4 ms·
> Helmets are pretty misunderstood. They don't offer much in the way of protection in a serious accident Have you got a source for that claim? http://bhsi.org
by dahart 9y ago
> Helmets are pretty misunderstood. They don't offer much in the way of protection in a serious accident
Have you got a source for that claim?
http://bhsi.org/stats.htm#effectiveness http://bhsi.org/stats.htm#effectiveness
"Helmets provide a 66 to 88% reduction in the risk of head, brain and severe brain injury for all ages of bicyclists. Helmets provide equal levels of protection for crashes involving motor vehicles (69%) and crashes from all other causes (68%). Injuries to the upper and mid facial areas are reduced 65%.
Authors' conclusions
Helmets reduce bicycle-related head and facial injuries for bicyclists of all ages involved in all types of crashes, including those involving motor vehicles. Our response to comments from critics are presented in the Feedback section.
Plain Language Summary
Wearing a helmet dramatically reduces the risk of head and facial injuries for bicyclists involved in a crash, even if it involves a motor vehicle."
- exceptione 9y agoYou are referring to the US situation. As a dutchie, I wouldn't even want to bike with a helmet in the US. Of course, helmets work to an extent when the conditions are extremely hostile. They have (limited) value. True. The solution isn't to leave the unsafe conditions untouched and protect just a part of the body by means of a helmet, rather it is making the driving conditions for bikers safe. As it turns out, those safe conditions render the helmet as unnecesary. As pointed out, helmets could be a net loss in safety in a safe biker environment. Biker helmets are a sign of bad road safety.
- rsfern 9y agoI agree with you that having all cyclists wear helmets wouldn't strictly increase overall safety (maybe people will switch to driving...), but I think you're discounting the utility of helmets even where collisions with motorized vehicles isn't the primary risk. Here are stats from the Netherlands [0]. Looks like there are about 9000 serious crashes each year that don't involve motor vehicles, with about 2500 cases annually of head/brain injury. That's actually a much higher rate than for crashes involving cars in the Netherlands, presumably because of the infrastructure and culture.... [0]: https://www.swov.nl/en/facts-figures/factsheet/bicycle-helmets https://www.swov.nl/en/facts-figures/factsheet/bicycle-helme...
- mahyarm 9y agoEven if your the only person on a closed smooth track, you can get a pretty bad TBI injury if you crash. Wear a helmet for yourself, not because it's against the culture of where you live. Look at this guy without a helmet get one because he screwed up on a track: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVZz8EN_NKw&feature=youtu.be&t=508 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVZz8EN_NKw&feature=youtu.be... The crash didn't look that bad, but it was enough.
- sndean 9y ago> Even if your the only person on a closed smooth track, you can get a pretty bad TBI injury if you crash. Yeah, or in my experience on the W&OD bike trail (largely just people on bikes), you can easily hit a rock or a deer and go sideways. It's more likely to break a collar bone than hit your head, but it's probably smart to have a helmet on.
- Fricken 9y agoWe always go off about helmets, no one talks about learning how to wipe out. That guy didn't know how to go to the ground correctly. Getting on a skateboard or a bike without having learned how to wipeout is about as irresponsible as going into a boxing match not knowing how to dodge or block a punch. Like, if there was a match between a guy with a helmet and no boxing experience, and a guy with no helmet but plenty of boxing experience, who would you bet on? Pro skateboarders and BMXers rarely wear helmets and regularly walk away from spectacular, cringe inducing accidents that would kill or cripple a less skilled individual, and of course, they've been mastering the art of wiping out for as long as they've been riding. A friend of mine once stood on a skateboard for not even 2 seconds before it rolled out from under him, he fell back and broke his elbow, he just hadn't conditioned himself to react properly in that situation. I saw another guy on a bike go sailing over the hood of a car that cut him off, and he did a face-plant on the other side, he didn't think to tuck his head or get his arms between himself and the pavement. His face was all bloody and his front teeth were knocked out, his helmet didn't do him much good. Being able to react instinctively to something like that takes training. Strapping some styrofoam to your head is probably better than nothing, but framing bicycle safety as a binary depending on whether someone has a helmet on is a gross oversimplification. Between skateboarding, various styles of cycling, and general horsing around I've had hundreds, if not thousands of wipeouts and the only time I suffered a concussion was when I was mugged by a guy who came up behind me.
- halostatue 9y agoMy wife’s German cousin had a low-speed fall off his bike and only avoided life-altering injury because he was wearing a helmet. Even with the helmet, he had fairly serious head trauma and it was touch-and-go. Without the helmet, everyone is pretty certain he would not have survived the fall.
- vacri 9y ago> As it turns out, those safe conditions render the helmet as unnecesary. One wonders why competitive track cyclists wear helmets, then? After all, no-one is on the track but the cyclists, all moving predictably, and they minimise the weight of everything else... so why not lose another 400 grams from their race weight?
- stordoff 9y ago[1] suggests that a suitably designed helmet reduces drag by a fair amount, which probably offsets the weight increase. [1] https://ir.canterbury.ac.nz/bitstream/handle/10092/7804/Thesis_fulltext.pdf https://ir.canterbury.ac.nz/bitstream/handle/10092/7804/Thes...
- dahart 9y agoDepends on where in the US you ride. Lots of cities are getting better very quickly, thankfully. There have been large changes in the last 5 years. > As pointed out, helmets could be a net loss in safety in a safe biker environment. I haven't seen any data on this yet. Do you have a source for this claim? I don't buy it. > Biker helmets are a sign of bad road safety. Bike helmets are a sign of someone who knows that the energy of impact is proportional to mass times the square of velocity. Every doubling of your speed does 4x damage if you crash. I've crashed my bike on my own probably 10x more than because of someone else. Hitting debris, riding in the rain, riding at night, unseen obstacles, railroad tracks, animals, mountain biking trails, all things that have taken me down. If I didn't have a helmet, I think I'd have cracked my own nut a long time ago, and road safety would have little to do with it. You can go without if you think it's somehow safer, I'm happy to wear mine.
