6 ms·
Elon Musk plans to build a Hyperloop himself
- fhood 9y agoI wish I had as much purpose in my life as Elon does.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- snewk 9y agoit’s never too late to start working on whatever it is you feel passionate about
- fhood 9y agoI'm just too much of a coward to commit to something to that degree, so I respect, and to a degree envy, those who can
- dabei 9y agoFor most people who's not a billionaire it's unrealistic to commit to such grand purpose. I believe your ability is not that different from Elon. But given where he is now and the platform he built it's much more in reach for him than for you. So think about what's within reach given your own platform.
- mikekchar 9y agoMy father was a chemistry professor. I always used to go into the lab with him on the weekends when I was a kid. I'd play with spent punch cards, or build things with the carbon-model "tinker toys" while he was working. One day I asked him if he would ever win the Nobel prize. He said, "No. To win the Nobel prize you have to dedicate your life to your work. I'm too busy for that." I asked him what was more important than winning the Nobel prize. He replied (without a pause), "Being a dad." It always stuck with me and given that I always respected my dad, but never did the same things that he did, I never had kids (much to his displeasure). But I will never do anything like winning the Nobel prize either, because I'm also too busy.... with whatever it is that I do :-) If you like what you are doing and believe in it, then that's enough. Really, that's more than enough. But if you are thinking, "You know I'm not so keen on how I spend my time here," then you are in the exceptionally lucky position of not being too busy to do something else! You don't have to commit, just go with the flow.
- am1988 9y agoThat is purpose to your life though. I spend most of my time watching TV and playing games. That's a lack of purpose.
- mikekchar 9y agoNot trying to criticise you, and if I get annoying, please tell me. Your statement is a judgement. Does that judgement come from you, or from somewhere else? I have friends who have chosen to pursue TV and games as their life's purpose. That sounds pretty geeky, but they are totally happy with their choice. Again, from my point of view, it's totally fine if you feel that what you are currently doing is not what you want to be doing. But it makes one wonder, "What do you want to be doing". I don't mean, "What do you want to accomplish in the end" (or more to the point, "What do I want to have done"). I literally mean: "What do you want to do?" - like today. Accomplishments sound awesome. It's tempting to think, "If I did something important, I'd feel satisfied". But it's my experience that people who do impressive things like this are not actually satisfied with the accomplishment. It's not the having, it's the doing that's important to them. As soon as one thing is "done", then it's useless and time to move on to something else. Some people like to have goals -- targets to shoot for. But some people don't like goals. It's not a bad thing. I don't actually know where this saying comes from (I think it might be Buddhist), but it's pretty old: If you keep one eye on the goal, you only have one eye for the path. Especially if the terrain is rough, or you feel afraid, or uncertain, it's totally fine to concentrate on your path (IMHO). Following that path, you will certainly go somewhere, even if you don't know ahead of time where that somewhere is. I hope that gives a different perspective, even if it's not helpful :-)
- am1988 9y ago> Does that judgement come from you yes, and it applies to me.
- imron 9y agoCareful what you wish for - it also comes with terrible lows and unrelenting stress: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/891710778205626368 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/891710778205626368
- tome 9y agoHe's also been divorced thrice, twice from the same woman!
- ashark 9y agoWhy?
- uptown 9y agoElon Musk's ex wife had an interesting write-up on what it takes: https://www.quora.com/How-can-I-be-as-great-as-Bill-Gates-Steve-Jobs-Elon-Musk-or-Sir-Richard-Branson/answer/Justine-Musk?share=1&srid=z5hf https://www.quora.com/How-can-I-be-as-great-as-Bill-Gates-St...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xiphias 9y agoIt's easy, just join one of his companies. Most employees have the same amount of purpose, just the money is unevenly distributed.
- holyjaw 9y agoIs there anyway to disable autoplay videos on bloomberg's website? They're one of the few sites I routinely click through from HN, but the disruption of the autoplay is quite disrespectful, and frankly boils my blood.
- alex_duf 9y agoI usually end-up opening the dev-tools and deleting the html tag...
- mwsfc 9y agoIf using chrome try this extension: Disable HTML5 Autoplay. Works pretty well and real life saver on many "disrespectful" sites.
- ljcn 9y agoBlock scripts at one level or another. On that particular page, it goes assets.bwbx.io -> cdn.gotraffic.net -> imasdk.googleapis.com which introduces some XHR from hopx.cedexis.com and (a subdomain of) akamaihd.net, and the video plays. I love uMatrix.
- petecox 9y agoFirefox: media.autoplay.enabled = false
- to_bpr 9y agoVery interested to see how he/they propose to expedite the boring process.
- wonder_bread 9y agoCan somebody clear this up; is "The Boring Company" it's own entity, or is it a division of Tesla?
