7 ms·
Put me in the camp that's very anti-AirBnB as a resident who doesn't want where I lived turned into a hotel. I live in NYC. It's a problem. The real problem he
by jseliger 9y ago
Put me in the camp that's very anti-AirBnB as a resident who doesn't want where I lived turned into a hotel. I live in NYC. It's a problem.
The real problem here is not Airbnb, which is a symptom; it's zoning, which forbids market-clearing prices and a sufficient number of units to satisfy demand for living in and visiting the city.
For more on this, see e.g. Matt Yglesias's The Rent is Too Damn High: https://www.amazon.com/Rent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957 https://www.amazon.com/Rent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp/B... .
When we have sane zoning, we'll have sane prices. Today there was an NYT opinion piece that comes at the issue from a racial angle: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/03/opinion/sunday/zoning-laws-segregation-income.html?ref=opinion&_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/03/opinion/sunday/zoning-law... but I don't think we even need the racial angle; we can come at it from a position of fundamental justice and human flourishing.
- teslaberry 9y agoYes and by nature too much money is at stake. Government in nyc is thus unreparably corrupt. The only practical answer is to simply shrink governmemt so that ethical, yet illega, behavior can flourish. Society is not built on law, it is built on willpower. If you have the will to compete against the hotel lobby and corrupt government, more power to you.
- yuhong 9y agoI do wonder what if there was a actual spot and contract market for housing like there is for DRAM, with zoning entirely unrestricted and free market.
- mschuster91 9y ago> it's zoning, which forbids market-clearing prices and a sufficient number of units to satisfy demand for living in and visiting the city. lol tourists and rich investors/other rich undesirables are ALWAYS going to outprice the lower and middle tiers, you need massive amounts of regulation to prevent rich-people-only city areas.
- tdb7893 9y agoI'm not sure what regulations can keep the price down without having lots of weird scenarios and adverse effects. If you can then that's great but I haven't seen it work in practice yet. It makes more sense to me to try to increase the supply of housing
- jseliger 9y agolol tourists and rich investors/other rich undesirables are ALWAYS going to outprice the lower and middle tiers, you need massive amounts of regulation to prevent rich-people-only city areas. Really? Was that true in the 1970s or 80s? https://jakeseliger.com/2015/12/27/why-did-cities-freeze-in-the-1970s/ https://jakeseliger.com/2015/12/27/why-did-cities-freeze-in-... If not, what might have changed between then and now?
- wpietri 9y agoI think the 70s and 80s were anomalous. White flight caused many major US cities to take a big dip in population and wealth: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight
- crdoconnor 9y ago* Taxes on property reduced, turning it into a more desirable asset to hoard. * Wealth inequality went through the wealth meaning more wealth seeking hoardable assets (bitcoin is also part of this phenomena, imo). * Governments stopped building social housing, cutting off supply of new apartments. Airbnb squeezing people out and low interest rates are symptoms of this phenomenon. Cutting zoning restrictions is just what property developers like to blame it on because it acts as an impediment to them building more profitable luxury developments. For some reason people listen to them.
- mschuster91 9y ago> If not, what might have changed between then and now? I think that what we're seeing today is what happened back in '70, just in extreme overdrive. Mainy caused, imho, by a massive explosion of the amount of money in circulation, which craves to be invested. Given that Yo could get 1.5M$ at 10M$ valuation, there's nothing better in the current ultra-low-interest environment than to invest the money in housing stock. Also, the massive flow of capital from new-rich Chinese and Russians (which mainly affected London, but side flows also hit Berlin and Frankfurt) is a factor.
- tptacek 9y agoThere is no hotel zoning that any city would come up with that would allow for the creation of one-room hotels in the middle of condo and apartment buildings.
- closeparen 9y agoSure, but Airbnb is (from one angle) just a weird and hacky way of adding more hotel rooms to a city's supply. Zoning that permitted more and taller hotels could meet demand with fewer negative externalities. Similarly, relaxed zoning for residential buildings could lower the size of the effect on the housing market when a unit is converted to Airbnb use.
- tptacek 9y agoYou're fleeing to abstraction. I'm making a simple point, derived from the specific complaint that my NYC friends have about Airbnb: there is no plausible change to hotel regulation that would ever allow people to open up single-room hotels in apartment and condo buildings.
- closeparen 9y agoSure. There is a plausible change that would remove the impetus to do so. I don't think anyone is suggesting that zoning should endorse Airbnb-style "hotels," but that maybe it should fix the underlying problems instead of just patching the loophole.
- tptacek 9y agoThat's a false dilemma. The problem we're discussing here is easily fixed by making short-term rentals in apartment and condo buildings unlawful, which is probably what will end up happening. There's nothing that says that can't happen independent of any other regulatory changes.
- bradleyjg 9y ago
- bogomipz 9y ago>"The real problem here is not Airbnb, which is a symptom; it's zoning, which forbids market-clearing prices and a sufficient number of units to satisfy demand for living in and visiting the city." Maybe you haven't been to NYC in a while? This is not the case at all. New York City has undergone a hotel boom over the last 7-8 years, so much so that it has actually driven down the price of hotels: See: https://ny.curbed.com/2016/4/20/11471644/new-york-city-hotel-boom-ending https://ny.curbed.com/2016/4/20/11471644/new-york-city-hotel... and http://www.wnyc.org/story/new-york-citys-hotel-boom-keeping-prices-down/ http://www.wnyc.org/story/new-york-citys-hotel-boom-keeping-... Zoning a problems in NYC? The amount of condos and pace of real-estate development in NYC is head spinning. I can't think of another city that is more developer friendly. In fact developers have even been entitled to tax subsidies for their efforts. See: https://ny.curbed.com/2016/1/15/10846176/everything-you-need-to-know-about-nycs-421-a-tax-program-poised-to https://ny.curbed.com/2016/1/15/10846176/everything-you-need...
- Markoff 9y agosolution to this issue is not using substitute company which will break laws instead of you, but voting for representatives who will change laws the way you want apparently you are in minority if it's not happening and it doesn't justify breaking the law
- cardiffspaceman 9y agoSo it seems to me the sequence is: a) You have a decent city with reasonable rents b) AirBNB c) Same city with outrageous rents -- Choose either -- d1) Now we have to change the building codes and wait for the effect of the invisible hand to complete the massive change to the city so that there is a huge new housing stock at the same rents as before -- or Choose -- d2) Now we have to ban AirBNB and have the city return to its original reasonable state. Forget for the moment the NYMBYist case for (d2). What about the tourist case? Is a tourist just as interested in the new form of the city with four additional new stories on every residential acre plus the increased grocery stores? What about the rest of the infrastructure that has to be built to support all this density? Is the open-minded local commuter going to want to continue to live in the (d1) environment as it grows more and more dense and commutes (on foot and by subway) grow worse and worse? Is this really "flourishing" or just the shortest path to a Blade Runner set with actual people?