3 ms·
"But there is an interesting and far-reaching debate about so-called natural kinds (typically water, gold etc.). In fact a widespread view is that, after Saul K
by ThomPete 16y ago
"But there is an interesting and far-reaching debate about so-called natural kinds (typically water, gold etc.). In fact a widespread view is that, after Saul Kripke and Hilary Putnam, water does indeed have an essential wateriness beyond its surface characteristics. This has interesting consequences in philosophy of language and philosophy of mind "
I have a hard time understanding what this characteristic would be that isn't emerging from our interpretation of reality rather than reality as such.
Or am I missing something?
- davnola 16y agoI don't know, maybe you're having a deep insight! Roughly speaking, the idea is that water in our universe is essentially H2O. The intuition is that if we went to another universe where there was watery stuff that duck-typed as water but had underlying composition XYZ, it would not be water. Doesn't sound too controversial, but has interesting implications (e.g. it's an a posteriori necessity!). And there's also some interesting and powerful explications of "our universe" and "another universe" to do with the nature of counterfactuals. For an alternative take, see Dupré, John. (1995). The Disorder of Things. Harvard University Press. Introduces the delightful notion of "promiscuous realism"!
- ThomPete 16y agoBut water is simply interpretation of phenomena in a specific context. Even on a compositional level. H2o have more fundamental properties, that again themselves are interpretations. Unless you find out a way to be certain about your fundamentals. And that I am not sure you can.