6 ms·
From the article, Apple's statement: “Highly-integrated design allows us to make products that are not only beautiful, thin and powerful, but also durable, so
by criddell 9y ago
From the article, Apple's statement:
“Highly-integrated design allows us to make products that are not only beautiful, thin and powerful, but also durable, so they can last for many years,” the company said. “When repairs are needed, authorized providers can ensure the quality, safety, and security of repairs for customers. And when products do reach end of life, Apple takes responsibility for recycling them safely and responsibly.”
Sounds reasonable to me.
- mamcx 9y agoI need to replace my old iMac. I can't stand to not use SSD anymore. I can't upgrade the new iMacs to SSD, and the prices that Apple give me are too much. I can't afford it, and I can't change to SSD later. So, I go hackintosh or find a way to be rich somehow. The first look more possible.
- thescriptkiddie 9y agoDepending on the year, you should be able to retrofit an SSD into an older iMac. I've done it with a 2011 27" model myself. https://eshop.macsales.com/item/OWC/DIYIMACHDD09/ https://eshop.macsales.com/item/OWC/DIYIMACHDD09/
- mamcx 9y agoThat is what I have done with my current one.
- backtoyoujim 9y agoSo durable that they cannot withstand being disassembled doesn't sound right to me.
- redial 9y agoI cannot disassemble my 20 year old soccer ball without sacrificing it. Still has lasted 20 years tho.
- abiox 9y agowhat does it even mean to "disassemble" a soccer ball?
- redial 9y agoExactly. At some point, when the battery gets integrated into the hybrid Display-SoC, what would it even mean to disassemble a smartphone?
- posguy 9y agoI can disassemble my 20 year old Apple Newton, or nearly any other handheld device of similar age. No reason I shouldn't be able to replace parts on my modern phone either!
- ivanbakel 9y agoWhat's the justification for anti-consumer practises like proprietary, uncommon screw designs? The difference between a Phillips and a 5-clover is the bill Apple gets for repairs. >When repairs are needed, authorized providers can ensure the quality, safety, and security of repairs for customers Do you think this is reasonable when Apple tries as much as possible to minimise the alternative at the cost of consumer choice?
- eridius 9y agoIt's not all that hard to find screwdrivers for the fancy screws that Apple (and other companies) use. And the justification is that it's not at all anti-consumer. Allowing consumers to disassemble the devices will practically guarantee that they break (and in a manner that voids the warrantee). The only people who should be disassembling them are people specially trained to repair them, or experts who have a lot of practice disassembling electronics safely. The former have the screwdrivers already, and as I already said, it's not that hard for the latter to get their hands on the screwdrivers.
- scottLobster 9y ago"Safely"? There's nothing in a iPhone, short of physically breaking the battery (which is hard to do), that would be even a remote danger to a user. Taking apart a phone is no more dangerous than taking apart a lego model. And if someone wants to void their warranty than that's their business. My Thinkpad is largely modular and designed to be disassembled/parts replaced. Several years now and somehow it's remained intact...
- Grustaf 9y agoExactly, their behavior can be explained perfectly well by this, the fact that they don't want to be dinged for low repairability does not prove they are opposed to repairs per se, just that for other reasons they will necessarily be making decives that aren't very easy to repair. It seems to me that people buy new phones because they want the latest, I mean a lot of people just keep using their phones with broken glass or home buttons. Beaides, resell value is very high.
- anonmoose123 9y agoExample of another article to help you along: https://9to5mac.com/2017/02/15/apple-nebraska-right-to-repair/ https://9to5mac.com/2017/02/15/apple-nebraska-right-to-repai... "According to the source, an Apple representative, staffer, or lobbyist will testify against the bill at a hearing in Lincoln on March 9. AT&T will also argue against the bill, the source said. The source told me that at least one of the companies plans to say that consumers who repair their own phones could cause lithium batteries to catch fire … " Sound a little more fishy to you yet? Oh no sorry, we can't let you repair your own car, there are dangerous corrosive chemicals inside. You must take it back to the dealership for service. You should read up on Louis Rossman, a guy who runs a YouTube channel to help people repair Apple products. To be fair to Apple- People were trying to sue them when 4chan had a campaign telling people you could recharge your phone in the microwave (look it up). Yes, it sucks how people will mess up their own devices and then try to sue Apple. But that's part of the cost of doing business. To be fair to the repair shops- Apple and other companies constantly try to use dodgy legal efforts like copyright claims to keep repair shops from posting schematics from computers in an effort to diagnose and repair components. Louis Rossman talks about these battles constantly. Yes it's messy. No, there's not a perfect answer. But the car analogy is a good one. Manufacturers could make "better" cars if they could seal the engine compartment against service. They could also make cheap cars that break constantly and force people to come in for service. Given my experience in the field, Apple's reliability and support is not nearly as good as people claim it is. At my work we constantly have problems, not the least of which are Apple's dodgy power connectors so virtually everyone in the office is limping along with black tape covering a frayed power cable waiting until the day it breaks or starts to spark and the need a new one. Or when they lied and said you couldn't upgrade the RAM, so when we slap in more RAM for work, we're violating the warranty and have to take it out to get service. And and and...
