8 ms·
What's the takeaway here? That they use a rudimentary security system as a mild deterrent which is easily exploitable. That it's okay to commit fraud as long as
by Spivak 9y ago
What's the takeaway here? That they use a rudimentary security system as a mild deterrent which is easily exploitable. That it's okay to commit fraud as long as you use tech to do it?
You wouldn't see this kind of thing on a lockpicking forum, "Airport lounges will let anyone in, provided you brink your kit."
- catshirt 9y agothe takeaway is that you can do it, as the title suggests :)
- mikeash 9y agoReminds me of the common joke life pro-tip: you can get stuff without paying for it by going to a store, picking something up, and just walking out with it!
- iainmerrick 9y agoExactly! Just because the flaw is there, that doesn't give you the right to gratuitously exploit it. Do we really want to force people to implement super-strict security for relatively trivial things like this?
- eunoia 9y agoOh the poor airlines! They would never, ever gratuitously exploit their passengers. How could these mean awful people take advantage of them like this? It's pretty hard to root for a corporation when it's smart individual vs faceless multinational ineptitude. Human nature perhaps?
- mseebach 9y agoBy that logic, shoplifting from sufficiently large stores is ok. Not stealing bread to feed your family, just randomly grabbing stuff because you feel like it (and it isn't locked down).
- eunoia 9y agoStealing physical items for fun != exploiting ineptitude to have a less terrible layover. It's also harder to even begin to measure the economic cost. I think it's more akin to buying terrible cheap seats to a show and moving into a better yet unoccupied section once it starts. The internet has always seemed to have a lot more moralists than the real world.
- mikeash 9y agoMaybe, as long as you don't touch any of the food or drink. How likely is that, though?
- eunoia 9y agoDid you know most airlines have absolutely awful inventory control over the supplies on their planes? If you make friends with a flight attendant they usually have the leeway to bring you just about anything you want for free. Is that stealing too? Pro tip: Bring candy or snacks for flight attendants on long flights, they appreciate it and may even reciprocate in kind.
- mikeash 9y agoIt's not stealing when they give it to you willingly without any fraud. Are you that fuzzy on the concept of "stealing" that you don't see the difference here?
- arnarbi 9y agoOpposing stealing is now rooting for corporations?
- eunoia 9y agoMany/most forms of hacking could be construed as stealing if you squint hard enough. What was this community founded around again? Do you think "disruption" is a peaceful, happy, 100% beneficial process for everyone involved? Is Uber stealing by taking business from incumbents that play by a different (regulated) rulebook?
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoThis 'community' (to the extent that all the users of this site can be clubbed into one) was definitely not formed on any founding principle which would legitimize theft. Not that sneaking into airport lounges is some huge theft, but acting like it's completely okay isn't cool either.
- eunoia 9y agoI agree, it's not 100% okay. I wouldn't feel bad doing it though. I also wouldn't do it in a situation where my presence hurts another paying customer (i.e. full lounge). My personal ethics apply to how my actions impact other living things. I don't lose sleep worrying if I've wronged an entity created solely for the purpose of maximizing shareholder value. I'm honestly surprised how many people don't agree with that. To each their own I suppose. Edit: You're totally right about the futility of trying to shove all of us into any one descriptive bucket though. That was a mistake.
- hueving 9y ago>I'm honestly surprised how many people don't agree with that. To each their own I suppose. You're advocating for stealing from businesses. When enough people like you do this, it results in either higher prices for honest people or the loss of a service entirely.
- bdcravens 9y agoI don't think it's rooting for a corporation, but a simple matter of ethics.
- finnn 9y agoThey have no ethics while exploiting you for as much money as possible, so you should be nice to them and treat them as you would another human? Edit: sorry, this was kind of a flippant remark that I made without thinking a lot.
- opportune 9y agoThat's a vast exaggeration of things. "Exploiting" my ass. You know the reason why airlines are so shitty? Because people only buy the cheapest tickets to their destination. I'm guilty of this myself. The end result is a race to the bottom . And yes, when the man refused to get off the United plane, he should not have been beaten. Big deal, hundreds of millions of people fly every year. The fact that that happened sucks, but the reality is that 99.99% of people will at worst just deal with incompetent customer service during a cancelled or heavily delayed flight. That doesn't give you justification to steal from the airliner. This is a discussion I feel you would have with a teenager.
- ImSkeptical 9y agoDon't they transport you and your luggage safely through the air at high speed for a sum of money that you agreed to pay? Where is exploitation coming from?
