4 ms·
It's interesting because the AI founders like McCarthy considered the intellectual challenges to be hard, and the robot challenges to be relatively easy. They
by goatlover 9y ago
It's interesting because the AI founders like McCarthy considered the intellectual challenges to be hard, and the robot challenges to be relatively easy.
They would have probably been really surprised that we'd have a superhuman Go player before we had a robot that was just average at picking up arbitrary items.
- digi_owl 9y agoHumanity seems to underestimate the mental activity needed for limb control because so much of it is subconscious.
- gozur88 9y agoI believe that. It takes, what four or five years for a kid to learn how to catch a ball?
- gumby 9y agoA good part of that is that the kid's nervous system is continually being detuned due to growth. Consider that dog learns how to catch a ball reliably once it has reached full size. Interestingly the myelin sheath around your peripheral nerves thins as you grow. I have always assumed this is to reduce capacitance so that signal propagation time between (say) your fingertips and brain remains roughly constant as your arm gets longer. I don't know if anyone has ever studied this though.
- joeyo 9y agoYou may be right that thinning during maturation could serve a purpose, but if so you have the effect backwards: thinner myelin should mean higher capacitance (C ~ A/d) and slower conduction velocity. One would expect, if anything, that the myelin would need to get thicker as the limb lengthens. Perhaps nerve fiber diameter also increases with maturation---which also results in faster conduction velocity---and the myelin sheath thins to compensate.
- gumby 9y agoSorry that was a brain fart -- I meant to type thicken. Myelination continues Into adulthood btw -- you can see a change in the distribution of white matter due to learning a new language for example.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jamesmishra 9y agoPart of it is that training the superhuman Go player is more parallelizable. The challenge is entirely virtual, and you can have unlimited synthetic training data by having Go-playing algorithms play each other. I've never worked with machine learning in robotics, but my understanding is that physics simulators are still insufficient environments for training state-of-the-art robotic agents. Especially when using reinforcement learning or a similar algorithm, many models are trained with several real robots picking up real objects.
- gumby 9y agoIronically Marvin Minsky discouraged me from working on robotics because it was so easy to get distracted by the hard problems in robotics and stop working on the hard problems in AI. He supported this argument through all the experience he had had building robot arms and the like. It really seemed unfair that he had had the fun of building the robots and than said I shouldn't do it. It took years to realize what he was really saying (a statement I could make about many things he said).