6 ms·
There's a trade off between modularity and sleek design as Apple has proven better than anyone. They were arguably the first PC manufacturer to take design ser
by chrisco255 9y ago
There's a trade off between modularity and sleek design as Apple has proven better than anyone.
They were arguably the first PC manufacturer to take design seriously and while Macs began to become more difficult to repair beginning with the iMac in 1998, there's no questioning that the component choices (from the external to the internal) lent itself to an increasingly sleek design that eventually led Apple to create the best-in-class laptops and desktops.
This push towards sleek design also gave Apple the chops to create the original iPod in the first place...which eventually lead to the revolutionary iPhone...which completely upended the mobile phone industry.
As a PC fan, I love creating and building my own box...carefully selecting my motherboard, case, processor, and memory in the process...and I rest easy knowing I can upgrade my machine over time...
But I wouldn't question the value that highly integrated designs that Apple and others have brought to the table. You can feel the quality in the products they make. There's a lot of careful thought and design. Modularity and repairability are a necessary sacrifice to build products that sleek.
Take a look at the failed Project Ara by Google: https://atap.google.com/ara/ https://atap.google.com/ara/. It would have brought modular parts and design to the mobile phone industry. While a great concept, and something that appeals to my custom rig PC roots, it may not actually have been that useful in practice for the vast majority of the general public.
- jaytaylor 9y agoMy MacBook Air is sleek and also very easy to repair and service. This aspect of products is not so black and white, and comes down to the design decisions made by the product people and engineers.
- crispyambulance 9y agoYeah, "easy" is in the eye of the beholder. For some folks a BGA rework is a piece of cake, for others it means "scrap". Depends on your tools, skills, time, will-power, documentation and tolerance for screw-ups. Mostly skill. I've seen techs performing successful BGA replacements on laptop MOBO's in repair stands in Mexico with pathetic equipment.
- smilekzs 9y agoIn Shenzhen, China, techs are supposed to be able to put together an iPhone from scrap parts.
- mschuster91 9y agoHow is that actually possible for a human given all the sub-millimetre-parts like micro smd resistors etc?
- candiodari 9y agoAnswer: plastic cutouts where you position the parts in prepared holes.
- crispyambulance 9y agoIt's not feasible for more than a few components-- we are, of course, talking about repair. You use a microscope, tweezers, a steady hand and accept a high rate of failure. Board repair only makes economic sense in certain markets where the price of electronics is high compared to to disposable income.
- redial 9y agoAs sleek as the MacBook Air is, the new 12" MacBook leaves it in the dust.
- tracker1 9y agoI'd still rather have a device I can upgrade the ram and storage on, as well as replace the battery... I miss my prior mbp (stolen)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- michaelcampbell 9y ago> led Apple to create the best-in-class laptops and desktops. Other than profit for Apple, best at what?
- chiph 9y agoYou can say that difficult-to-repair Apples started with the original Mac, which required a long-handled Torx driver to open the case (which no one had). The Apple ][ was the last truly user-serviceable Apple product.
- ngneer 9y agoGot one of those to play with that others left for dead. Ended up gluing the bit to a long pencil and it worked!
- tracker1 9y agoUntil the trash-bin Mac Pro, most of that line has been pretty user serviceable. People are still getting really good money in resale for 2010-2012 Mac Pros, while the trash can units aren't doing nearly as well (accounting for age). I mainly notice as I've been considering getting one of the older models and upgrading cpu, maxing ram, newer gtx1080 etc.
- ksk 9y ago>But I wouldn't question the value that highly integrated designs that Apple and others have brought to the table. And yet nearly every single person I know has had their power cable for their iphone and/or macbook fray after a year or so. Meanwhile the "ugly" Sony one that I have for the past 7 years, continues to work just fine. Apple do make well designed products, but they're not above sacrificing functionality for looks, and when they do, its kinda embarrassing. Especially rookie mistakes like not having proper heat dissipation for their laptop GPUs. Also.. didn't the first unibody macs have several design flaws with the hinges and the battery bulging, etc ? >Modularity and repairability are a necessary sacrifice to build products that sleek. Apple can already repair it themselves. They're artificially restricting the supply of parts so others can't repair it. Apple repair costs are substantially higher and its unfortunate that they're against other repair shops competing with them.
