11 ms·
Roman Britain in Black and White
- bionsuba 9y agoIt's interesting that she decided to leave out the fact that Taleb's comment on citations was him firing back after she called anti-fragile et. all "pop risk books": https://medium.com/incerto/something-is-broken-in-the-uk-intellectual-sphere-7efc9a1f154a https://medium.com/incerto/something-is-broken-in-the-uk-int...
- zipfle 9y agoShe didn't leave it out. "I think Prof Taleb did get annoyed when I said that I had read his ‘pop risk’ book, not the others. But I was actually trying to make clear that I had some knowledge of his work, though not a lot."
- ar-jan 9y agoAlso, even if you disregard the "pop risk books" qualification, her argument comes down to "what did you publish on Roman Britain", instead of engaging with Taleb's argument.
- panzagl 9y agoTaleb is disregarding the entire field of history because it is 'Anecdotal' as opposed to 'Statistical'. Since there are no 'statistics' from the period he is acting like he knows as much as one of top living scholars on Roman history. The written and archaeological record shows that auxiliaries were often stationed far from their home territories, but I guess that was all part of a 2000 year plot to make Britons accept immigrants.
- ar-jan 9y agoNo, all he's saying is that you cannot ignore genetics, and that genetics is more reliable than fragmentary historical records. And that those Roman auxiliaries would have been Mediterranean, not sub-Saharen Africans.
- DanBC 9y ago> and that genetics is more reliable than fragmentary historical records Geneticists disagree.
- pknight 9y agoShe not only mentioned that in the article, it's the truth? And how is that a slight? It's bloody amazing that you can write books on risk that reach mass audiences. It's only a slight to Taleb because he prefers to think of himself as above the fray.
- ItsDeathball 9y agoThe piece seemed like it was intended to explain the historical consensus on ethnic diversity in Roman Britain and how that consensus was achieved, which one can't really do reasonably in 140 characters. She mentions the Twitter drama for context, but I think she's trying to keep the debate focused on the point of factual contention rather than personal conflict. If people want to get anything productive at all out of these constant Twitter flareups they need to allow for de-escalation.
- dragonwriter 9y agoAnti-Fragile is a popular work on risk; the description is simply accurate, and distinguishes the works she had read from Taleb’s academic work. Most academics who also write popular works aren't prickly about describing their popular works as such; I don't think Hawking would get upset at someone describing A Brief History of Time as pop cosmology.
- aaronbrethorst 9y agoThe author, Mary Beard, is a classicist and the UK's top Roman scholar. She's also the author of the critically acclaimed SPQR: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/18/books/review-in-spqr-a-history-of-ancient-rome-mary-beard-tackles-myths-and-more.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/18/books/review-in-spqr-a-hi...
- ch4s3 9y agoFor those who haven't read the book, SPQR is an excellent piece of writing.
- sremani 9y agoProf. Beard is hiding behind the bad behavior of her opponents, there is no cogent answer to the question.. where are the genes ?
- pja 9y agoIn her article, she points out that the same study failed to find Norman genes either. So I might ask similar questions about them: where are the Norman genes? Is the Norman invasion of Britain a hoax perpetrated by the alt-right of yore? etc. etc. (In other words: it’s a legitimate question, but the way Taleb is using it as some kind of gotcha! query suggests that he isn’t really asking it in good faith.)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> it’s a legitimate question, but the way Taleb is using it as some kind of gotcha! query suggests that he isn’t really asking it in good faith. Or, more generously (as to Taleb’s character) that the implicit premise (if there were ethnic diversity, we would have robust genetic evidence) justifying his argument is itself not based on a well-informed understanding of the context.
- emmelaich 9y agoYeah, since he has explicitly argued[1] against such "gotcha" tactics I would presume your inferrence is more accurate. [1] See The Ethics of Disagreement in https://medium.com/incerto/the-facts-are-true-the-news-is-fake-5bf98104cea2 https://medium.com/incerto/the-facts-are-true-the-news-is-fa...
- dibujante 9y agoIt really isn't. It's very hard to identify genetic influences that go that far back, especially given the subsequent major migrations to the British Isles. You would be hard-pressed to demonstrate that Romans ever lived there if all you had were the genes of modern Britons.
- tcbawo 9y ago
- pja 9y agoMary Beard’s proper title would be Prof. Beard of course. Something she extended the courtesy of to him, but apparently he couldn’t be bothered to extend the same to her. The falling back on 'I got more citations than you, so ner' isn’t exactly a good look either.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- unknown_apostle 9y agoTaleb calling people Ms and Mr here was obviously about being firm. As in Agent Smith saying "MISTER Anderson". If anyone wants to suggest that Talib pulled some kind of gender card on her, that's pathetic. It actually strengthens the idea that academia needs to be wary of identity politics creeping in (and also bad manners). Btw Taleb was a huge fan of Beard. Until a few days ago that is.
