14 ms·
Publii – Open Source CMS for Static Websites
- petepete 9y agoCan't seem to find a link to the repo on their site.
- klint 9y agoI hope someone posts it soon. This sounds like a dream come true, but I'm a bit weary of punching my SFTP credentials into an app by an unknown company without any idea of what it's actually doing behind the scenes.
- irishasaurus 9y agoNo Linux option planned, and no public access to the source-code. That doesn't feel very "open source" to me.
- thefreeman 9y agohow can they possibly call it open source without providing the source code. Also on the website it says it is licensed under GPL, doesn't that entitle users to source code access?
- johnchristopher 9y ago> Also on the website it says it is licensed under GPL, doesn't that entitle users to source code access? What ? Why entitled ? I have some WIP and production ready code in some git repo on my company's network and it's MIT licensed but there is absolutely zero obligation to upload it on the internet. Of course I don't go around making website about it so there's that. Pretty sure those guys will upload the source code when they feel like it's the time to do it.
- masukomi 9y agothe GPL requires that you make the code available WHEN you distribute it. they have distributed it, thus yes, we are entitled to it as of the time of distribution, not whenever they feel like it in the future.
- true_religion 9y agoNot really in the way you are implying. You can either distribute it with the binary, or you can distribute it to someone who received a binary once they request it. The GPL doesn't require you post the source on GitHub or the internet at all.
- bachmeier 9y agoThe GPL applies to other users. There's no such thing as a license that applies to the person that wrote the code (that would imply that you could sue yourself for violations). They'd only be required to make the source available if they were using someone else's GPL code.
- cyphar 9y agoThat is incorrect. If a company gives you a copy of the program under the GPL, then they must obey by that license because they made an implicit agreement with you to obey that license. And you can't call any other license the GPL (modifications are not permitted by the FSF). Ultimately it does become a matter of "suing the copyright holder for a license granted by that copyright holder", but it's definitely still not okay. By that logic, no copyright license can ever be expected to be honoured by the original author -- because "they own the copyright and thus cannot be sued for breach of license". Not to mention that you don't know why they went with the GPL. Maybe they used some GPL code and thus have no choice in the license terms. So it would be a matter of the original copyright holders suing them for breach of license.
- zokier 9y ago> Ultimately it does become a matter of "suing the copyright holder for a license granted by that copyright holder", but it's definitely still not okay. By that logic, no copyright license can ever be expected to be honoured by the original author -- because "they own the copyright and thus cannot be sued for breach of license". If the license promised delivery of source code then of course the author could be sued. But as far as I can tell, GPL (at least v3) makes no such promises. If you disagree, please point in the license text the part that you think applies.
- rubenbe 9y agoGPL does not mean that the company has to provide a github repo. Strictly seen, the sources should be provided in case a user requests the them. (IANAL) But I agree, it doesn't feel very "open source"
- megido 9y agoThere's a github account, but no repo published :/ https://github.com/GetPublii https://github.com/GetPublii
- rhblake 9y agoIt's an Electron app so the source code comes with the package. They've also tweeted "We have a plan release it for Linux with the first stable version" [0] and that a proper source code release is planned. [1] Haven't tried it myself. [0] https://twitter.com/GetPublii/status/878563554118561792 https://twitter.com/GetPublii/status/878563554118561792 [1] https://twitter.com/GetPublii/status/871670397145665537 https://twitter.com/GetPublii/status/871670397145665537
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fiatjaf 9y agoIt is not the CMS, it is also the site generator which comes with its own themes.
- gtirloni 9y agoThe license is GPL but I can't find the code repository anywhere. We'd love do ditch WordPress but our users demand a web-ish interface to work with static sites. This could be it. Also, what's the strategy for plugins?
- vbernat 9y agoAnother (similar) option would be Lektor: https://www.getlektor.com/ https://www.getlektor.com/
- fiatjaf 9y agoOr you could use my https://github.com/fiatjaf/coisas https://github.com/fiatjaf/coisas
- xorcist 9y agoI have had good experience with Lektor (getlektor.com) for small sites where I don't really want Wordpress. It's simple, drop it in and run, it's quite mature and you can write plugins in Python.
