4 ms·
A Bizarre USC Case Shows How Broken Title IX Enforcement Is
- Overtonwindow 9y agoMany ages ago I served as defense counsel, of sorts, at a judiciary board hearing at my university. A young man was accused of stealing textbooks from the campus bookstore, and selling them back. I was given wide latitude to investigate, and I poked a ton of holes into that, found there was zero evidence of the crime. Pure suspicion and assumption. Yet he was suspended for a semester having been found guilty, reasoning it was "more likely than not" he committed the offense. This was absolutely laughable. I am reminded of this because universities have become adverse to conflict resolution, and conditioned to believe ever accusation, and every "victim" no matter the evidence.
- ubernostrum 9y agoDon't look now, but you're alleging the "believe every victim" (with scary air-quotes, no less!) in discussion of a story which alleges the problem of refusing to believe the person the university said was a victim.
- tbrownaw 9y agoBut they are believe the accusation regardless of evidence, it's just that this case is odd in that the accusation for once isn't coming from the "victim".
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI could have said things better, as I was trying to make a point about the dispute/discipline procedure of a major university. The victim, IMHO, in this instance is the student. The school believes they are the victim, but they also happen to be the judge and jury. I found the process, the evidence procedures, finding of fact, and guilt, to be seriously flawed.
- jancsika 9y agoI'd like to attempt to do a complete end run around the impending anecdote war and ask: how the hell are academic professors, lecturers, staff, and students agreeing to serve in a position of power where they make recommendations/findings/whatever on potentially criminal acts by university students without having any expertise whatsoever in criminal law? If one sits on a university panel and is shown evidence that one student raped another student, how is one's next action not to go to the police station and hand over that exact same evidence? If one is not being shown any actual evidence, how can one possibly rationalize participating in such a proceeding? If you are an academic and have served in this capacity, please explain to me how your decision was motivated by anything other than a desire not to rock the boat. Please also explain how serving in a non-expert position of power over students who have potentially committed criminal acts is compatible with being a humble and conscientious scholar.
- extra88 9y agoThey don't operate with a criminal court's standard of evidence and the punishment meted out is not criminal punishment. The accuser is free to go to the police in addition to the school's administration, if they chose not to it would be wrong for others to do so. Say you had some friends over including someone you don't know well and a while later you discovered something valuable was missing. You think that person may have taken it because you don't know them well and they had the opportunity, would you not hesitate invite them over because you have no evidence? "Innocent until proven guilty" is a cornerstone of our criminal legal system but not every judgement can, or should, be based on the same standard. I'm not comfortable with the position school administrations are put in but recognize that often times it's better than counting on the criminal justice system in a timely fashion.