- pja 9y agoNice use of the passive voice there. In what way am I 'pulling the gender card' exactly?
- unknown_apostle 9y agoThat's what the Ms vs Prof thing was about.
- pja 9y agoIt would have been equally sloppy in the circumstances to use "Mr Beard" had Taleb been arguing with a man. When arguing with someone on their academic specialism using an incorrect title looks like a subtle (but deniable! how cute) insult. No gender politics required.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- uyhso8 9y agoThis whole thing strikes me as sad. The argument could have gone an entirely different way. Taleb blasts the nature and tone of the argument, concluding "scholarship is dead in the UK,"(https://medium.com/incerto/something-is-broken-in-the-uk-intellectual-sphere-7efc9a1f154a https://medium.com/incerto/something-is-broken-in-the-uk-int...) but the irony is that if it's ending, it's ending in part because of behavior such as his. I actually agree in general with his perspective on the cartoon, but found his behavior unacceptable. The other side of the argument isn't unreasonable, even if you conclude it's maybe not the best side of the argument. In some ways it doesn't matter, but I'm getting tired of the right setting up this dynamic where they engage in ad hominem bullshit, and then act offended when other side responds. I say this as someone who often identifies with the right--it's alienating and pushes reasonable people away. Rather than apologizing about not being respectful of Professor Beard, he becomes defensive and somehow tries to rationalize it. Next time Taleb, could you please just take the high road in your behavior? Even if the other side is totally full of shit, and acting inappropriately, you'll look better and everyone will win by being the better one. I even agree with you and you've turned me off of your own damn arguments. Jeez.
- autokad 9y ago> I'm getting tired of the right setting up this dynamic where they engage in ad hominem bullshit its not different than the way the left attacks people as: racist, homophobe, mysangist, uneducated, hillbilly, etc. the last one i find quite interesting, a party that is supposed to stand against stereotypes, labeling, and skin color references uses hillbilly / red neck a lot.
- sqeaky 9y agoCalling someone out for being racist or bigoted in some other should be acceptable, because that behavior is not acceptable. Preventing people from being called out on their bigotry is tolerating intolerance, and we shouldn't have any of that. I do agree it is not a real rebuttal if the other side has a point unrelated to their bigotry.
- 9y ago
- patrickg_zill 9y agoGo to Google Images, type in "European people history" and note the first ten results. That is what this is about.
- hn_anon_founder 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_bomb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_bomb
- cabalamat 9y agoIn other cases where Google's algorithms have come up with something embarassing, they have corrected it. It is revealing that they have chosen not to do so in this case.
- clock_tower 9y agoI'd always heard "Europeans", not "European people"; if Google is just confused (and I wouldn't rule it out -- look up "Goofle Translate"), I think it's because "European people" is a pretty rare semantic construct.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoI'm kind of amazed at how seriously people are taking this. The guy is the editor for a literal conspiracy theory website that condones the idea that Sandy Hook was staged by the US government. And long list of even more ridiculous and appalling things. They make their money selling pseudoscientific "wellness" products of the kind that Gwyneth Paltrow sells on Goop. The main star of Infowars recently admitted it was just an act of entertainment because if he didn't a divorce court would have ruled him a danger to his children based on things he says and does. Back to the matter at hand, he's literally proposing a conspiracy theory, based on an educational cartoon, for children, about the Roman empire. Just let that soak in. The BBC are, in this theory, intentionally promoting "mass uncontrolled immigration" to children via animations about the Roman empire. Step 2 ???. Step 3. White Genocide. It's an embarrassment to us all as a species that this passes for political discussion today.
- emmelaich 9y ago"The guy?" Which guy? What website?
- aptwebapps 9y agoDid the link change or something?
- pja 9y agoI think ZG might have confused Taleb with Alex Jones? (Taleb is the arrogant loud-mouth[1] who made his money in the financial markets, Alex Jones is similar in aspect but made his money by building an audience of right-wing conspiracy theorists and then selling them herbal supplements.) [1] Not an insult. I suspect he’d embrace this description whole-heartedly.
