5 ms·
Aren't companies like McKinsey more efficient? They have the rule that you either get better and a promotion or you will be fired. So they only keep people th
by k__ 9y ago
Aren't companies like McKinsey more efficient?
They have the rule that you either get better and a promotion or you will be fired.
So they only keep people that improve every year or they get new people.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> They have the rule that you either get better and a promotion or you will be fired. The conventional term for this is "up or out".
- k__ 9y agoYes, but why aren't other companies do this?
- Applejinx 9y agoBecause that's also a mistake: the problem there is, you cannot keep a person doing something they're optimal for if you need to continually promote them. One of the holy grails of effectiveness at doing stuff is having some comprehension of your boundaries. To categorically disavow even the concept of boundaries is catastrophically silly.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoUp-or-out relies on a constant intake of new staff. You'll have to do a lot more hiring, and you're applying a pretty strong personality filter on the company. And as Applejinx says, the fact that someone isn't suited to the role above them doesn't mean they aren't suited to their current role. Up-or-out means tossing out the guy who knows his job well and is doing it well to replace him with someone who's never done it before and needs a training period; this is significant overhead applied to every job in the company.
- sjg007 9y agoNo. The partner model is different. Tech companies are keeping talent on the bench. McKinsey and co turn over hardworking younglins.
- k__ 9y agoDifferent from what I said?
- richardknop 9y agoOh no. Companies like McKinsey / Accenture etc are not more efficient. Their bureaucracies and inefficiencies are way worse than tech companies like Facebook or Google.
- k__ 9y agoI see. The whole up or out principle sounded rather efficient to me.