other injustices unaddressed, many of them horrible.
- gehwartzen 9y agoSo the goal for our society should be that the pipeline for every job from janitor to engineer to CEO should have a sex balanced pipeline? Or is there something special about programming? The goal should be that everyone can freely decide which career path they want to join regardless of how the ratios in the final pipeline look.