- bedros 9y agothis looks amazing, do they have sample templates for blogs
- animesh 9y agoIf you meant theming, you would have to do it yourself. If you meant how to setup a blog, it is fairly simple (https://www.getlektor.com/docs/guides/blog/ https://www.getlektor.com/docs/guides/blog/).
- zokier 9y agoI would love to see a prepackaged full-featured blog engine built on top of Lektor. Lektor seems great and all, but it is really more of a framework than ready-to-use thing.
- nik736 9y agoThe concept is not bad, but how do I change the actual looks of my site? Can't I edit the frontend somehow?
- aphextron 9y agoWhere is the repo? I can't seem to find any info on the site or Google.
- johnchristopher 9y agoThey actually support many languages out of the box (Ghost doesn't). I'll be exploring it this evening, looks nice and tidy.
- Exuma 9y agoThe themes are absolutely incredible... for once I'm actually impressed!
- jacobwilliamroy 9y agoHere is a link to an interaction between a user and developer from June 23rd 2017 RE: publii source code: https://publii.ticksy.com/ticket/1216232/ https://publii.ticksy.com/ticket/1216232/ From Bob: "We still preparing the dev documentation and I think it will be ready this holiday. Right now you can browse the themes packages and see how they are built. Below you can download the .pdf with handlebars tags used in Publii themes. https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B92PpHk85ShpZk50NVFVQlZjX3c/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B92PpHk85ShpZk50NVFVQlZjX3c... Referring to repository question, we will need to reflect further on this matter, but probably the GitHub is the best solution for that."
- hetfeld 9y agoOpen Source in 2017...
- Jedd 9y ago> ... be ready this holiday. I think everyone needs to spend a year living in the other hemisphere so they know to never again announce something on the Internet as 'happening in summer' or 'ready this holiday'. 'Open-Source' appears six times on the posted page (source). With a properly versioned web page I would have expected it would be easy to publish that as 'Soon-to-be-open-source' and change that to 'Open-source' when it actually is. (Usual ambiguities about what 'open source' actually means to one side.) Having said that, it does look like a lovely interface, and a good way to manage static sites -- though without a GNU/Linux release I won't be able to try it out.
- jacobwilliamroy 9y agoUPDATE (I can't edit my original comment): Apparently the source code comes with the app: From Bob: "Hi Guys, Publii is built with Electron, so the source code is available, you can read it directly after installing the app. Here is where the files are located: ;https://getpublii.com/docs/install-publii.html https://getpublii.com/docs/install-publii.html We know that there is no source code repository, we will publish it soon, but before that we have to finish work on the implementation some key features and polish the code. The next release will bring a dev documentation with the Starter theme, I hope this will help you to better understand app and find out how the themes are built." https://publii.ticksy.com/ticket/1265759 https://publii.ticksy.com/ticket/1265759
- ryanashcraft 9y agoI definitely think there's demand for solutions like this. I probably would like this even better if it worked on top of an existing static-site generator platform like Jekyll or Gatsby. I just wrote about immutable deployments with Ghost 1.0, which is also open source (MIT licensed), and how that can be a nice compromise between static sites and hosted CMSes: https://ryanashcraft.me/ghost-and-now/ https://ryanashcraft.me/ghost-and-now/ I might've tried Publii out if I had heard about it beforehand, but right now I'm really happy with the entire Ghost editing and consumption experience I've set up (thanks to the Ghost and Zeit teams).
- indigodaddy 9y agoAwesome post Ryan, I really like your approach! I just found out about now.sh the other day, and found its features and capabilities to be very exciting, and pretty unique for the most part. Does Ghost still have the capacity to output static html (thought it did pre 1.0; not sure with latest) ? If so, can I ask why you didn't go with using that feature, and then push the html via now or to any other service, since you're composing/editing locally anyway? Also, I looked for the ability to make this comment on your blog post itself, but didn't see any facility to do so, and then realized that this was because it's a read-only Ghost instance as you described. Is there any way to get comments with this approach. I'm thinking with the an Ghost-to-html approach (if available still in 1.0), you might be able to script something up to also embed Disqus into the outputted HTML, but as far as comments with your read-only Ghost on now.sh approach, no way to incorporate comments, correct? Anyway your blog theme was pretty attractive on Chrome mobile BTW. Enjoyable read all the way around.
