3 ms·
"if it tries to expand, it can only do so upwards." There also can be an inversion inside the tube. For example, air might cool more on the shadow side of the
by Someone 9y ago
"if it tries to expand, it can only do so upwards."
There also can be an inversion inside the tube. For example, air might cool more on the shadow side of the tower, and start going down there.
I think it is 'obvious' that that will happen if you make the chimney wide enough (as a thought experiment, make it 2000 km wide, treat the outside of the chimney as the inside of a chimney with diameter of close to the circumference of the earth, or consider the case of a kilometer high wall on the equator with air intakes at the bottom. You argument that air must go up on both sides of it)
Question is whether the proposed chimney is wide enough for that to happen, and to what extent.