4 ms·
This isn't a tech* company. It's a prepared food/grocery delivery business with too much VC and some fancy design. *there's actually no such thing as a tech co
by manigandham 9y ago
This isn't a tech* company. It's a prepared food/grocery delivery business with too much VC and some fancy design.
*there's actually no such thing as a tech company at all
- Spivak 9y agoI think it's more accurate to say that every company is a tech company in some capacity.
- manigandham 9y agoHow is that more accurate? Every company uses technology, at which point saying anything like "tech company" is a useless modifier compared to just "company".
- potatolicious 9y agoI think "every company is (nowadays) a tech company" is a relatively fair assessment, even if somewhat exaggerated. Increasingly, successful companies require ownership of proprietary technology, rather than purchase of commodity technology from third parties, and in that way more and more companies - even those in "traditional" fields - have invested in in-house tech R&D. More importantly, software engineering has become a critical part of companies' success, even if the company doesn't ship software to end users (see: UPS, FedEx, Visa, MasterCard). It certainly seems like the old definitions of "tech company" is increasingly archaic - is Amazon a tech company? Or are they just a retailer that uses technology? Is Grubhub a tech company, or just a delivery service with a frontend? > "Every company uses technology, at which point saying anything like "tech company" is a useless modifier compared to just "company"." I think that's exactly the point. Software has become so critical to almost every field (and more importantly: in-house developed software) that many companies have become tech companies, and those that haven't are either getting on the bandwagon shortly, or will perish soon after. There may come a point where "company" vs. "tech company" loses its distinction, but for now it seems like "companies" are becoming "tech companies" rather quickly.
- hari_seldon_ 9y agoThe way that I think about a "tech" company is that it is able to scale its growth non-linearly with its staff (or human resources). This isn't a binary rule, and obviously many successful companies are in a gray area -- but I think that it serves as a good litmus test / starting point when thinking about companies. For example, an app that is running on a few servers can gain users more quickly than it needs to hire additional workers. A company like Blue Apron has to grow its warehouse staff as it gains new subscribers, effectively meaning that its SG&A and overhead costs scale fairly evenly with growth.
- gehwartzen 9y agoI would have to disagree with that definition. There are tons of companies that are scaling non-linearly without using any particularly new technologies. I don't consider a frying pan manufacturer a tech company just because they have managed to grow by optimizing their supply chain and productivity. Alternatively I also think a company that makes brand new technology year after year even if they scaling one for one with hiring is still a tech comapny I think what you describe might just be a general guideline for identifying a financially successful company not necessarily a tech company. People hear VC funding or IPO and often automatically think it must be a tech company by conflating technology and financial success.
- hari_seldon_ 9y agoWhat's your definition? I think you are getting caught up in definitions for the concept in a vacuum. I was just trying to help explore "tech" when it comes to hacker news and the VC landscape, whether or not I agree with the definition.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- manigandham 9y agoTechnology is strategy, techniques and general knowledge on applying science, engineering, and other disciplines to solve problems. It is not a thing in itself but a means to an end. That end describes the actual business. Just because you use technology to improve productivity and output compared to a competitor does not mean you are a "tech" company - it means you're better at doing whatever your business is.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoGoogle is a tech company, tech is their core. Or SpaceX. But yes food delivery isn't one. Perhaps if they'd use robots.
- manigandham 9y agoGoogle sells advertising software and people's attention. They also make search software and various other portals that they give away for free. SpaceX builds rockets and sells freight-to-space logistics. We have had rockets for decades, newer tech just make it possible to make better rockets. Google and SpaceX (like every other person and company on the planet) uses technology to create these products and services, but that's it.
- metaphorm 9y agohaving interviewed at Blue Apron, I can confirm that they very much view themselves as a tech company even though they are not really in the tech business space. The level of Google envy I saw at what is essentially an e-commerce grocery store was insane to me.
- psyc 9y agoThere are many companies that just sell software.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoA mistake on one end of the axis (BA is a tech company) doesn't need to be corrected by an outrageous statement on the other end of the axis (there is no such thing as a tech company).
- manigandham 9y agoThere is no other end of the axis. You might as well say an electricity company because they use power to run. Some are more cutting edge with newer tech, but that's making the process and operations better, with their end goal still being the same (whether it's selling software or groceries).
- Helmet 9y agoI agree. While pinpointing the exact definition of a "tech company" is a game of semantics, I think it's pretty clear that they're simply a meal-prep delivery service. Same goes for Casper, which dubs itself a "sleep startup" (whatever the hell that means). They sell and deliver mattresses.