- fhood 9y agoThe impression I get from googling it is that it is, in fact, a separate entity from Elon's other venture, or rather as separate as an Elon company can be.
- olegkikin 9y agoThe Boring Company is a separate project from Hyperloop anyway. The plan is to have tunnel networks underground with sleds for cars, not vacuum tubes.
- rory096 9y agoThis is no longer the case. The plans have merged. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/888053175155949572 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/888053175155949572
- rory096 9y agoIt's been wholly funded by SpaceX thus far. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/6kw70z/rspacex_discusses_july_2017_34/dksrrwy/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/6kw70z/rspacex_disc...
- wonder_bread 9y agoThe above helpful comments being said, my question now is, how long is he going to be able to run these companies separately without a shareholder revolt saying they should be put under one roof to create more value for the investors in Tesla? Right now it feels like I'm an unofficial investor in TeSpaceBoringLink as opposed to just the former. I expect to get some hate for the comment as it's a Wall Street type complaint, but to my eye, it seems like these companies are becoming ever more similar.
- newyankee 9y agoAnyone has knowledge about factors other than speed ? Cost per mile improvement, carbon footprint reduction etc. that has been scientifically estimated.
- dispo001 9y agoNot exactly what you asked but this might help http://www.et3.com http://www.et3.com
- newyankee 9y agoIt says 50x , but i am assuming even a 10x improvement in efficiency with the already crazy increases in speed would be great, hopefully with a way to recoup the investment in 20-30 years. Also was wondering whether above ground system is cheaper outside cities than tunneling but i guess they feel that tunneling is cheaper if they get the purported 10x gains they want there
- olegkikin 9y agoEvery estimate I've seen is incredibly idealistic or simply ignores the problems. Safety alone is an incredibly complex issue - the pod travels at high speeds in a tube a few inches from the walls, in vacuum. Any imperfection or leak immediately results in a catastrophe. Even if you somehow manage to stop the pods, how do the people get out? When you start adding all the safety features, the costs grow extremely fast. Hyprerloop is not impossible, just very very expensive to build and to maintain.
- JustAnotherPat 9y agoGlad to see him involved. I think he's earned enough credibility with moving forward battery and electric car technologies so that all can benefit. The current batch of hyperloop startups don't seem all that promising and a potential bunch of patent hoarders.
- simias 9y agoI'm super skeptical about Hyperloop and I was vehemently opposed to "wasting" tax money to build it but I'm pretty happy that he's giving it a try for real, obviously he believes in the project. Hopefully he'll prove naysayers like me wrong and we'll get a kickass futuristic mode of transportation out of it. At least it puts to rest the conspiracy theory that he came up with the Hyperloop concept only to undermine the current bullet train projects . I only hope that if it doesn't pan out it won't hurt his other ventures too much, but I suppose he knows what he's doing.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoHyperloop appears to be a niche solution to a specific transportation situation. It may work (be profitable/useful) for a time between specific destinations. Then the population situation (density, distribution) will change and it will become less profitable or even be discarded. Its not clear that any current pair of cities currently fit the sweet spot for hyperloop. Even if some did, its not clear a hyperloop could be built in time, before the situation changes and they exit the sweet spot. Execution and timing will be especially critical to a successful venture.
- QAPereo 9y agoThere are also very real technical questions to be considered with holding a vacuum over that much pipe, especially when there's gonna be some seismic activity, potential for sabotage etc. I'm not sure that it really is economically viable unless there's some kind of incredibly durable and flexible material to be had which is as easy to use as concrete, about as cheap as concrete, but basically magical spiderwebs.
- kbenson 9y agoIt's not a vacuum, it's a partial vacuum (1 millibar). Apparently that's supposed to make it much easier to achieve with pumps, even with leaks.
- QAPereo 9y agoFor it to be enough of the vacuum to yield real benefits in terms of The fluid dynamics of the air of the tunnel, it needs to be hard enough to be hard to achieve as in this case. It is easier to achieve than the kind of vacuum NASA might want to draw to test devices, or that somebody with a Watt balance might need, but honestly that only goes to show how horrendously difficult it is to pull that kind of vacuum
- kbenson 9y agoThere are plenty of breakdowns of the specific numbers that were given in the proposal. If you know enough to contradict one of those assessments or have enough knowledge of the engineering and current technology required to assess the proposal as a whole, feel free to submit your own numbers or point to the assessment you believe best covers the reality of the situation. Otherwise, definitive statements about small portions of a rather large and complicated proposal that don't provide evidence for their assertions aren't really worth reading. Sorry if that comes across as harsh (it's less directed at you, and more towards the situation as a whole), but this topic is so fraught with people making assertions based on rumors and assumptions rather than the actual data presented that there's a real problem wading through the misinformed to get to the useful information.