- tarboreus 9y agoIt sounds reasonable, but their policies influence people to throw away perfectly good phones for the next big thing. You might say, "That's their prerogative." If they can convince us to buy new phones with new features, then fine. If it's by making replacing the battery illegal, then I say not fine. The real issue here is not so much with smartphones, but with printers, cars, and other devices that have more predatory business models.
- jjoonathan 9y agoApple forces "authorized providers" to gimp their offerings and push you strongly towards buying a new device. That's not a hypothetical, btw. Louis Rossman (an unauthorized repairman) has some good youtube videos where he calls around to get quotes from authorized vs unauthorized repair centers. The difference in what they are able to offer is dramatic and repeatable.
- scottLobster 9y agoExcept for the fact that (at least the authorized repair part) is a bald-faced lie: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OR5ZUl0Q-NI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OR5ZUl0Q-NI
- Domenic_S 9y agoThe only "Authorized provider" is Apple itself, because they don't provide repair parts to the general public. Something that was surprising for me to learn is that e-waste recycling, while better than throwing something away in the garbage, is actually not great at recovering metals -- and it's orders of magnitude worse than just fixing the item and using it longer.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sbov 9y agoThis applies to all recycling. The phrase "reduce, reuse, recycle" has recycle last for a reason.
- khedoros1 9y agoIt's funny...that order is used in 99% of what I can find online, but the only song listing them that I remember from growing up had lyrics like "Recycle, reduce, reuse, you can close the loop". It's always a little disorienting to me, to hear the more common order.
- pavanred 9y agoWhat's unreasonable is the cost of repair which was quite conveniently not mentioned here. And, this is not just Apple. I owned a Moto X and my display cracked after over a year and half of use. The warranty doesn't cover it anymore and authorized repair was going to cost me an estimated $120 (excluding taxes). The phone had not reached it's end of life, but by then the phone it self is quite cheaper and it made sense to just buy a new phone instead of investing more into a phone that will probably not be supported with updates for long. And, the old one is now catching dust in my house.
- Paul-ish 9y agoHow does having my lithium ion battery die without being replaceable allow my device to last for years?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mulmen 9y agoIt is replaceable at an authorized (or just capable) service center.
- criddell 9y agoIf replaceable batteries were something that more consumers cared about, I think more handset makers would be making them.
- digi_owl 9y agoI don't think it has to do with care, it is more that the ones without get all the marketing these days. People really seem to ignore the power of marketing. Lets not forget that for a long while every Android device in USA was a "droid" because Verizon was running ads after ads about their reskinned Motorolas. Even people outside of USA applied the theme to their Motorola phones to get the droid experience. And these days everything is Galaxy because Samsung have for years been going toe to toe with Apple on ads spending. And speaking of Apple. For a number of years every commercial break seemed to have one of their "see how easy it is" ads that basically was a step by step guide for launching maps, emails or messaging. So by the time joe consumer would touch an iPhone they had by rote memorization internalized those steps. So much for "ease of use".
- tomc1985 9y agoShould be: “Modular design allows us to make products that are not only beautiful, thin and powerful, but also user-serviceable, so they can last for many years,” the company said. “When repairs are needed, Official Apple Service Manuals mean users are assured of the quality, safety, and security of repairs of their devices. We do not build with a short end-of-life in-mind, and we encourage a thriving aftermarket of parts and repair services for all Apple products.” One can dream...
- cwyers 9y agoThere are tradeoffs. Modular hookups take up more space and have a failure rate compared to just soldering something down. You can dream, but unless you're willing to make tradeoffs, that's all you can do.
- tomc1985 9y agoWhat you describe is a matter of willpower. I would bet one could modularize a modern iPhone to previous levels of repairability with only 10% to 20% more space. But Apple wants those repair dollars...
- redial 9y ago> What you describe is a matter of willpower. > ...only 10% to 20% more space. So not a matter of willpower then?
- tomc1985 9y agoWillpower drives everything... but there's less money in modularity so Apple doesn't have it
- cwyers 9y agoNo, look, 10-20% bigger is a real tradeoff. It's not about willpower, it's about what tradeoffs matter to you. Apple doesn't want their phones bigger. They very clearly care about how thin and light everything they make is. And I can mock it all I want to (I don't own a single Apple product, because I really don't share those values), but given that they are incredibly successful at what they do I don't think it's obvious that consumers don't care about these things. You can argue this preference all you want, but until you admit _it even exists_ you aren't going to be able to have a useful conversation on the matter.
- mulmen 9y agoMarketing generally sounds reasonable at first glance.