4 ms·
How hard is it for the author to say "I'm writing a piece on you and would like some clarification on some points"? He never told them he was writing a piece a
by StavrosK 9y ago
How hard is it for the author to say "I'm writing a piece on you and would like some clarification on some points"?
He never told them he was writing a piece and gave them a chance to read it or comment, AFAICT.
- FRex 9y agoI see, schrödinger companies. The answer to a question (that isn't any company secret but a simple question) is totally different depending on you being a client vs. being a journalist.
- StavrosK 9y agoI don't so much see the answer as being totally different as I see the amount of effort going into the answer varying wildly.
- thanksgiving 9y agoShould Consumer Review disclose the fact that they will review the car when they buy a car from a dealership?
- StavrosK 9y agoThe author didn't review the service, he basically assumed many things about the inner workings and didn't give the company a chance to clarify. Consumer Review doesn't have to disclose the fact that they will review a car when they buy it from a dealership, but they probably should ask GM to comment when they say "it seems to us, without having driven one or heard from anyone who has driven one, that GM are making their cars so they explode on impact".
- thanksgiving 9y ago> Consumer Review doesn't have to disclose the fact that they will review a car when they buy it from a dealership, but they probably should ask GM to comment when they say "it seems to us, without having driven one or heard from anyone who has driven one, that GM are making their cars so they explode on impact". Do they have to disclose that they are Consumer Review when they talk to GM?
- bogomipz 9y agoOr the CEO of Airmule could have take a few seconds to look at the Twitter profile of the user asking questions before responding publicly. The Twtitter profile for user @TPrphet states that he is a blogger for a site called Seat31B. Also the blogger may not have had any intention of writing a blog post prior to the exchange.
- tprophet 9y agoAs a startup founder myself, I don't take writing a negative post about another startup lightly. That being said, I always reserve the right to blog about anything I think is interesting or important to my readers, and this subject meets the bar given the seriousness of the potential consequences here. "Move fast and break things" is something you can do in a social app but lives are potentially at stake here. It's also fair for me to move quickly. Airmule is out in public advertising $99 flights to Beijing right now. Why should I have to wait until Rory is back in the office on Monday to write about it? It's fairly normal to write blog posts without interviewing anyone. If the facts are clear, why spend the time? There isn't a law that says that I have to schedule an interview with an airline before I blog about their economy class cabin, and there isn't a law that says I have to schedule an interview with a startup founder around his backyard tile laying project and Costco shopping trip. Note that my readers are largely young backpackers - think the /r/shoestring and /r/solotravel crowd. I would have written an entirely different blog post--and one that the founder would have been completely happy with--if the answers had been different. It's unfortunate that they weren't.