- blisterpeanuts 9y agoI love new technology especially when it comes to transportation, but as a people mover this thing seems to have unsolvable problems. You're trapped in a tin can in a vacuum tunnel 20 feet or 50 feet below the surface -- what if it stops? You can't get out. Obviously we put up with a similar predicament in air transportation, and for that matter train derailment and automobile collisions are a real and not uncommon risk of above-ground transportation systems. But Hyperloop has this inherent issue that doesn't have any obvious solution. For transporting goods, it sounds fantastic. Move tons of cargo from SF to LA in 30 minutes, or from D.C. to Boston in 40 minutes. If nothing else, it would be great for USPS and FedEx. If it at least partially relieves the interstates of the stress and damage caused by 18-wheelers, another point in its favor (sorry, drivers).
- aninhumer 9y agoI'm surprised we don't hear more about Japan's Chuo Shinkansen in discussions of Hyperloop: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ch%C5%AB%C5%8D_Shinkansen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ch%C5%AB%C5%8D_Shinkansen It's long distance maglev project that's already under construction, using proven technology, and it aims to cut travel times in half relative to the existing high speed line. I find this project far more exciting than the vague plans and ideas surrounding Hyperloop.
- fhood 9y agoHow well would it work on Mars?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- am1988 9y agoI would think better?
- acjohnson55 9y agoThat technology is only proven because they started working on it about 50 years ago. So, I'm not holding my breath for working Hyperloop installations, but supposing the Hyperloop proves to have fundamental advantages over mag lev (not sure if it does or not, just supposing), then it seems worth pursuing.
- bmcusick 9y agoI love Solar City, Tesla, and SpaceX, but I just don't see Hyperloop/Boring Co as viable or useful. It's true that LA traffic sucks, but the only solution you need is good transit planning with existing technology. Throw in self-driving mini-busses (which I bet Tesla is working on) and you'd never be stuck in traffic again. Tokyo manages a population more than 10x that of L.A. with just good transit planning. The problems with US transit are political. We have political problems that makes building infrastructure cost 10x too much and take 10x too long. Hyperloop can't solve those problems with better engineering. And if we fix those political problems, you don't need Hyperloop.
- Jedd 9y ago> I love Solar City, Tesla, and SpaceX, but I just don't see Hyperloop/Boring Co as viable or useful. This is one of those occasions where a Hacker News appears to think they've thought of something that someone who's been thinking about this stuff for a very long time, and has the money and track record to back it up, disagrees. You seem to have a very narrow view of the technology being proposed - the announcement is about New York to Washington, USA - but presumably this is a proof of concept build with modest scope. > Tokyo manages a population more than 10x that of L.A. .. > ... makes building infrastructure cost 10x too much and take 10x too long. One should be careful with throwing around orders of magnitude claims willy nilly. Tokyo's population is is just shy of 10 million, Los Angeles about 4 million.
- Torai 9y ago> This is one of those occasions where a Hacker News appears to think I would say this is the only occasion that I read people telling others they shouldn't write their critical thinking about an issue because of the person who is behind.
- Jedd 9y agoI regret the tone - I should not have adopted n-gate's vernacular here, though parent's comment is the epitome of what they, and I, find most frustrating about these kinds of seemingly ill-considered, negative HN comments. Parent questioned viability of hyperloop, claimed that transport problems in the USA are due to poor planning and/or politics, and then made up some numbers around population, infrastructure costs and construction times. My point was that Elon Musk thinks this is worth his time to construct. It's possible he, and the people advising him, have not properly thought this through. In TFA there's mention of some concerns by several other startups looking to build Hyperloop systems, who've raised some US$200m. It's possible that they, also, have failed to understand that all the transport problems in the USA could be solved by fixing 'the politics' and that Hyperloop is 'not viable'. But which is more likely?
- falcolas 9y agoThere's still some part of me which wonders if the "Rolling Roads" vision of Heinlein's wouldn't be a better long-term solution (even if requiring much more in terms of space and materials) over rails, the Hyperloop, etc. The concept is effectively a series of moving sidewalk (like you see in airports) loops scaled up to run at 100+ mph, with its own ecosystem of shops, restaurants, inns, etc. They would replace the highways, and be powered by solar panels on the enclosure of the road. Getting on and off is handled by a series of parallel belts which go progressively slower at reasonable increments. No need for "stops" where the entire system must come to a halt to disgorge passengers, no need for negative pressure systems, it could power itself (and surrounding communities)... But the impact of the roads "stopping" would be pretty major and widespread (if mitigable via multiple smaller loops). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Roads_Must_Roll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Roads_Must_Roll
- soyiuz 9y agoI'll be happy with better/cheaper Amtrak service. Nothing beats working at the cafe car and watching the scenery roll by. Plain old rail travel is way too expensive in the US compared to the alternatives (bus or rental). Heck, I'd even be excited about wifi upgrades in the NE corridor.