- bryananderson 9y agoIt should be clear to anyone who has read this article by Dr. Beard (or her phenomenal book SPQR) that it isn't really up for debate whether there were Roman soldiers and civilians in Britain who came from the far reaches of the Empire and beyond. Yes, including from Africa. Whether we would have looked at these people and said they were "black" is, as Dr. Beard explains, pretty unanswerable (not to mention a vain attempt to view the ancient world in terms of group identities that are very modern indeed). Dr. Taleb and others show a massive ignorance of how the studies of history, archaeology, and biology work when they assert that we can just "look in the genes" for an unambiguous record of every damn person who has ever set foot on the British Isles. But a misguided desire to hold history to the same evidentiary standards as, say, physics or mathematics - including by physicists and mathematicians - is nothing new. What's more worrisome is the determination of some to willfully ignore historical evidence that might challenge their worldview. Look around the Internet - there is a new revisionist history of the Western world that is being pushed, one that holds a shared "white" or "European" identity as paramount. These are the people who came after Dr. Beard as they come after anyone who challenges their views. These people are undoubtedly far less numerous than they appear; they use bots and multiple accounts to make themselves appear more legitimate. This itself is dangerous, as it may cause bystanders to view these people as more mainstream than they truly are (and it's no secret that people ascribe more credulity to an idea when it seems widely accepted). This is not going to get better as neural networks improve at writing tweets that sound human.
- zpergs 9y agoYou're making it sound more complex than it is. If Roman Britain was ethnically diverse then what happened to the diversity? It's just not represented in the modern population. Furthermore, a study is probably incorrect if it can't withstand sanity checking from simple population models based on data we do have from the time (e.g. Roman garrison sizes). > Look around the Internet - there is a new revisionist history of the Western world that is being pushed.. The revisionism is actually that Roman Britain was ethnically diverse. To paraphrase the source of this controversy, Paul Joseph Watson: If Roman Britain was diverse then modern day Japan is ethnically diverse. The "we are all immigrants" narrative is pushed to justify mass immigration and open borders. This might make academics like Beard feel cosmopolitan and P.C. views might draw the attention of the Guardian and boost her book sales, but tens of millions of people are suffering from the consequences of these policies and feel alienated by an elite that they feel is working against their will and best interests. > These people are undoubtedly far less numerous than they appear; they use bots Paul Joseph Watson has over 1m subscribers on YouTube and his videos have hundreds of thousands of views. This places his daily circulation higher than most newspapers. While only a small percentage of those people may agree with his views enough to push them online, that is still a lot of people. Anyway, I'm looking forward to reading "Skin in the Game" and wonder whether this story will become another anecdote of Taleb's "Intellectual Yet Idiot" social class.
- Red_Tarsius 9y agoIt's not an isolated incident. The same show depicted ethnic people in questionable situations. – Sub-Saharan Celts http://i.imgur.com/WSHbj36.png http://i.imgur.com/WSHbj36.png – A Sub-Saharan English Nobleman, 1215AD http://i.imgur.com/Y5WFtXO.png http://i.imgur.com/Y5WFtXO.png – A Sub-Saharan blacksmith, Iron Age Britain http://i.imgur.com/XptrQDP.png http://i.imgur.com/XptrQDP.png – A North-African Norman priest http://i.imgur.com/5JHBzMN.png http://i.imgur.com/5JHBzMN.png The criticized video was supposed to be "An exploration of life in Roman Britain shown through the eyes of a typical family." http://i.imgur.com/tg25juJ.jpg http://i.imgur.com/tg25juJ.jpg
- ng12 9y agoChrist, this needs to be further up. All this discussion of whether or not the cartoon was politicized becomes moot when they have dark-skinned Celts.
- mirimir 9y agoHow do you know that there weren't dark-skinned Celts? But maybe you're saying that there are? Consider that priests of the Lemba tribe carry the Y-chromosome Cohen gene. http://www.worldjewishcongress.org/en/news/lemba-tribe-in-southern-africa-has-jewish-roots-genetic-tests-reveal http://www.worldjewishcongress.org/en/news/lemba-tribe-in-so...
- emmelaich 9y agoI like the article in The Atlantic about this. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/08/dna-romans/535701/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/08/dna-roma... As it says, it's mostly people talking past each other. Taleb is unnecessarily un-collegial though.
- Klockan 9y agoI'd say that this is roughly on par with depicting Jesus as a white western European, but I don't see any right wingers complaining about that.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Kevve 9y agoJesus often gets depicted to match the local population. In Korea, for example, he looks Asian. The difference is that it's done for religious purposes, whereas an "educational historic video" like those made by BBC are expected to have different motives and standards of objectivity.
- pm24601 9y agoRomans were in Britain 2000 years ago. In 2000 years, with negative environmental selection - maybe the gene for black skin was turned off. Everyone is focusing on skin color, what about curly hair or ... This is all silly any how.