- ryanashcraft 9y agoThanks! Great questions. I’m not 100% confident about supporting static generation and Discus integration with Ghost 1.0, although I imagine it’s feasible. That said, I’m personally not interested in pursuing either for my own blog at this time. Maybe in the future.
- linopolus 9y agoAll I read is SEO. All I see is a Mac app not feeling and behaving like a Mac app. If I wanted these modern-Windows-style UIs, I'd use Windows. But I don't like them, so why does everyone try to explain to me how cross-platform, which is really pushing a windowsy UI and UX down the throats of all others, is so much better?
- thangngoc89 9y agoYou can build an Electron app that looks and feel like Native app on both Windows and MacOS. And this app doesn't look like Windows 10 to me
- linopolus 9y ago> You can build an Electron app that looks and feel like Native app on both Windows and MacOS Show me one. Just one.. Most "cross-platform-apps" I used seemed to think moving the window frame buttons to the left and making the interface the same grey is integration enough.</slight_exaggeration> > this app doesn't look like Windows 10 to me Maybe my picture of windows is skewed, I haven't used it for many years now, I apologize. But isn't it even worse then? If it feels at home neither on Windows nor on OSX, but foreign to both?
- gtirloni 9y agoI've had a similar experience with Electron apps. Quality (in terms of "nativeness") varies a lot. This article lists many things Electron developers have to be careful about: https://blog.avocode.com/blog/4-must-know-tips-for-building-cross-platform-electron-apps https://blog.avocode.com/blog/4-must-know-tips-for-building-...
- allover 9y agoAll I see is entitlement. I also see nothing wrong with the copy on their website, 'All I read is SEO' is just a petty attack, and your tone sucks. If you really had problems with the marketing copy, there are other ways to say it or suggest improvements. The reason for building cross-platform UIs is clearly so that a small team can reach more users. The vast majority of users simply do not care about native look and feel. This app looks plenty intuitive, I don't see how you can reasonably complain about its behaviour, I'm assuming without trying it.
- kostarelo 9y ago> It's a desktop app, so you can manage your pages anywhere. Take a laptop to the beach, write in comfort, then sync with one click once you're back online. Really? Wouldn't a web app be better for this?
- jedisct1 9y agoFinally an alternative to Netscape Composer.
- zaphar 9y agoJust downloaded and tried it out. But selecting the SFTP key doesn't seem to work and there is no local filesystem option that I can see so I have no way to test at the moment.
- pmlnr 9y agoAaaand no linux version. Pleae, people, cross-platform is not just win and mac. Especially with electron apps this should be a simple to include.
- allover 9y agoThey've said a Linux version is coming. Aaaand chill your entitlement, they don't owe you jack, no matter how simple you think it is.
- thenomad 9y agoLooks very cool. If I hadn't already settled on a Hugo/Git/Netlify setup, I'd be investigating this for sure. Also, congrats on writing website copy to appeal to non-techie audiences. It's well written, benefit-focused, and generally good stuff. I could actually see myself introducing this to non-techie entrepreneur friends and having them likely to use it. P.S. - even more impressed that your docs seem to be written for non-technical users in mind too! Nice one.
- janci 9y agoXara web designer going popular again?
- glasz 9y agoxara! that's some fringe memories right there.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- indigodaddy 9y agoI posted this article, but have no affiliation at all, just thought it looked quite excellent and fairly unique, and was surprised it hadn't been posted to HN before this. A feature that may be lacking that I don't see would be to get a local sync option in play if you are using multiple instances of the app (say you are using it sometimes on MacBook and also on Windows here or there). They do support pushing/syncing TO github pages, but I'd like to see perhaps a Git functionality used also to always keep any Publii instance synced locally with each other, and with Github, etc. I think that would really put this app over the top.