3 ms·
Managers in large companies will push anything in a top-down fashion. Before, they pushed waterfall. Now, they are pushing something they call Agile. (They do,
by wpietri 9y ago
Managers in large companies will push anything in a top-down fashion. Before, they pushed waterfall. Now, they are pushing something they call Agile. (They do, I don't.) In 5 years, the consultant-managerial complex will push something else. I agree that is bad. [1]
But the top-down thing is explicitly not what the Agile movement was about. As the early Extreme Programming community would say, "By-the-book Extreme Programming is where we suggest you start, but it's definitely not where you should end up." The notion was always that teams would take time every iteration to look at how they were working and improve it to match local conditions.
That was definitely true even at the beginning; "self-organizing teams" was one of the principles from 2001: http://agilemanifesto.org/principles.html http://agilemanifesto.org/principles.html
So the way to think about it isn't in terms of manager interventions. It's in terms of those non-interchangeable teams experimenting and then sharing what they've learned with other teams. Teams will learn things! Some of those things will apply to other teams. A few will apply widely. And that's exactly how the good Agile teams work today. They may start from some recommended set of practices, just like any novice does while learning things. But they are supposed to evolve from there to match local talent and conditions.
[1] I've written more about that here: http://agilefocus.com/2011/02/21/agiles-second-chasm-and-how-we-fell-in/ http://agilefocus.com/2011/02/21/agiles-second-chasm-and-how...