- u801e 9y ago>> Helmets are pretty misunderstood. They don't offer much in the way of protection in a serious accident > Have you got a source for that claim? The CPSC (Consumer Products Safety Commission) impact testing standards for bicycle helmets only require that the pass tests like a guided free fall on a weighted headform from a height of about 6.5 feet. That's the equivalent of falling over from a trackstand, for example. If you're going at speed or are hit by a car, the forces the helmet will experience will far exceed the force generated by the impact tests as specified above.
- dahart 9y agoThat's true. But the numbers I cited above came from actual collisions, not from CPSC testing. The actual fatality rate when cars are involved is considerably lower with a helmet, verified many times over across many studies.
- stordoff 9y ago> If you're going at speed or are hit by a car, the forces the helmet will experience will far exceed the force generated by the impact tests as specified above Does that matter? It may not be ideal, but even a helmet that only meets those requirements is going to _reduce_ the force experienced if you land on it. My dad was in a crash with a car (impacted the side of the vehicle, went over the top and landed on the other side) - his helmet was cracked into three pieces, but he was fine. I find it difficult to picture him avoiding some sort of head injury without the helmet.
- u801e 9y ago> It may not be ideal, but even a helmet that only meets those requirements is going to _reduce_ the force experienced if you land on it. My dad was in a crash with a car (impacted the side of the vehicle, went over the top and landed on the other side) - his helmet was cracked into three pieces, but he was fine. From [1]: >> The principal protection mechanism in a cycle helmet is the polystyrene foam, or styrofoam, that covers the head. When this receives a direct impact force, the styrofoam is intended to compress and in this way spread and reduce the force that is passed onto the skull, thus reducing linear accleration of the brain. >> However, it is common for helmets to break without the polystyrene foam compressing at all. A major helmet manufacturer collected damaged childrens' helmets for investigation over several months. According to their senior engineer, in that time they did not see any helmet showing signs of crushing on the inside (Sundahl, 1998). Helmet foam does not 'rebound' after compression to any significant extent. If the styrofoam does not compress, it cannot reduce linear acceleration of the brain. The most protection that it can give to the wearer is to prevent focal damage of the skull and prevent minor wounds to the scalp. It is not likely to prevent serious brain injury. [1] http://www.cyclehelmets.org/1209.html http://www.cyclehelmets.org/1209.html
- u801e 9y ago> "Helmets provide a 66 to 88% reduction in the risk of head, brain and severe brain injury for all ages of bicyclists. Helmets provide equal levels of protection for crashes involving motor vehicles (69%) and crashes from all other causes (68%). Injuries to the upper and mid facial areas are reduced 65%. There has been criticism of that study, some of which is listed in [1]. [1] http://www.cyclehelmets.org/1131.html http://www.cyclehelmets.org/1131.html
- dahart 9y agoThat criticizes a 1989 paper. The snippet that I used and you just quoted are from a 1999 paper by the same authors, and the critique you linked on cyclehelmets.org isn't addressing the updated language. The critique also doesn't challenge the conclusion, it's challenging the specific degree, getting into the weeds on the numbers and the subtler points of methodology. It looks to me like the page you linked even provides links to other papers that came to the same basic conclusion that helmets reduce risk of death, in the event of a crash. "Government agencies withdraw support for 85% claim" That's a pretty misleading statement considering it leaves out the fact that the NHTSA and CDC both still quote Thompson 1999 and both have strong and unambiguous pro-helmet recommendations. Cyclehelmets.org says they are not helmet skeptics, that their beef is only to correct the science. Is that the same goal you have? Do you think that people should or should not wear helmets? Are you policing what you think is bad science? I ride bikes a lot. I've crashed a lot. I've seen other people crash a lot. I've seen head injuries and concussions with and without helmets. I honestly don't really care to debate the science at this level, because I didn't perform any studies myself and I don't research helmet effectiveness or policy. Do you? Do you ride bikes and want others to ride bikes? Are you upset about mandatory helmet laws or something like that? What does this debate mean to you?
- u801e 9y ago> That criticizes a 1989 paper. The snippet that I used and you just quoted are from a 1999 paper by the same authors, and the critique you linked on cyclehelmets.org isn't addressing the updated language. I didn't click through enough links to check the year and only checked the author names and found the 1989 study. Through more searching, I found the pdf of the actual study you referenced and checked through the studies that they referenced in their analysis. Most of those source studies have corresponding analysis pages on the cyclehelmets.org website with similar types of criticisms. > Do you think that people should or should not wear helmets? I really am not concerned about whether or not bicycle riders wear helmets while riding. But I think it's a disservice to cyclists to imply that wearing a helmet is the only thing that matters in terms of safety. I would like to see more emphasis on other things like bicycle maintenance, equipment like lights and a mirror and education on how one should ride their bike on MUPs and in traffic, but it seems that the debate on helmets has overshadowed the other things that can have a greater impact on the safety of the rider. > I ride bikes a lot. I've crashed a lot. I ride roughly 2000 miles per year (for the last 12 years). I've only crashed once. > I honestly don't really care to debate the science at this level, because I didn't perform any studies myself and I don't research helmet effectiveness I am interested in reading research on helmet effectiveness, critiques of that research as it pertains to study methodology and standards that helmets are required to meet in the US. I think it's necessary to have that knowledge and keep up to date on the field to really have informative discussions on the issue.