- always_good 9y agoIt's just about unforgivable how long Apple sat on their Macbook charger til they finally let us swap out the brick<->laptop stretch of wire -- the part that actually breaks. Astonishingly wasteful (both in dollars and electrical waste) to buy a new $70 brick when it was never the brick that broke. Now you can just buy a $7 cord from Amazon when it breaks. Of course, go for an off-brand if you want one that won't fray in <1 year.
- b212 9y agoThat's why I can't understand people who complain about removal of MagSafe. Seriously, it was a great thing to have but replaceable cord is MUCH better for me. I'm very careful with my laptops and never needed MagSafe (luckily) but during the years I broke 6 or 7 chargers. Sometimes it was a year, sometimes two, but the cord always snipped. No matter how careful I was.
- pseudalopex 9y agoPeople complain because Apple could've made a replaceable MagSafe cable.
- michaelmrose 9y ago"Modularity and repairability are a necessary sacrifice to build products that sleek." This is too silly to even deserve a comprehensive retort. It's about small cost savings that add up over massive units sold and the money to be made on new units. Essentially you can be paid significantly more for making slightly worse items. It is wholly 100% about money.
- SpikeDad 9y agoExcept of course it's true. Naturally price is a factor but consumer preferences as well and scale of production are enormous factors. Sorry you can't see that.
- michaelmrose 9y agoExcept you know on the exterior samsung looks enough like an iphone that we had to have a lawsuit over it. Except if you put your thumbnail between the edges you can pop off the case and swap out the sd card and battery. It also appears to be slightly easier to disassemble and replace components. At the very least they never tried to disable their devices if repaired by a third party... https://www.theguardian.com/money/2016/feb/05/error-53-apple-iphone-software-update-handset-worthless-third-party-repair https://www.theguardian.com/money/2016/feb/05/error-53-apple... Its about money.
- solatic 9y agoDesign and maintainability are not mutually exclusive. The original Thinkpad design is the laptop equivalent of blue jeans - functional, comfortable, durable, fashionably flexible, and timeless. Are blue jeans as "high" fashion as an evening gown? No. Does that make them "bad" fashion? No. I for one want more blue-jean electronics.
- bmaupin 9y agoCouldn't agree more. I'm a huge fan of the ThinkPad T series. They may not win any awards for design, but I'm impressed with how thin and light mine is considering without any tools I can pop off the bottom cover, exposing access to the user-replacable battery, CPU fan, and hard drive. A couple additional screws gives you access to user-replacable RAM.
- walterstucco 9y agoDesign is maintainability and reproducibility. Everything Apple is not. Two things Apple did good on their laptop: the touchpad (not the pizza tray they've put on latest models, the smaller one) and the friction of the lid, that is perfect. Other than that unibody is a heating disaster, retina screens are useless and created (another) double standard, keyboards got worse and worse up to the point they don't have real keys anymore, the UI, well, classic Apple UI, hide everything behind the curtain, if we say you don't need it, we'll forbid anybody else from even trying. Etc. Etc. Etc.
- SpikeDad 9y agoAnd naturally everyone that buys Apple products are zombies and a victim of Apple's irresistible marketing. Funny but most folks are not like you - they want their computer to do stuff for them without drama. It's easy to throw out a bunch of hackneyed Apple insults and to use your own personal preferences to stand in for the majority of folks who use and enjoy the form and function of Macs and other Apple gear.
- michaelcampbell 9y ago> I find comments from folks like you ignorant and of low quality.
- MaymayMaster 9y agoThey're honestly nothing more than children's toys.
- cable2600 9y agoAfter Jobs was fired or quit Apple in 1985 because the Mac was a flop and the Commodore Amiga and Atari ST came out for a lower price with color. Apple had to redesign the Mac and came up with Nubus slots for the Mac II and Mac SE line. They used the 68020 CPU and expandable video cards with up to 16 million colors to rival the Amigas 4086 colors. IBM countered with VGA and the Adlib and Soundblaster cards came out to have better sound and Windows 3.x sold a lot and Windows 95 basically put competitors to near bankrupt or almost bankrupt status. Jobs came back and saved Apple using a BSD Unix solution that used the Mac GUI aka OSX.