- zo1 9y agoCapitalism, apparently. Though, to be a bit more generous, I'd interpret that people hate airlines without really having a conscious reason, so they make something up that's visible and easy to be upset about. E.g. Cost of flying, leg-room, crappy service, "run by evil corporation". I'd posit that they somehow see something wrong with it, yet can't pin-point what that is. In my view, somehow they realize that a government-enabled and enforced monopoly makes the whole thing unfair. And if only we had no intervention and prevention of competition, they'd finally see "nice" airlines. But until they actively "see" that, they'll always think that it's the government that's preventing the really nice peachy happy people from running an airline that they'd enjoy using.
- whipoodle 9y agoI mean, I see your point, but if that's what they have to do to stop fraud, and the fraud is something they really care about, then yeah, they should do that. Surely it's no great tragedy that stores have cash registers and bill checkers.
- mikeash 9y agoMost stores have far fewer controls than they could, because they'd rather be nice to their customers. This changes if the level of fraud/theft increases. Stores places where few people steal are nice and open, have nobody watching the doors, and basically rely on the honor system to ensure that you pass by a cashier before you leave. Stores in places where theft is common have all sorts of unpleasant security measures. Society only works because most of us behave. Look around you, and you'll see an incredible number of structures that only work because 99% of people are basically decent and honest. Don't be in the 1% who aren't, and definitely don't encourage that 1% to grow.
- techsupporter 9y ago> Most stores have far fewer controls than they could, because they'd rather be nice to their customers. This changes if the level of fraud/theft increases. Yep, and people can easily see this for themselves. It is incredibly telling to note the difference between going into the Rite Aid on Rainier Ave S in Seattle and the Rite Aid on 35th Ave NE in the same city. They're almost directly due north/south of each other and separated by less than ten miles. However, the Rainier one has at least one visible store security guard, tags on the shopping trolleys to prevent leaving the store with them, locked-down shaving razor refills and baby formula and small electronics, and "you are being recorded" security televisions prominently placed. The one on 35th has none of those. If there is a security guard or loss-prevention specialist, that person is often hidden. Shave refills are easily accessed (though do have removable security tags), there are corrals outside so customers can use the trolleys to load purchases into their vehicles, and the store simply feels more open and accessible.
- popcorncowboy 9y ago> Most stores have far fewer controls than they could, because they'd rather be nice to their customers. ... 99% of people are basically decent and honest. Don't be in the 1% who aren't This is dangerous thinking. People don't generally steal because they're bad vs "nice", they steal because they have an incentive to do so (economically speaking). Heaping moral judgement on them is unhelpful and in many cases actively detrimental [because it obscures causal underlying issues and excuses bad policy designed to address symptoms]. 'I mean, have you noticed that like, in white, "nice" places, where people are "nice", the stores are all open and nice and people are friendly, but in those dirty poor black neighborhoods the corner stores have got bars on the windows and grills in front of the cashiers, because blacks steal more and make up more of that nasty 1% obviously' </valleygirlvoice> I hope it's obvious where this line of reasoning leads. Dangerous places. Theft controls are functions of behavioral economics, not how "nice" people are (store owners included). ALL stores suffer from some level of theft, and thus _could_ implement HYPER security to eliminate the problem. They don't, mostly because the costs (direct and indirect) outweigh the benefits of deterring a given level of theft. So for most stores, the expenditure on theft prevention comes down to the minimum spend necessary to reach a tolerable level of theft. And levels of theft have everything to do with a very careful balance of cost:benefit to do with economic and social incentives for the actors involved. This "most people are nice but 1% of people are bad and mess it up for everyone else" type thinking excuses awful systemic abuse and places blame in entirely the wrong place.
- another-dave 9y ago"Hotel breakfast buffets will let anyone in, provided you can say a room number."
- BenjiWiebe 9y agoThe people who bring your food at Sonic do not make sure you've activated (removed) the coupon you told them you had. So you could use the coupon over and over...
- mnutt 9y agoI think the HN-framed takeaway here is that the developer building the system could have used a timestamp + HMAC and prevented the issue, but chose not to for whatever reason. Maybe they wanted to be able to generate barcodes from the app itself while offline, maybe they were getting the data from the server anyway and just didn't know any better.
- BenjiWiebe 9y agoPerhaps the developer saw an opportunity to make an app to distribute to friends to let them into the lounges.